As the losses pile up for Pitt football, the problems stay the same. All that really changes is the opponent and the day.

And the quarterback.

Pitt lost to No. 20 N.C. State, 35-17, on homecoming Saturday at Heinz Field, but fans of quarterback controversies won big. Coach Pat Narduzzi started redshirt sophomore Ben DiNucci, then pivoted to freshman Kenny Pickett for a crucial possession late in the third quarter. Pickett handed off twice, then threw an incomplete pass, forcing a punt. N.C. State scored on the ensuing possession and never looked back.

The Wolfpack (6-1, 4-0 ACC) won for the sixth time in a row, beating a Pitt team now off to its worst start since 2001 — that much was predictable.

Advertise with us

But with Pitt trailing, 21-14, late in the third quarter, Narduzzi benched DiNucci, who managed to do enough to keep the Panthers (2-5, 0-3) within striking distance of a Top 20 team. He turned to Pickett for what amounted to his first live action at the college level, save for the final play last week at Syracuse.

“It wasn’t taking Ben out because he wasn’t getting the job done,” Narduzzi insisted postgame. “I think Ben had four series in the second half and Kenny had three. We wanted to work it.”

Pat Narduzzi on Pitt's loss to N.C. State

And yet, it’s hard not to wonder if the sudden shuffle put both quarterbacks in a bad spot. Pickett was asked to come in and lead a rally, just as DiNucci was in previous weeks when replacing now-injured Max Browne, and DiNucci had perhaps shown some signs of promise.

What the former Pine-Richland High School star didn’t show after the game was an understanding that he was on such a leash.

“A little bit surprised, yeah,” said DiNucci, who was 19 of 32 for 170 yards with a touchdown, an interception and a lost fumble when he tagged back in for the final drive with the game out of reach. “I wasn’t necessarily aware going into this week that they were gonna try to get him series, but that’s ultimately their decision, so the only thing I can do is respect it and try to help him out as much as possible.”

Advertise with us

Narduzzi said he and offensive coordinator/​quarterbacks coach Shawn Watson spoke to both players pregame about the plan. In fact, Narduzzi said he wanted to use Pickett in the first half, but that DiNucci was playing well, so he stayed in.

Pitt quarterback Ben DiNucci postgame N.C. State

“The communication was done prior to the game,” Narduzzi said. “And I know it doesn’t make anybody happy, either. I’m sure Ben would like to have had those three series back, too, and you can look back and forth, but that’s what we decided to do.”

For as messy as it got, things couldn’t have started much better for DiNucci and the Panthers, who struck first on their second drive. Jester Weah shook his defender to get wide open, and DiNucci dropped a 33-yard pass softly into his arms for a touchdown to make it 7-0 with 5:05 left in the first quarter.

But when the two teams came out for the second half tied at 14, DiNucci tossed an interception on the third play of the third quarter, and after both sides exchanged punts twice more, N.C. State pulled back in front. Then, it was Pickett time — later than expected for Narduzzi, and for DiNucci, not expected much at all.

“I didn’t know anything about it going in beforehand, so I was a little caught off-guard,” DiNucci said. “But that happens. It’s football, so gotta roll with it. … The biggest thing for me, or whoever else is gonna be in the saddle, is just control what you can control. I can’t make decisions for coach Watson and coach Narduzzi. I’ll leave that up to them, and I’m gonna worry about trying to put points on the board when I’m on the field.”

Advertise with us

Pickett finished 5 of 13 for 61 yards, with three of those completions going for first-downs to Weah, who had seven receptions for 106 yards and the score, but was again plagued by drops. Neither signal-caller had much help from the ground game, as Pickett’s four carries for 18 yards tied Jordan Whitehead for the team lead, so a quarterback and safety contributed most to Pitt’s 95 yards rushing.

N.C. State running back Nyheim Hines ran wild, scoring on an 83-yard run and a 92-yard punt return on back-to-back touches in the first quarter. In the second half, the Wolfpack pulled away as Pitt slipped ever closer to a forgettable season that might soon have more starting quarterbacks than victories.

“I’m not gonna comment on that,” DiNucci said when asked if he thinks he’ll start again next week at Duke. “I’ve done that before [after the Georgia Tech game] and it’s bit me in the behind a little bit. … I don’t think I necessarily did anything to lose the job.

“Coaches have kinda said they burned [Pickett’s] redshirt last week, so they’re gonna try to work him in a little bit. That’s fine, that’s their decision, I’ll live with that. But whoever’s out there first next week is gonna try to do the same thing that the other guy’s doing: Just lead the team to a win.”

Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.