Pitt is in a no-win situation with graduate transfer Cameron Johnson.
Grant his unconditional release to ACC foe North Carolina and it only hurts coach Kevin Stallings and the Panthers. Johnson, an Our Lady of Sacred Heart graduate who was set to be Pitt’s top returning scorer next season, will instead play for the Tar Heels immediately with two seasons of eligibility remaining. In all likelihood, he’ll help the defending national champions rip Stallings’ rebuilding Pitt team limb from limb in that time. This is obviously bad for Pitt, and it’s generally bad for competition for a power program like North Carolina to be able to poach a player recruited and developed by a weaker conference opponent so easily.
Continue to fully or partially block his transfer, a move Johnson is now contesting after officially committing to North Carolina Tuesday, and Pitt will be swamped with grandstanding headlines borne of moralizing media groupthink calling it “vindictive” or “petty” for protecting its own interests at the expense of Johnson’s.
The NCAA shouldn’t put these decisions about release into the hands of the schools for exactly this reason. The interests of the athlete and the interests of the schools will always be at odds in situations like these. So this is a conflict major college sports’ governing body should have figured out long ago.
Should a graduate student be allowed to transfer his athletic eligibility to any school in the country, without restriction? Or is it anti-competitive for a player to be able to transfer within a conference or to a scheduled opponent of the school he’s leaving?
This space tends to side with the point of view that such behavior is anti-competitive; that unchecked graduate transfers put us on the road to the best programs always ending up with the best talent without having to put in any of the work to recruit or develop it. It’s not a popular view in the media, to be sure. Sports Illustrated’s Andy Staples, for example, called it “silly” in a May 23 post, arguing that the best players should have the best opportunities regardless of where they begin their careers.
Read More
Whatever.
Media personalities like Staples and ESPN commentator Jay Bilas have their hearts in the right place. The current system isn’t fair to athletes in big revenue sports in denying them paid employment.
That lack of fairness does not, however, justify granting them rights that destroy the competitive fabric within the system as it exists now. It’s justification to broadly reform the system. Short of that, the NCAA does have a role in discouraging anti-competitive behavior of exactly the type Johnson and North Carolina are pursuing.
And the NCAA is shirking that responsibility by leaving the decisions in the hands of the schools.
This should be simple. It should be an NCAA rule that players, graduate or otherwise, who want to transfer within a conference must either sit out a year of competition to do so or be blocked from making those moves entirely. Graduate transfers should have immediate eligibility to play for any school in a different conference. Undergraduate transfers should continue to sit out the customary one year but be unchecked to head anywhere out of conference.
No exceptions. For coaches. For players. For schools.
That’s the take here, at least. Obviously people like Staples and Bilas will disagree with it, and that’s fine. Debate is healthy, and if the majority — or even a court decision — would prefer a free for all, then let there be an NCAA-mandated free for all.
But it should be the NCAA’s mandate, one that’s simple to understand and that prevents schools like Pitt from having to choose between getting beat up on the court or getting beat up off it.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter, @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.