The scene Friday at PPG Paints Arena was nothing short of a nightmare for Pitt after its 64-55 loss to Duquesne, with fans and players from a neighboring school it has dominated for four decades rushing the court in unexpected and unbridled joy.

What transpired on the same court for the previous 40 minutes provided just as much of an unsettling jolt.

With guard Jamel Artis serving a one-game suspension, the Panthers offense was a shell of what it had been in the first seven games of the season. They shot a season-low 33.3 percent from the field, missed 19 of their 22 3-point attempts and, without their second-leading scorer, looked generally lost against one of the Atlantic 10 Conference’s weaker defenses.

A few weeks before Christmas, it was a basketball version of “It’s a Wonderful Life,” a discomforting peek at just quickly and unsightly everything can unravel with the removal of a single person. Unlike how it was for George Bailey, what Pitt witnessed Friday night wasn’t an eerie glimpse at an alternate reality; it was a cold and sobering look at both where it is now — as a thin team almost wholly dependent on two scorers — and what its future might hold beyond this season.

Advertise with us

“There was nothing about our play that was good enough to win,” coach Kevin Stallings said Friday after the loss. “We weren’t good enough on offense, we didn’t shoot it well enough, we didn’t do anything well enough offensively to win the game.”

With Artis and his 19.7 points per game tethered to the bench, the Panthers missed 40 of their 60 shots after entering the game with a .468 shooting percentage. Their points per possession average (0.797) was, by far, its worst in a game this season and was only a smidgen better than a 0.796 mark they posted in last season’s ghastly 47-43 loss to Wisconsin in the first round of the NCAA tournament.

The most profound impact of Artis’ absence was seen not in the team, but his teammates who, suddenly, had to function in an offense down one of its two key parts.

Mike Young and Cam Johnson — Pitt’s first- and third-leading scorers, respectively — were productive but inefficient against the Dukes, each posting career highs in shot attempts (21 and 16). They combined to make just 13 of those 37 shots (35.1 percent). Young often appeared overworked, something Stallings acknowledged after the game. It was most apparent in the second half, when he made just one of his 11 field-goal attempts.

Unexpectedly thrust into the role of No. 2 scorer, Johnson spent much of the game forcing off-balance, contested shots after excelling for much of the season as a dangerous outside shooter.

Advertise with us

“Certain guys have green lights, certain guys have yellow lights and we won’t talk about red lights. If you’ve got a green light, I don’t say much to you. Cam’s light is pretty green,” Stallings said earlier in the season of Johnson. “There are certain types of shots Cam should take. Driving-across-the-lane, one-legged, going-away-from-the-goal ones aren’t. He took a couple of those. But squared-up 3s, even if they’re deep because he has range, those are good shots.”

While questioned in the preseason, Artis’ move to point guard was revealed Friday to be a necessity, as the backcourt options beyond him and fellow starter Chris Jones, who made 4 of 6 shots for 11 points, struggled as they have for much of the season. In a combined 31 minutes, Damon Wilson, Justice Kithcart and Jonathan Milligan made 1 of 6 shots for two points.

With Artis and Jones among four seniors who will graduate after this season, the Duquesne loss painted an unappealing portrait of what the Panthers might be like next season. Only two of Pitt’s players scheduled to return in 2017-18, Johnson and Ryan Luther, are averaging more than 3 points per game, and only three are averaging more than 10 minutes per game. That third player, freshman point guard Kithcart, is shooting just 29.4 percent from the field and 11.1 percent from 3. While he is arguably the team’s best perimeter defender, Kithcart has struggled offensively while he gets acclimated to the college game.

Whatever problems might face Pitt next season, its present team needs some help with shouldering the offensive burden, as the loss to the Dukes and the end of a 15-year win streak in the series fully demonstrated.

“We’re going to carry a lot of the load, but we can’t win it ourselves,” Young said late in November. “We need every single one of those guys, whether it’s Ryan Luther tonight, Sheldon [Jeter] the next game or Cam Johnson tonight or Chris tomorrow, whoever — Kithcart, Wilson — we need everybody. We’re going to carry a lot of the load, but we need those guys to be just as big and just as important for this team as we are if we’re going to be who we want to be.”

Advertise with us

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG.

Scouting report

Matchup: Pitt (6-2) vs. Buffalo (4-4), 7 p.m. today, Petersen Events Center.

Radio, Internet: KDKA-FM (93.7), Pitt IMG Sports Network, Sirius channel 145, XM channel 202, WatchESPN, ACC Network Extra.

Pitt: Coming off 64-55 loss Friday to Duquesne, its first loss in the City Game since 2000. ... G Jamel Artis is listed as a projected starter after being suspended vs. Dukes. ... F Mike Young has led the team in scoring in each of the past seven games and is ninth in Division I in scoring at 23 points per game.

Advertise with us

Buffalo: Coming off 90-84 loss Saturday at St. Bonaventure. ... Each of its four losses have come to teams ranked in the top 80 in Division I by kenpom.com. ... Lost its past eight meetings against Pitt, including a 92-45 loss in their previous matchup in 2007. ... F Blake Hamilton leads the team in scoring at 19 points per game.

Hidden stat: Buffalo, from the Mid-American Conference, has seen 25.2 percent of its possessions end in a turnover this season, the sixth-worst mark among Division I teams.