Pitt is blocking former guard Cameron Johnson’s immediate eligibility to play for ACC foe North Carolina, and it is well within its rights to do that, despite what Jay Bilas thinks.
The ESPN analyst blasted the school Sunday on Twitter, arguing Johnson’s amateur status should give him the right to get on the court wherever he wants next season as a graduate transfer.
No school should restrict the transfer of an unpaid, amateur student for any reason. Period. Pitt is wrong here, and should let Johnson go. pic.twitter.com/QFAa8lE5a9
— Jay Bilas (@JayBilas) May 21, 2017
There is a good and well-worn argument to be made that college athletes in big revenue sports such as football and basketball should be paid, or at least be allowed to control their own likenesses. Bilas has been at the forefront of that movement, and good for him.
That argument, however, should not be the cudgel used to beat the NCAA or its members in other circumstances where individual athletes don’t get their way.
The Tar Heels went 14-4 in the ACC this season before winning the national championship. Pitt went 4-14 in the league and missed the postseason completely.
It would be anti-competitive for North Carolina to be able to pluck Johnson, who was in line to be Pitt’s top returning scorer, without the Panthers’ permission. If the NCAA allowed unchecked transfers, it would be presiding over a system in which the best talent always ends up finding its way into the same handful of programs in exactly this manner. Thus Pitt’s defense as presented to Inside Carolina for blocking Johnson from heading there immediately:
Read More
"We have remained consistent with our athletic department policy, within NCAA legislation, stipulating student-athletes are restricted from transferring to institutions within the [ACC] and those on our schedule over the next season,” Pitt spokesman Matt Plizga said in an email. “Cameron Johnson and his father were informed of our policy as well as the appeals process when they elected to seek to transfer. They went through our transfer appeals process and were granted permission to contact ACC schools. However, the committee upheld the policy to limit immediate eligibility within the conference. If Cameron were to transfer within the ACC, he would be eligible to receive financial aid immediately but would have to sit out a year of competition due to standard NCAA transfer regulations.”
This is perfectly reasonable, and it’s a decision the NCAA does and should leave up to schools like Pitt because the NCAA exists to maintain a competitive environment. Fulfilling that mission means crafting rules that help prevent schools like Pitt from becoming subservient to conference powerhouses like North Carolina by discouraging excessive player movement of exactly the type Johnson is pursuing. His father, remember, specifically cited Pitt’s roster turnover amid its coaching transition and not any kind of personal hardship as the reason his son left Pitt.
Should the NCAA also exist to do right by the athletes who generate billions of dollars for members institutions? Sure. And Bilas has every right to express his opinion that they should be paid.
He’s just wrong to conflate those separate issues.
To be fair, coaches can sometimes abuse their ability to block transfers. Pitt’s own Kevin Stallings, then at Vanderbilt of the Southeastern Conference, once blocked Sheldon Jeter from making a move directly from the Commodores to the Panthers in a bid to play closer to his Western Pennsylvania home. In that case, Pitt and Vanderbilt weren't’ scheduled to compete, so it’s pretty easy to judge that decision as petty and unjustified.
This is different. This is Pitt pursuing a tactic that’s commonplace to protect its interests. Johnson will be fine. He has a Pitt degree and a slew of offers from power programs outside the ACC. Provided Stallings doesn’t pull a Jeter at the last minute, he’ll be correct to argue he did right by both his former player and the players who stayed committed to his program, who probably wouldn’t appreciate Johnson hurting them next season any more than Bilas’ grandstanding to justify it.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter, @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.