Brian Batko: Hello, all. Another week, another Pitt game to preview, and this time it's Duke on the road Saturday in Durham, N.C. I will be there. Chat begins now.
SOMDPanther: HCPN was noticeably disgruntled in his press conference when talking about his QB decisions. From my angle it seems like his reasoning in playing Pickett for the garbage time snap against Cuse and some against NCSU (i.e. we was the #3 QB and we need 2 QBs ready to go at all times), is entirely a form over substance argument. My question is: Do you think that we will ever get down to 1 QB this season? Or is this just a going to be matter of getting Pickett ready for next year?
Brian Batko: Good afternoon, SOMD, thanks for stopping as always. Narduzzi wasn't necessarily in a bad mood Monday, but "disgruntled" is as good a word as any to use as far as his quarterback discussion. "Form over substance argument" is a bit too lawyerly for me, but to answer your question, no, I don't think a clear leader will emerge by the end of 2017 and into 2018. But I think if it's either guy, it'll be Kenny Pickett, if only because he's coming from behind in the competition, so to speak.
Pitt linebacker Oluwaseun Idowu previews Duke
Ed M: What to you think it will take Pitt to become athletically competitive in the ACC? Is Pitt in the wrong conference sportswise? It's very frustrating week after week, year after year.
Brian Batko: Coaches. Look what Pitt men's soccer is doing in Year 2 under Jay Vidovich, as told so wonderfully by my beat partner Craig Meyer http://www.post-gazette.com/sports/Pitt/2017/10/16/Coach-Jay-Vidovich-...
That's a problem that was languishing to such extent that people wondered if it would ever get right. But I think it's a prime example that if you get the right coach, he/she will either win enough to help recruiting, or recruit/find the right players to help you win. I definitely don't believe the ACC is the wrong league for Pitt, because where else would you want to be? The American Athletic? Please.
Read More
Maximus: Seems like the loss of Wirginis has really hurt us but goes under the radar. Your thoughts ?
Brian Batko: Hundred percent, Maximus. Good observation by you. It's probably gone under the radar a bit because every time I tried to ask a coach or player about it preseason or early in the year, they brushed it off by saying something along the lines of "We're focused on who we have." Well, who you have isn't nearly as experienced or as productive as a three-year contributor in Quintin Wirginis. Would he be a cure-all for this run defense? Probably not, but you have to think he'd be able to help up the middle, and also maybe even occasionally get to the QB, as had been a strong suit of his in the past.
BigPitt: Narduzzi able to get some highly rated DBs in his first few classes because of his defensive reputation. Now that he’s thrown that reputation out the window with heir defensive performance on the field, how does he get talented DL to commit to Pitt. I believe Pitt DL deficiencies are root cause for their issues on D.
Brian Batko: Greetings, BP. I won't go so far as to say he's thrown his reputation out the window. All that stuff at Michigan State, all those accomplishments, did they get vacated by the NCAA for some reason? Pretty sure that all still happened. As far as the DL recruiting though, I think you have to be encouraged there. DL coach Charlie Partridge, with deep Florida ties, might just be the best recruiter on Pitt's staff, and DL might just be the stronger area of the 2018 class so far. I happen to think Thomas Jefferson's Devin Danielson is Pitt's best get to this point, his teammate Noah Palmer and DeMatha's John Morgan seem like promising edge rushers, and then when you throw in the possibility that Butler standout Jake Kradel might be a DT in college, there's some intrigue there.
Pitt Meister: Do you think Ian Troost kneeling during the national anthem is a team distraction? Personally, I do not. He has his reasons and has clearly stated them. I think all Pitt fans should kneel during the national anthem to protest the injustice of being subjected to the bad football coaching and play this season!
Brian Batko: Thanks for the Q, Meister. My A is: Yes and no. I think it is a little bit of a distraction, simply because it's one more thing a few players and coaches have had to address, but it's not a huge deal. As the second part of your statement there suggests, if anything, distracting fans from this season might not be a bad thing.
I also tend to agree with you in terms of Troost's explanation to Craig Meyer last night (if you didn't read it: http://www.post-gazette.com/sports/Pitt/2017/10/17/Pitt-kicker-Ian-Tro...). I'm about as apolitical as it gets, so without injecting my own opinion into it, it seems like Troost handled this hot-button topic about as well as possible.
Mikey T: Where was the fan attendance last weekend? It has to be hurting recruiting! Homecoming, free bobbleheads, discounted tickets, a beautiful day with no other pro sports games happening and the place was empty.
Brian Batko: Hey Mikey, it's tough when you're 2-4 (which Pitt as entering its homecoming game). Even with all those factors you mentioned, factors that I bet still brought some people to the stadium who otherwise wouldn't have gone, it's not a good product right now. And as we all well know, at least I hope, this program doesn't have that huge number of supporters who stick through thick and thin no matter what's happening in the W-L column. It is what it is, and that's kind of the constant goal for Pitt football, to build that base, right?
