We have no right to complain. The Penguins won the Stanley Cup last season and look as if they can repeat if they can keep 18 skaters healthy. The Steelers made it to the AFC championship game and are a Super Bowl contender most seasons. The Pirates, though not a favorite to make the playoffs this season, have become interesting and relevant after 20 years of losing. These are good times for Pittsburgh sports. We should be thankful.
But that doesn’t mean we’re not greedy. We wanted to enjoy Selection Sunday as much as many parts of the country, but it was an awful day for us. I couldn’t bring myself to watch the selection show Sunday night, though I have a feeling I’ll regret not seeing Northwestern’s name called out for the first time ever. I just thought that folding T-shirts would be more interesting and more productive.
Again, we probably had this day coming. Pitt made the NCAA tournament last season and 12 times in the 14 years before that. Robert Morris has represented well on its level, getting in the field in 2015, 2010 and 2009. I would mention Duquesne, but I’m not sure Duquesne basketball exists or even should exist. I haven’t noticed it in more than three decades.
Pitt spoiled people to the point that just making the NCAAs wasn’t good enough. That was ridiculous. It’s not easy making the tournament. It’s not like football where about 93.8 percent of the teams make it to a bowl game. Connecticut has missed the tournament five times since 2007, including this season and in 2015, the year after it won the national championship. North Carolina sat out in 2010 and 2003. This season, Syracuse, which went to the Final Four last spring, didn’t make it. Not even Hall of Fame coaches are guaranteed a spot.
Pitt didn’t just make it almost every year, it often received a high seed. It was a No. 1 in 2011 and 2009 so we definitely can appreciate the excitement at Villanova, Kansas, North Carolina and Gonzaga this morning. There always was the feeling that each year might be the year Pitt gets to the Final Four. It would have made it in 2009 if not for Villanova. Thanks very little, Scottie Reynolds.
But this Pitt season was so bad that it almost was unbelievable. Its 4-14 record in the ACC was its worst league record in 40 years. It finished 16-17 overall, its first losing season since 1999-2000. I was at a basketball function a few days after Pitt lost at home by 55 to Louisville and heard prominent former Pitt players talking about how embarrassed they were to be associated with the program because of the players’ lack of fight. They could have included the coach; Kevin Stallings quit on his team that day by getting ejected with 14:27 left. I didn’t have the heart to ask the alums what they thought about Pitt losing to Duquesne in December. They would have wanted to crawl in a hole somewhere.
Read More
We should have known Pitt’s slide was coming. It started with the move to the ACC. Not that Pitt had a choice. The football monster had to be fed. Pitt needed a home after the Big East collapsed. The ACC has been good to Pitt and Pat Narduzzi, who has the program trending up. I’m sure Big Ten champion Penn State and national champion Clemson would agree. But Pitt basketball has suffered. It is just 36-44 in the ACC, including conference tournament games.
Jamie Dixon saw this coming. That’s why he took what appeared to be a backward step by returning to his alma mater TCU after last season. It was time for him to go, time for a change for him and for Pitt.
Dixon thrived this season, leading TCU to a 19-15 record and Big 12 tournament wins against Oklahoma and No. 1 Kansas. It wasn’t enough to get TCU to the NCAA tournament — it settled for the NIT — but it was a heck of an improvement over their 2-16 Big 12 record in 2015-16. They love Dixon in Fort Worth.
Stallings wasn’t nearly as successful. I think I’ve pointed out his first season was a colossal failure. He couldn’t connect with his players, often questioning publicly their heart, commitment and basketball acumen. It all was so unseemly. It’s always unseemly when a college coach, who is making millions, fingers his players for blame. That isn’t to say Stallings didn’t have a point at times. His seniors let him, the program and themselves down. It’s still hard to believe Jamel Artis managed to get suspended for the Duquesne game and the start of the game at Virginia. Stalling ran a dysfunctional team, to say the least.
But like all coaches, Stallings deserves time to get the program back and running. It’s unfair to judge him on just one season. The problem is Pitt should be worse next season. It might not be until Stallings’ third year that we begin to see progress.
I’ve already started a new pile of T-shirts in the corner. I’m expecting another miserable Selection Sunday next year.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter @RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.