With 10 new players, seven of whom are freshmen and nine of whom have no Division I experience, it’s reasonable to assume the Pitt men’s basketball team will struggle this season. Anything more specific than that, though? Good luck.

With the team’s season opener against Navy still three days away, it’s still fair (and fun) to speculate about how Pitt may fare this season — not from any concrete standpoint, but rather within a range.

The best case

The Panthers, unfazed as they are inexperienced, get off to a hot start, dispatching a better-than-you-may-expect Navy team in their season opener before ripping through their next three games, highlighted by a win in Brooklyn against a young, talented Penn State team. They lose in the Legends Classic championship to a preseason top-25 team in Texas A&M, but only lose twice more in the nonconference slate, an encouraging home loss against West Virginia in which they stay within two possessions most of the game and an upset loss at home because on a team with so many freshmen, such a setback is bound to happen. In the process, they thump Duquesne and reclaim the City Game trophy.

Advertise with us

Once ACC play arrives, the wins don’t come as frequently, but the signs of progress and promise are plentiful. Pitt wins the games in which it has the best chance to win — Boston College, N.C. State, and at Clemson — and pulls off a handful of surprises elsewhere, winning at Florida State and at home against Georgia Tech. At 6-12 in conference, Pitt wins one game in the ACC tournament and Kevin Stallings finishes in the top three of ACC coach of the year voting. At least one freshman — we’ll say Marcus Carr — makes the ACC all-rookie team while Jared Wilson-Frame, the team’s leading scorer, narrowly misses out on making the all-league second team. They are, in effect, what Georgia Tech was the previous year — a team from which nobody expected anything, only for it to excel.

The Panthers narrowly qualify for the NIT, where they lose their first game. But with a core of Wilson-Frame, Carr, Shamiel Stevenson and Parker Stewart, the last three of whom are freshmen, there is legitimate hope heading into the 2018-19 season, particularly with some promising incoming players and the eligibility of an almost certain starter in Malik Ellison.

Record: 17-17 (6-12 ACC)

The worst case

The team’s widespread inexperience is palpable from the opening tip of the first game. The Panthers lose handily to Navy to start the season, are shocked in their home opener by Montana and drop both of their games in Brooklyn to fall to 1-4. They rebound with back-to-back wins before falling for the second-consecutive year to Duquesne in the City Game. Eight days later, they’re drubbed at home by West Virginia, losing by 30. To wrap up non-conference play, they’re caught looking ahead to ACC play and are surprised at home by Towson and former Pitt assistant Pat Skerry.

Advertise with us

Once conference play begins, the challenges they face only become clearer and more painful. They’re whipped by the league’s top teams — never coming within 15 of Duke, Miami, Louisville or North Carolina, the last of which is led by 30 points from former Panther Cam Johnson in a thundering win — and can’t get over the hump against some of the more beatable opponents. Through it all, former Pitt standouts (think Levance Fields during last season’s 55-point loss to Louisville) take to social media frequently to voice their displeasure at how far the program has fallen.

By the end of the season, they become just the second ACC team since 1987 to go winless in conference play. None of the team’s freshmen earn all-rookie honors, and while some of them put up respectable numbers, they do so incredibly inefficiently on perhaps the worst offensive team in major college basketball. Dismayed by what faces them, one or two of the more promising youngsters transfer and Stallings enters Year Three of his Pitt tenure on one of the hottest seats in the conference.

Record: 6-26 (0-18 ACC)

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG