Last week’s mailbag — which was open to both football and basketball-related questions — was so popular I figured we’d give it another try. Given recent developments, there’s certainly not a lack of possible topics.
This week, we tackle Pitt’s ACC win total, the offensive coordinator position, some wrinkles in the still-fresh AD search and, most important, the merits of sweater vests.
Merry Christmas, Happy Hanukkah, Happy Kwanzaa and, since it’s today, a Happy Festivus. I’ve got a lot of problems with you people. Now, you’re going to hear about it.
@trimdadd33: Why such negativity & outright bashing by hoops fans? Excessive for 10-2 team with 3 Ws over P5 teams do u agree?
It’s a multi-faceted situation, one I think has little to actually do with Kevin Stallings, who I’ve found to be a very friendly and decent person.
A lot of it ties back to Stallings’ hire, both for what it was and how it came about. Though he was pretty successful for a long time at a school, Vanderbilt, with some inherent restrictions, Stallings was a known commodity who wasn’t either a) a home run, almost certainly unrealistic hire (i.e. Sean Miller) or b) a promising up-and-comer (any slew of top mid/low-major coaches or top-level assistants). There’s little pizazz to be had in hiring a 55-year-old whose job security at his previous stop was reportedly in question and who, while successful, never won in an overwhelmingly big or noticeable way. Then there’s the matter of the process that led to his hiring, with Scott Barnes using a search firm headed by his former boss, a man who, while the athletic director at Vanderbilt in the late 1990s, hired Stallings. It was seen externally as a potential conflict of interest and, at worst, an inside job between old friends.
Read More
The loss to Duquesne, which snapped a 15-game win streak against the Dukes, did some serious damage to his relationship with the fan base, though that had much more to do with Jamel Artis being suspended for the game than any sort of irredeemable coaching shortcoming. While there would still be some discontent, I’d be interested to see how Stallings would be perceived with an 11-1 record, wins over Maryland and Marquette, and no unsightly losses.
@ChrisYokish: Would you go over/under 8.5 Pitt wins in ACC?
That’s pretty close to the threshold I’d expect, but I’ll take the under. Predictions are a dangerous and sometimes fundamentally useless exercise, but in a sport like college basketball compared to, say, the NFL, it’s a little easier.
When the media picked Pitt to finish 12th in the ACC in the preseason — for the record, I had them 11th — I think it had much more to do with the quality of the conference than with the Panthers, who were returning four starters. The schedule that awaits them in the conference is absolutely brutal. Though it likely won’t unfold exactly this way, KenPom projects Pitt to lose 10 consecutive games, which would make it winless between Dec. 29 and Feb. 8.
Taking a quick glance at their schedule and how their opponents look as of now, I’ll say Pitt goes 8-10, which, with likely 11 nonconference wins, may put it in the NCAA tournament.
@Spano_97: What’s the word on AD and OC??
This question was posed yesterday, hours before the Scott-Barnes-to-Oregon-State news became official. It’s incredibly early in the AD search, a process that I’d guess will take several months, so I haven’t heard any developments on that front.
As for offensive coordinator, Pat Narduzzi said in a release announcing Matt Canada’s departure to LSU that the search won’t fully begin until after next week’s Pinstripe Bowl. Whether that’s totally the case is uncertain, but you likely won’t see much movement on that front until after the bowl, especially since there’s a recruiting dead period until Jan. 11.
@kocis112: lots of hoops transfers announced already. Is the Pitt staff interested in going that route?
I’d expect them to. As I’ve noted several times, next season could be a difficult one for Pitt given what it loses and the relatively little amount of experience it brings back. Many of the transfers that have already emerged wouldn’t be immediately eligible at the start of next season, which wouldn’t necessarily preclude them from being recruited.
The crucial difference, I think, is whether the staff wants these transfers to be a part of their longer-term plans or as a sort of bridge that will make next season easier to endure. If it’s the latter, the graduate transfer market will be the one to explore, and many of those players are a ways off from announcing their intentions. At Vanderbilt, Stallings was effectively unable to recruit junior-college players and graduate transfers. We’ve already seen him add a player from the former and, with this new pool of players from which to recruit, I’d expect him to aggressively look after the latter.
@Jason_J_W: I choose Pitt every year in my bowl pool with highest possible confidence points. How smart will I be this year?
It only helps so much now, but there are a few others I may have picked before this one. Still, it’s not a bad choice. Pitt’s on an absolute roll right now, particularly offensively, following that upset win at Clemson, so it’s hard to bet against them. While Northwestern has some impressive performances on its resume — including a win at Iowa and a four-point loss at playoff-bound Ohio State — it also has a few duds, most notably a 9-7 loss at home against FCS Illinois State.
I’d expect Pitt to win, but you can never predict how a group of 18-22-year-olds will fare after a month off.
@JMcDMVP: do u get the feeling stallings is willing to pull scholarships from current plyrs on roster heading into next yr?
Scholarships, at most schools, are given out on a year-to-year basis, so it’s possible. I don’t envision it being quite that cold of a process, though. After a year with a new coaching staff, and given statistics measuring roster turnover across college basketball, I’d expect a player or more to transfer. But it’s pretty early to make any ironclad conclusions just 12 games in.
@PGHskid: how delusional are ppl to think Pitt would hire Tressel?
This is in response to a report that former Ohio State coach and current Youngstown State president Jim Tressel is interested in Pitt’s vacant athletic director position. I wouldn’t classify Pitt fans’ thoughts on it as delusional if it’s simply in response to a report they believe to be credible.
I do, however, agree on the institutional end. As impressive as Tressel’s resume is, and with as much weight and recognition his name carries, I’m not sure it would be the best idea for Pitt to hire someone who had a five-year NCAA show-cause penalty end just this week, a punishment stemming largely from his failure to disclose potential NCAA violations of which he was informed. And though Tressel has a high-ranking administrative position now, colleges over the past 10 or 15 years have increasingly hired business-oriented athletic directors rather than the former players and coaches they gave such positions to for years.
@chansen991: if Tressel is hired will Pitt roll out a new line of Pitt script sweater vests?
They’d be stupid not to, even if, again, I don’t think a potential Tressel hire is the best idea, even just from a perception standpoint. There would be excitement around his arrival and there’d be a kitschiness to it, as well. Besides, I think we’re at the point where there’s still such an excitement over the return of the Pitt script that you could slap it on just about anything and people would buy it.
@CoreyECohen: What are your thoughts on the sweater vest? Is it a dapper look or 80’s sitcom nerd?
I veer more toward the latter. In Tressel’s case, it kind of epitomized the stodgy-but-effective midwestern coach whose teams used an equally stodgy-but-effective style of play, at least on offense, to great heights.
This isn’t to say it can’t be a good look. I personally wouldn’t wear a sweater vest, but I know people who dress their kids more dapperly, or at least adventurously, than I dress myself. My wife will tell you as much.
Like it is with a lot of other garments, the sweater vest’s appeal is tied largely to the person who’s wearing it. If you’ve got a stylish, urbane person rocking it with the right pieces of clothing, it can work and work quite well. If you’re a weathered suburban dad wearing it with jeans and white New Balances, you’re probably going to look like a dork.
Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.