Penn State coach James Franklin, speaking at a Coaches Caravan event Thursday night in Cranberry Township, suggested the Nittany Lions' upcoming four-game series with Pitt may be extended past its 2019 expiration date.
Then today, Pitt coach Pat Narduzzi told Sirius XM told Sirius XM College Sports Nation: “Next year we play Penn State for the next four years and hopefully for the next 44 years.”
Let’s hope such talk is the beginning of the schools figuring out what the long-term future of their rivalry is going to look like, because the uncertainty of the past 15 years since their last meeting at Three Rivers Stadium in 2000 has been exhausting for fans on both sides.
It took them until 2011 just to agree to play again at all. And now with the anticipation of the series set to begin at Heinz Field in September 2016 building, already that excitement is being dampened by questions about what comes after that. It’s time to stop kicking the proverbial can down the road.
Granted, coming to an agreement that works for both sides will not be easy.
Pitt also has to juggle what to do with the Backyard Brawl now that West Virginia is in a different conference. And it’s already lined up several dates with quasi-rival Notre Dame through 2025 that will complicate scheduling.
Penn State, meanwhile, has become a regional school that’s being tugged in plenty of other directions by a diverse fan base that has arms into Baltimore/Washington, New York, Philadelphia and, increasingly, Boston.
All of those alumni blocs want to see non-conference games in their neighborhoods, too, and aren’t nearly as invested in the Pitt rivalry as local Nitters.
But with fresh administrations now fully in place at both schools following Pitt’s hiring of Scott Barnes as athletic director, it seems like a good time to sort out all those issues.
The entrenched egos wearing different shades of blue that were responsible for the series falling apart have been mostly swept out. (Some more gracefully than others.) Now, this group of administrators composed mostly of outsiders should be able to view the situation more objectively, without the pettiness that previously colored negotiations and turned the series into more of a cold war.
One option they could consider is committing to an annual renewal that alternates location between State College and Pittsburgh. This is obviously the most restrictive solution for schedule makers, because they can only have so many home-and-home series running concurrently and still be able to get the requisite number of home games per year required to adequately fund their athletic departments.
That’s especially a problem at Penn State, which has dozens of teams that depend upon the football cash cow. It needs at least seven home games and would have few options if it were married to Pitt. But it’s also hard to conceive of a way Pitt could play West Virginia, Notre Dame and Penn State in the same season once, let alone regularly.
So maybe the irregular type of arrangement Pitt has with Notre Dame through an ACC scheduling agreement is more attractive.
Currently, Pitt is scheduled to play the Fighting Irish in 2015, ’18, ’20, ’23 and ’25. This dictates the schools meet often enough to stoke the passions but allows the Panthers some room to maneuver in scheduling Penn State, West Virginia, and other non-conference opponents that can drum up interest, recent examples being Nebraska, Iowa and Utah.
Lining up something similar with Penn State for the 2020s would be a good first step and could hopefully set a precedent for the decades to come.
Perhaps that means they’ll only meet four or five times in a given 10-year period, less often than some fans and alumni might like.
But at least this once-great rivalry will then be spared the scheduling squabbling that’s caused unnecessary animosity since both programs gave up their independence to join conferences in the early 1990s. Fans would be able to rest assured they’ll regularly get to see the Nittany Lions and Panthers squaring off to awaken the echoes of the glory days of the rivalry in the 1970s and ’80s, when the games frequently had national championship implications.
We saw this past week that the rivalry remains vibrant. When the P-G’s Mike White reported Tuesday that Woodland Hills running back Miles Sanders plans to visit other schools — presumably including Pitt — while remaining committed to Penn State, partisan message boards and social media accounts on both sides erupted with interest.
Sanders is, after all, the top-ranked prospect in the state and is a crucial test of Franklin’s “dominate the state” dictum that’s ruffled feathers in Oakland. Securing his commitment would give either school major bragging rights as they gather the 2016 recruiting classes that will face each other for four straight years.
With that in mind, administrators would be wise to use this moment to make things work, if not every year, then often enough that we don’t have to worry about any more long hiatuses once the series ends in 2019.
Adam Bittner writes sports commentary for The Pittsburgh Press, our afternoon electronic edition. He can be reached at abittner@post-gazette.com or Twitter, @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.