SYRACUSE, N.Y. — Saying Pitt’s trip to Upstate New York was a “must-win” game might be a bit dramatic, but it certainly seemed like it could represent a crossroads at the midpoint of the season.

It was just a matter of which way the Panthers would go, and they went further down the conference standings in a season of “worsts” under coach Pat Narduzzi.

As the defense tried to cover for an anemic offense for the second time in as many ACC matchups, and couldn’t do so nearly enough in the second half, Syracuse sent Pitt to a 27-24 loss Saturday at Carrier Dome.

The Panthers (2-4) now are 0-2 in the ACC for the first time since Narduzzi arrived, off to their worst start in conference play and overall since 2012, when they were in the Big East Conference and coached by Paul Chryst. That also was the previous time they lost to Syracuse (3-3, 1-1).

Advertise with us

“It’s 22 guys. It’s our football team,” Narduzzi said after the game. “We win together, we lose together and we stick together.”

Pitt’s rout of Rice last week was good for a breather of sorts, but as the Panthers jumped back into the ACC, many of the same issues present two weeks ago at Georgia Tech cropped up again.

Pat Narduzzi breaks down Pitt's loss at Syracuse

Quarterback Max Browne and his receivers found occasional success against Syracuse’s secondary, until Browne left the game with an injury in the third quarter and gave way to backup Ben DiNucci. To make a long story short about the run game, here’s a stat that says a lot: For the second consecutive week, Pitt’s leading rusher was Jordan Whitehead, a safety. Whitehead even scored the first touchdown for the Panthers, a 35-yard scamper on the first play of the second quarter that made it 7-3.

But that early lead was gone by halftime, as Syracuse quarterback Eric Dungey hit Devin Butler for a 32-yard touchdown with 34 seconds left before the break to make it 10-10. And yet, holding the uptempo Orange offense to just two scores after last year’s 76-61 victory was about as much as you could ask for — maybe more — as Pitt eschewed its base 4-3 defense for an extra defensive back from the start.

The gates opened from there, as Dungey scored on a 10-yard keeper to make it 17-13 midway through the third, then found Steve Ishmael for a 35-yard touchdown for a 27-16 lead. That came a few minutes after Pitt kicker Alex Kessman tied a school record and broke the Carrier Dome mark with a 56-yard field goal on the first play of the fourth.

Advertise with us

“Don’t point any fingers,” Narduzzi said was the message to his team. “We all had a hand in it as coaches and as players. They’re probably going to be real sick to their stomach when they watch the tape on Sunday, because you left a lot of plays on the field.”

Finally, Pitt’s offense managed to get 6 without Whitehead, as starting running back Qadree Ollison found some room and took off for a 19-yard score with 7:15 left. Whitehead came back in to rush for the 2-point conversion and cut Syracuse’s lead to 27-24.

When Syracuse got the ball back, though, it ate up more than six minutes by gaining 74 yards over 15 plays to drive to Pitt’s 5. That left just 52 seconds for DiNucci to go 95 yards with one timeout, and he didn’t even come close to engineering a miracle. The last-ditch effort ended with a thud, as he was sacked so hard that his helmet came off and Narduzzi chose to insert freshman Kenny Pickett, burning his redshirt season for the final play.

Hits on a quarterback costing the Panthers became a theme of the day, as one of the most regrettable plays of the game came after a third-down stop on Syracuse’s opening drive in the second half. On an incompletion, redshirt freshman backup linebacker Chase Pine drilled Dungey in the chest well after the throw and got flagged for roughing the passer. That extended the possession, and Dungey made Pitt pay with a 10-yard touchdown run to make it 17-13.

“Unacceptable,” Narduzzi called it.

Advertise with us

On the ensuing Pitt drive, it was another shot on a quarterback — this time a legal one, this time Pitt’s — that put the Panthers in a bad spot. Browne, who was 15 of 22 for 161 yards, was sacked as he tried to throw and fumbled. Matt Flanagan recovered for Pitt, but Browne lay on the turf nursing his right arm and went to the locker room, forcing not just a third-and-long but also a quarterback change.

With Browne expected to be out at least a couple of weeks, it’s back to the drawing board at quarterback and everywhere else. Narduzzi let his frustration show at the end of his news conference when asked an innocuous question about how he would rate his front seven.

“We lost, so, nothing’s good enough,” he said. “So how do I rate it? You want me to give you A, B or C, or you want me to give you 1, 2 or 3?”

“A, B, or C,” the reporter replied.

“C,” Narduzzi shot back, and with that, he was gone.

Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.