Thousands of high school seniors formally will decide today where to spend their college years, put ink to paper and use a fax machine for possibly the only time.
It’s national signing day, a date that has become one of the most important in college football’s offseason. It has become an annual tradition over the past decade or so to watch the best high school football players choose from a variety of school hats on national TV.
There’s also a chance that today could be the final signing day of its kind.
Conference commissioners will vote in June whether to implement an early signing period for football, possibly starting as soon as next year. The idea has been bandied about for years, but a recent proposal to the Conference Commissioners Association — the body that governs the national letter of intent program — has generated a lot of momentum.
The new signing period would start the third Wednesday of December and last 72 hours, coinciding with the same dates as the mid-year junior-college transfer signing period. Prospects could sign then or wait until the traditional February date to sign their letters of intent.
Mid-American Conference commissioner Jon Steinbrecher, who chaired the committee that made the proposal, said his group found that of the 2014 recruiting class, 82 percent made a verbal commitment before this December date. Of that group, 90 percent ended up sticking with their commitment.
“The feedback from the coaches was that we’ve got a number of kids who have made their decision,” Steinbrecher said. “Why aren’t we allowing them to go ahead and formalize it?”
Once a prospect signs a national letter of intent, other schools are prohibited from contacting them. While verbal commitments have become popular over the past few years, they are not binding.
Football’s lack of an early signing period is an exception, rather than a rule, across NCAA sports. Soccer and men’s water polo are the only other NCAA sports that don’t have an early signing period for prospective athletes.
“Those sports that sign early, you see a benefit of it,” said Susan Peal, director of the NCAA’s national letter of intent program. “They see that for those prospective student-athletes, they get the recruiting process complete in the early part of their senior year of high school so they can go on with their senior year and concentrate academically [and] athletically on the rest of their senior year.”
There has been support in the past for an August signing period, including from the ACC at its spring meetings in May. But Steinbrecher said his group settled on a December date primarily because it allowed for the least significant changes to the NCAA’s recruiting calendar for football.
The middle of December marks the beginning of the NCAA’s “dead period,” which limits coaches to one phone call per prospect per week. In effect, a December signing period would eliminate any last-minute recruiting that occurs after the dead period ends in the middle of January.
It also allows for factors like coaching changes to play a role in a prospect’s decision, whereas an August signing date could get complicated if a coach is fired.
“There’s no one perfect date at the end of the day, but, when we got down to it, it always seemed like the December date was the one that seemed to address the most issues without upsetting additional apple carts,” Steinbrecher said.
While it may not change the formal recruiting cycle, an early period would influence the process. For instance, if a player verbally commits to a school the summer before his senior year, which is common, but chooses not to sign in the December window, it could be a sign to coaches that his commitment is not strong.
“That’s a huge red flag,” said Mike Farrell, national recruiting analyst for Rivals.com. “As opposed to [now] where [a prospect] can just say ‘Oh yeah, I’m solid,’ and then the next thing you know [coaches] see on Twitter that he’s visiting another school.”
Of course, the rule has to pass first. The leagues will discuss it at their spring meetings, and the CCA, which is made up of commissioners from the 32 Division I conferences, will vote in June. Steinbrecher said he thought support from the coaching community was strong, and Penn State coach James Franklin said last spring that he would support the idea.
“I’d be for it, but I’d be for it under the right circumstances,” Franklin said. “What I mean by that is I think you only want an early signing period for the kids that are going to a school no matter what and have always wanted to go to that school.”
It can be difficult to gauge how conference commissioners will react. ACC commissioner John Swofford could not be reached for comment on the December date, but said in the past he would be in favor of an August signing period.
“Our feelings are that would be a healthy thing for the recruits in the sense that it gives them an opportunity to make their decision, fully commit to it and sign, then be able to play and study during their senior season without the distractions of the recruiting process, which can be very significant,” Swofford said.
“Our feeling is that if a player knows where he wants to go and is ready to make that commitment, it really enhances the situation for that player, first of all, and also for the institutions, as well.”
Sam Werner: swerner@post-gazette.com and twitter @SWernerPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.