Heavy metal music blares as Mike Grimm — “Michael” to his mom, sister and grandma — saunters through Jezioro’s gym in Bethel Park on a Friday night, tattoos covering large swaths of his 6-foot-6, 372-pound body. His girlfriend, Casey, works out nearby and the two talk shop in between sets.

Just a few miles down the road is the high school football field where he used to dominate, an uber-imposing offensive lineman whose size and strength attracted college scholarship offers across the country. He chose Pitt, the place he still calls his “dream school” nearly a year after walking away from his sport and into a new, even more appropriate venture: powerlifting, a sport in which participants lift as much weight as possible for just one repetition.

A 2014 graduate of Bethel Park, Grimm, 21, spent three seasons on the Pitt football team, but the one-time four-star recruit under former coach Paul Chryst never played. Highly touted as he was, he redshirted as a freshman, then Chryst left for Wisconsin and coach Pat Narduzzi took over. Grimm also didn’t see the field the next year and lost his entire third season to injury.

Michael Grimm transitions from football to powerlifting

Grimm tore the labrum in his left hip, and after a surgery in which the labrum had to be repaired and his hip socket shaved, he was on bed rest for nine days with little to do but think. Think about what would come next in his football career, think about his friends and teammates, and think about his path. When he had one last meeting with Narduzzi this past January, the writing was on the wall.

Advertise with us

“I didn’t just go into that meeting like, ‘All right, well I’m done. Bye,’ ” the intimidating but affable Grimm recalled recently. “I thought long and hard.”

But just like that, Grimm’s football life was over. He left the program, and his name would be lumped in with several others about a month later when Narduzzi announced his offseason departures.

Mike Grimm goes through a practice during his senior year at Bethel Park. (Michael Henninger / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Suddenly, he was a regular Pitt student with all sorts of free time. In August, he graduated with a bachelor’s degree in administrative justice, and he’s now a sales associate for Webster’s Fitness Products by day. By night, he’s chasing a powerlifting dream that technically began with a meet last April, but really long before that.

“Michael was 2 or 3 months old in a baby carriage hanging on the lat pulldown,” says his mom, Nanette, a personal trainer herself who made the lifestyle an “in my blood kind of thing” for her son.

Even while playing football, Grimm always looked forward to the offseason. Sure, he loved the thrill of gameday, but once the games were done, that meant more time in the weight room.

Advertise with us

He’s spending more time there now than ever. In August, in his second official competition, all he did to mark the occasion was break three world records for the International Powerlifting Association. Grimm’s 740-pound deadlift and 1,840-pound three-lift total (squat, bench-press and deadlift) still rank No. 1 among the super-heavyweight category of raw junior amateurs, men aged 20-23 who weigh more than 308 pounds and are natural, as in drug-tested.

Grimm’s ultimate goal is to eventually become the strongest man in the world, while steering clear of extra supplements and steroids.

“Aw, absolutely,” Grimm says with a grin. “I mean, why would you not try to get to the top?”

While Grimm acknowledges that his newfound love for powerlifting has helped fill the void of football, he insists he doesn’t derive much motivation from never living up to outside expectations. He just thinks about trying to be the best.

Asked if he lost his love for football, he pauses and says he has to think about that, settling on an answer of “yes and no.” He notes the toll it took on his body, then gives a self-aware chuckle because his new mission is trying to lift thousands of pounds in a day instead.

Advertise with us

“For me, being mediocre, being average was never an option,” says Grimm, who was 200 pounds by fourth grade and an even 6 feet by sixth grade. “Especially because I’ve never looked average, so why would I carry on a life that was average?”

The “average” thing to do when he fell behind on the depth chart at Pitt might have been to transfer. He admits the thought crossed his mind but claims he never seriously considered it. As he figured, it would just be an excuse, and most of his teammates had gone through plenty of adversity, too. Plus he went to Pitt for an education, not just football.

But those same teammates are what make Grimm most nostalgic. There’s the sleeve on his arm, completed by the tattoo artist referred to him by veteran upperclassmen J.P. Holtz and Darryl Render. There’s the occasional pain in his knees from constant beatings by the quick hands and powerful thighs of defensive end Ejuan Price, who was as relentless in practice as he was in games.

Still on the team now, there’s Chris Clark and Colton Lively, his workout buddies when all three were hurt last season. There’s George Aston, who can confidently assume the mantle of strongest on the Pantehrs, now that Grimm’s gone. And most of all, there’s Mike Herndon, the do-anything lineman who was Grimm’s best friend and roommate since they were freshmen, since the day Grimm walked into their dorm room with a 5-inch Mohawk and started pounding on the door because his key was stuck.

“I can’t believe I didn’t scare him away,” Grimm remembers.

Advertise with us
Mike Grimm poses for a portrait before his senior season at Bethel Park, with a mohawk that would get much bigger by the time he enrolled at Pitt. (Michael Henninger / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

He gets downright wistful thinking about that first year, he and Herndon going everywhere as a pair, from class to practice and eventually to their off-campus apartment they shared until this past July. Even living together, they didn’t see each other all that much once Grimm left the team.

“I mean, that’s who I thought about. That’s what I wrestled with,” Grimm says. “We literally did everything together, and you know, obviously he’s busy doing his thing, but it kinda sucks for me.”

Grimm still keeps in touch with his “brothers” now and again, be it through social media or phone calls or text messages, and they think about him, too. Redshirt junior guard Alex Bookser was asked if he stays in contact with former linemates Dorian Johnson and Adam Bisnowaty, both in the NFL, as well as Grimm.

“Yeah, I try to. All three of ’em are doing great,” Bookser said, “especially Mike. His new love of weightlifting — well, not new, he’s always been into it, but he’s excelling at what he’s doing right now. Miss him a lot.”

Perhaps it’s inconsequential whether Grimm left football or football left him. In April, he’ll have his next meet, another couple of tons to push, press and pull. Until then, he’ll go to the gym and lose himself in the heavy metal and the heavier iron, maybe thinking about what could’ve been and once was, but maybe not.

Advertise with us

“I found a new path, and I think it’s the path that fits me the best,” Grimm says, then laughs. “I mean, I’ll always have two years of eligibility left. I could go back when I’m 30 or something. I guess we’ll see.”

Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.