Blawnox Panther: What happened last week in the 2nd half of the game? Pitt choked again and lost the game on all fronts.
Brian Batko: Blawnox, you just reminded me, maybe that particular game would've been RIPE for Sweet Caroline going into the fourth quarter!
H2P333: Do you think the "young" excuse is played? Half of the teams in the country are young. Penn State was young last year and improved over the course of the season to 10-3 and a Big Ten championship! Pitt should be able to do the same.
Brian Batko: I do think it's played out a bit, yes. And I don't really think the players and coaches are clinging to that all that much at this point of the season. Linebacker Sean Idowu even said today that at seven games in, you can't keep saying you're young. Time for that youth to make strides.
JScass: Where were the Pitt students going? It was a 7-point game and the start of the 4th and the students are leaving?!?!?! Unacceptable. Other programs do not have this problem, why does Pitt?
Brian Batko: Not enough free beverages?
Pope: Don't you think Pickett should start? He is the future. This season is over and highly doubtful we make a bowl game. So, Pitt will lose that extra practice time. Pickett might as well get as many touches now to prepare for next year, right?
Brian Batko: The topic du jour, Pope. I do not think Kenny Pickett should start. As I said last week, I haven't changed my stance that I'm not ready to throw in the towel on Ben DiNucci just yet. Didn't think he was all that good, didn't think he was all that bad last week against a really tough N.C. State defense. It's a fluid situation, and I'm not anti-Pickett either, but just not sure we've seen enough of DiNucci to this point. Last I checked, they'll both need "to prepare for next year."
Pitt Guru: Do you believe that local recruiting has gotten WORSE with Narduzzi? Sure, he gets the 2-3 stars that most of the top programs have not offered. One 4-star recruit in each class is NOT going to make the grade and get Pitt to the next level.
Brian Batko: In a sense, maybe. Dave Wannstedt was really good locally, but the WPIAL was also producing more talent at that time. How can you fault Narduzzi for getting Jordan Whitehead, Damar Hamlin and Paris Ford to enroll in his first three classes? This year's class is a bit tricky to judge. How much do you criticize the staff for missing on Phil Jurkovec? Lifelong Notre Dame fan, committed way early, but still, isn't that part of the challenge of recruiting is changing kids' minds one way or the other? Beyond him, though, Pitt has landed almost anyone and everyone it's coveted from the WPIAL. We'll see what happens with Aliquippa's Kwantel Raines.
Pope: What is your revised season prediction? I originally had Pitt at 6-6, but now I am saying 4-8 w losses to Duke, Va Tech and Miami.
Brian Batko: I originally said 7-5, so I'm still alive! But yeah, obviously things look bleak. I'll say 4-8 as well, but it certainly wouldn't surprise me if a ninth loss finds this team somewhere the rest of the way.
gary@northernVirginia: Brian...I'm still a Narduzzi supporter, but I really question his handling of QB's, even going back to Voytik. That turned out well, but doesn't his constant juggling of the position hurt when trying to recruit top flight QB's?
Brian Batko: Gary, I agree that it's maybe his most glaring weakness thus far, his impulsiveness when it comes to that position. Maybe impulsiveness isn't the right word, but he sure seems fickle this season. He and his assistants get paid handsomely to persuade recruits and their parents that their son is the right fit and will thrive at Pitt. I wouldn't say they're putting themselves in that big of a hole because of the QB situation this year.
OHIO412FAN: Well, it certainly looks like it’s not Pitts year. With the odds of not making the bowl season, what can Pitt do to improve their program all around moving forward in the long term future?
Brian Batko: More bobbleheads!
Harley's WPIAL Wedge: Is it at all short sighted not to be recruiting any additional RB's this year, and to have put all their eggs in the basket of Cole Beck?
Brian Batko: Too early to say Pitt won't add an RB in this class. Could be a lot of moving parts behind the scenes, whether with high school kids or JuCos, plus you never know when a grad transfer might hit the market. Although despite the running struggles this season, all five scholarship tailbacks are currently expected back next year...
Brian Batko: It's 2:30, my usual chat-quittin' time, but let's keep going.
Matt N.: What up Bri-dog? Sorry, that was sassy for no reason. What does your eye-test tell you about Dinucci vs Pickett vs MacVittie? Who has the most raw talent, best arm, the most moxie, poise, 'it' factor, etc.?
Brian Batko: Hi, Matt. Not sassy at all. I liked it. As I stated above, my eye isn't looking down all that much on DiNucci or Pickett so far. Need to see more from both.
McD: What in the heck is going on?
Brian Batko: No idea.
