Between all the different looks of an opponent and the slew of situations for which to prepare, there’s nothing particularly simple about a football coach’s plan entering any game, let alone one against a heated rival.
Had Pitt played Penn State last year instead of this year, the Panthers’ defensive strategy would have been relatively straightforward and, in some respects, easier because the Panthers would have faced a more traditional pocket passer in quarterback Christian Hackenberg, who didn’t pose a threat beyond what he could do with his arm.
With a new season and a new starter in Trace McSorley, though, the Nittany Lions’ offense — led by new coordinator in Joe Moorhead — presents a new and perhaps more difficult challenge. A more mobile quarterback, McSorley gives the Penn State offense an added dimension it lacked in recent years and gives Pitt, for as good as it has been defensively under coach Pat Narduzzi, a chance to pass a test it hasn’t often excelled at in the past year: Containing a running quarterback.
“They’ve got quarterback runs and quarterback-keepers now,” Narduzzi said. “He’s going to carry the ball and in big games, I’d imagine he’s going to carry it even more. When they get down into the red zone, he’s going to be more active as far as running the ball. He’s an active guy and you have to watch him with 11 guys.”
Under Moorhead, the Nittany Lions utilize a run-pass option. In that scheme, a formation that would seem to indicate a run can suddenly turn into a passing play. There are also instances where the quarterback, instead of handing off to the running back, can take the ball himself. It’s a fast-paced attack, one in which the offensive line advances sometimes as far as five yards ahead of the original line of scrimmage on a given play.
That quicker tempo was evident in Penn State’s season-opening victory against Kent State, a game in which it ran 69 plays, about five more than the 63.8 it averaged last season.
Read More
“We’d like to be in situations when he is running where it’s more of a clean look,” Penn State coach James Franklin said of McSorley. “And there’s less bodies around him, like [running back] Saquon [Barkley], he’s built to do those things. If it’s a great look, hand the ball off and let Saquon get those yards.”
The new scheme, and the quarterback running it, adds a layer of unpredictability for opposing defenses, something Pitt has struggled with at times in 14 games under Narduzzi.
Last season, the Panthers had difficulties not only against option teams with quarterbacks whose greatest threat came on the ground — like Navy’s Keenan Reynolds, who ran 24 times for 144 yards, and Georgia Tech’s Justin Thomas, who had 15 rushes for 98 yards — but also against mobile quarterbacks in more conventional schemes, like Duke’s Parker Boehme, 11 carries for 80 yards, North Carolina’s Marquise Williams, nine rushes for 52 yards, and Syracuse’s Eric Dungey, six rushes for 38 yards.
Pitt has undoubtedly also had success in neutralizing such quarterbacks on the ground, as it did last season with Louisville’s Lamar Jackson and Notre Dame’s DeShone Kizer, both of whom have emerged as popular Heisman Trophy candidates early this season. But even against an overmatched Villanova team last week, the Panthers allowed quarterback Zach Bednarcyzk to run for 60 yards on seven carries, many of which were scrambles (officially, with six sacks, he ran 13 times for 2 yards).
When asked about it Thursday, Narduzzi bristled at the idea his team has had trouble against more mobile quarterbacks. Pitt’s defense, regardless of the quarterback and style it faces, will be ready in the eyes of its coach.
“We’ve never really struggled with those guys and don’t expect to,” he said. “But when you’re defending 11 guys, is it going to be perfect? No, it’s never going to be perfect. But when you see a quarterback for 100 yards or 200 yards, then we’ve got a problem. But if we don’t have that, I think we’re sound.”
Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.