Nate and Aaron Peterman both remember their last competitive basketball game against one another.
The two brothers, Aaron three years older, had often gone rough-and-tumble under the hoop outside their house in Fruit Cove, Fla., just south of Jacksonville. The games usually ended with Aaron victorious and Nate somehow bruised or bloodied.
“I was mostly a protector of Nathan when he was younger,” the oldest Peterman brother, Ryan, three years Aaron’s senior, said.
“Aaron beat up on him a lot. They’d be playing one-on-one out there and Nate would come running in, running for his life.”
Until one day the summer after Nate’s freshman year of high school. The two were out on the concrete, and the game had already taken its usual physical turn. But that’s when Nate, who earlier this week was named Pitt’s new starting quarterback, established that he wasn’t the little brother anymore.
“I was getting angry he was getting the best of me, so I threw him down after a shot or pushed him real hard,” Aaron recalled.
“He got up and he wiped the blood off the corner of his mouth because it scraped the concrete, then he shot a 3-pointer right in my face. He was just clutch. It’s like, ‘OK, he shut me up.’ ”
This football season, Nate found himself in another competition as a member of the Pitt football team, this time with incumbent starting quarterback Chad Voytik. The two have split snaps so far this season, but coach Pat Narduzzi announced Wednesday that Peterman would be the team’s starter moving forward.
“Nate’s a competitor,” his dad, Chuck Peterman said. “He has been ever since he was 3 years old.”
While that competitive spirit and toughness may have been forged on that basketball court with his older brother, his upbringing was also heavily shaped by the much more peaceful influence of religion.
As children of Dana and Chuck Peterman, now senior minister at Creekside Christian Church in St. Johns, Fla., religion was an undeniable influence on the three Peterman boys growing up.
Rather than rebel against the stereotype of being “preacher’s kids,” though, all three, especially Nate, embraced that aspect.
“Luckily, I think they just raised us so well that they told us, ‘Hey, it’s your choice,’” Nate said. “Honestly, I was just completely blessed with two other brothers that paved the way for me and showed me it is cool to be a Christian.”
Faith is a constant theme in just about every seminal moment in Nate’s life, and his football career. Going back to fourth-grade Pop Warner when he was forced to play center, and all he wanted was just to have the ball in his hands.
“I would come home bawling and my dad would just kind of have me stay faithful with it,” Nate said.
Nate even admitted that he thought about giving up on football all together and sticking with basketball. He finally got his chance to play quarterback in sixth grade, though, and has stuck at the position ever since.
Ryan’s first hint that his youngest brother had a special athletic ability, though, came on the basketball court, when Nate was in fifth grade.
“He took a half-court shot, right at halftime, and just swished it through,” Ryan recalled.
“He was doing reverse layups, all kinds of stuff. At that age, kids are still trying to learn how to dribble the ball sometimes.”
By the time Nate hit high school, there was no doubt about his future potential in athletics. Just a freshman, he secured a role as the backup varsity quarterback at Bartram Trail High School. He didn’t see much playing time, but Aaron, then a senior offensive lineman, recalled his little brother’s first touchdown pass in a blowout against Ponte Vedra High School.
Aaron had already been pulled with the rest of the starters, but when he saw Nate marching the offense down the field, about to score his first touchdown, he begged coach Darrell Sutherland to put him back in the game.
“He did, and it was cool to celebrate that touchdown pass,” Aaron said.
During his four years at Bartram Trail, Nate made it clear that he was more than just the nice preacher’s son.
“You’re kind of known as the ‘church kid’ or the ‘good kid’ or whatever,” Aaron said. “I tried to pierce through that a little bit, and Nathan really pierced through that. He became the homecoming king and kind of left high school — he wouldn’t say this — but as a very humble guy.”
Nate’s football career hit a bit of a rough patch when he enrolled at Tennessee. Passed over for the starting job after three years and opting to transfer, Nate once against turned to his faith.
“He was really, honestly, just following how he felt the Lord was leading him in prayer, and that’s how he ended up [at Pitt],” Chuck Peterman said.
It didn’t get much easier when he arrived at Pitt, though, facing an uphill battle against Voytik, an incumbent starter. The two developed a quick friendship (including more than a few rounds of golf over the summer), which meant for no bad blood when Peterman took over the starting job.
“I do know what it’s like to have your job taken,” Nate said. “It’s tough. All the respect to Chad. He’s really been a great guy through this whole process.”
Of course, Narduzzi also emphasized this week that while Peterman is currently the Panthers’ starting quarterback, the competition between him and Voytik is still ongoing. And that’s just fine with Peterman.
Going back to his backyard basketball days, he has never shied away from a little competition.
“I knew that he was going to be pretty top-notch because he always hated to lose,” Chuck Peterman said.
“I tried to console him with, ‘Hey they’re two feet taller than you’ and all that, but he’s been that way since he was a preschooler. God just kind of put that fire in him.”
Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SWernerPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.