Geoff Ferruzza: I'm a Notre Dame fan at heart so I hope Jurkovec leads them to 4 National Titles, but do u see any chance he could possibly flip to Pitt at last second?? Thanks
Brian Batko: Not unless something happens with Brian Kelly, and even then, I highly doubt it.
M96: I'd like to see Ben DiNucci or Kenny Pickett take a knee with less than a minute to go in the 4th quarter.
Brian Batko: I think they would, too.
Andy: Brian I enjoy reading the chats each week. There is a lot of hype around Paris Ford (possibly the second coming of Darrelle Revis???). I know Pitt will not be competing for a major bowl or anything but why not play him and let him get experience. If he is really that good 3 or 4 years from now he will leave for the NFL draft anyways and not use all of his eligibility (if he is redshirted he will only play 2 or 3 years). If you play him now you may be able to use his 4 years of eligibility. If he is still here as a 5th year senior he probably was not as good as all the hype around him or he got hurt. i say play him and let him develop with others in the secondary.
Brian Batko: Whoa Andy, let's not get too far ahead of ourselves here with the Revis comparison. Let's let Paris play a college game first. I'm on record saying Pitt should use him, and I'm not flip-flopping on that even with (likely) only five games left. By now, it doesn't seem that Pitt greatly needs him in the secondary, but give him a chance to do something. Cover a kick, a punt, put him back there on a return with Quadree Henderson, just something.
Dave: Shouldn't the Panthers defense perform very well against a dink and dunk slowish Devil offense?
Brian Batko: Oh yes Dave, it should. Duke has really had problems scoring this year. But will Pitt's run defense be up to the task? I will write about that tomorrow, my friend.
NC Ken: I'd love to know (ask the staff) why Henderson is never thrown anything past the line of scrimmage (that isn't working.) RaRa finds the seam regularly. Having Henderson catch a pass just 5 yards downfield while moving downfield will allow him to do his thing without facing the stacked box. Thoughts?
Brian Batko: Ken, I don't think it's by design. Perhaps QH's route-running isn't quite where it needs to be just yet. Certainly, Lopes has outperformed him as a wideout. One play I remember specifically was at Syracuse when Henderson did get (way) past the line of scrimmage, and when the quarterback looked his way, he fell down. Something's not clicking there for him as a pass-catcher.
Panther MBA: Do you know why Moss was suspended?
Brian Batko: I do not.
Jeff: At this point, when HCPN talks QB's, he doesn't mention McVittie by name and he appears to be an afterthought as a QB, playing special teams. Although DiNucci has been given playing time, he's yet to see a full game in his career, having been pulled in every game he's started. The staff clearly doesn't think DiNucci is a long term answer.
With the way that he has handled DiNucci and McVittie over their careers, do you think we should worry about one of them transferring?
Brian Batko: Jeff, I'd say that's always a question to ask in this landscape of college sports. Especially at a position like QB where if you're blocked, you're pretty much injury insurance. Haven't heard anything about one of those two in particular going elsewhere, but you never know.
Panther MBA: I agree with Mikey T. Why would a top notch recruit want to play at 1/2 empty heinz field when they could play at Rocking Beaver Stadium or WVU?
Brian Batko: Maybe because they like Pitt's coaching staff, like the city, see a path to playing time, grew up a Panthers fan, etc. etc.
Terry: As the secondary has improved a ton this season i feel as if the rush defense has not improved to the level I thought it would especially the D-line thoughts?
Brian Batko: Youthful faces there still struggling to generate consistent pressure. Dewayne Hendrix, Rashad Weaver or both might be close to breaking through, though. Granted, that's not the first time I've written that.
DiNucci, Pickett discuss quarterback situation
Salma Hayek: Hi Brian...great chat
Brian Batko: Thanks, love your work
Jacob Johnson: Will Pitt make a bowl game this year? They would have to win out I'd imagine
Brian Batko: Actually, Pitt could still lose even this weekend and still have a chance at 6-6. Then, they'd have to win out. UNLESS ... they could be one of those 5-7 teams that make it because of a good APR score or something. Pipe dreams...
Andy: do you think whitehead will be back next year?
Brian Batko: I'm leaning no...
Larry: Why not play the nickel more? The dime package simply is not working when they load the box and go four wide.
Brian Batko: Pitt's been playing five DBs a lot more lately, starting with the Syracuse game.
Andrew: Is it possible the running games isn't working because they don't ever seem to give one guy more than ten carries to get into the flow of the game?
Brian Batko: I wouldn't rule it out, but the O-line of course needs to get some push, too. It's a bit shocking to me that this position group has been such a disappointment, the backs, I mean. I was high on the group coming into the year and thought any number of them could have a huge season. And as it turns out, not one is...
Alex Ovechkin: Who is the national champion this year? And will I finally win the SC?
Brian Batko: Bama. And yes, sure, you will. I know nothing about hockey.
NC Ken: The D has 31 guys on the two deep; 2 seniors, 14 freshman, 6 sophs. I think they are playing better than last year's D, and they have far less experience. They will be pretty good next year. The offense is the issue going forward. Do you agree?
Brian Batko: For the most part, yes. Some positive signs defensively, no doubt about it. But there seems to be some serious soul-searching to do on the other side of the ball.
Pitt Jim: Is Franklin a better coach then Coach Narduzzi? I know a lot of Pitt faithful make fun of Franklin as being a cheerleader, but he seems to be doing a great job in the W column and in recruiting.
Brian Batko: Don't forget, people (read: Terry Bradshaw) called Mike Tomlin a cheerleader, too. And I happen to think Mike Tomlin is a heckuva coach. As for Franklin vs. Narduzzi, well, the overall results of this season and last are difficult to dispute, aren't they?
pete: how many staff changes do you forsee after this disaster of a season? also,curious what you thought about Dabo going into Cuse locker room- I thought it was really out of bounds and he needs to worry about his own team that he obviously didn't have prepared to play!
Brian Batko: Pete, I didn't see that from Dabo, but everything I heard/read after that game was about how classy he was and how well he took the loss. As for staff changes, dosen't do anyone much good to speculate on that. Narduzzi has been pretty loyal to his guys, though, since getting to Pitt.
Matt N.: Also, how is it that Watson, who was demoted in-season by Charlie Strong -- during a bad Texas year -- becomes our first choice to replace Matt Canada? Watson runs a 1970s high school offense that is so predictable you can set your watch to it...run up the gut, run up the gut, pass on third and long, punt...repeat.
Brian Batko: Narduzzi and Watson go way back, so the head coach obviously felt comfortable with his new OC and vice versa. If Matt Canada this season and the past two has taught us anything, it might be that a coordinator is only as good as his players. And Matt Canada had some very good players last year at Pitt.
gary@northernVirginia: I saw a comment on another site that said that Pitt's expectations in both football and basketball should be to emulate Virginia Tech and Virginia, good programs that from time to time break into the top 10. That does sound realistic, don't you think?
Brian Batko: That doesn't sound like a bad goal at all. VT appears to have excellent coaches in both sports in Buzz Williams and Justin Fuente. Obviously, Frank Beamer's stability was/is huge. As for UVA, things are kinda one-sided there right now in terms of hoops success. Good start for Bronco Mendenhall and the football side so far in 2017, but they're a long way from being a program that breaks into the Top 10. Let's have the Cavs crack the Top 25, first.
pete: so you think its ok for a coach to violate another teams space and just prance in? can you imagine any coach doing that(saban,noll,ditka etc)? you give your congrats on the field
Brian Batko: I said I didn't hear about it/read it/see it, pete, gimme a break!
Foolback: Brian: Who
Brian Batko: ... T and the Blowfish?
Foolback: Brian: Are the offensive line issues simply talent, or cohesiveness? I really expected them to be strength this year, especially in the running game.
Brian Batko: Cohesiveness, or lack there of, might be an underrated aspect of it. While three starters came back, one moved from RT to LT (Brian O'Neill) and another (Alex Bookser) has played both RT and RG quite extensively this year. And then in the middle it's an entirely new face at center in redshirt freshman Jimmy Morrissey. We knew the unit would be in flux somewhat, but figured the talent would overcome those changes.
Bean: Does Pitt gets its first ACC win this weekend against a top 20 D and it’s best asset being able to stop the run? Can the Pitt offense finally do enough to get a win?
Brian Batko: That's the big question, isn't it Bean? Someone asked earlier if Ian Troost's protest is a distraction, but I don't think it's nearly as distracting to the team as the constant QB changes. To a man, every player says it doesn't matter to them and it's not their call, but I don't buy that. It has to be strange to not know who's coming into the huddle until they actually come into the huddle. Maybe this will be the week one separates from the other?
pete: why cant you give an answer-it happened-stay informed- tell narduzzi he should go in the duke locker room and give cutcliffe big hugs regardless of the result!
Brian Batko: OK, I will attempt to be better informed about Clemson-Syracuse games moving forward.
Brian Batko: Er, the postgame happenings of Clemson-Syracuse matchups.
SOP2017: What is your prediction for the Duke game this weekend?
Brian Batko: I will end the chat as I do most other weeks, with my FEARLESS prediction. Call it bold, but I'm taking Pitt to win on the road this week at Duke. Not ready to say the offense will turn the corner, though, so I guess I'll go with something like 17-14. one week after Florida State beat Duke, 17-10.
Brian Batko: Thanks for the participation, everyone, have a great night and rest of the week.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.