College sports got a seismic jolt Saturday with the news that the University of Pittsburgh and Syracuse University would leave the Big East Conference for the Atlantic Coast Conference.
The Post-Gazette learned that Pitt would make the jump, although there has not been a formal announcement on the move, which caught Big East conference officials off guard.
A Big East official said Saturday that members are required to give 72 hours notice before applying to another conference, but added that the conference had no idea this was coming.
A highly placed Pitt source had no comment for the record, but did say "a school would not apply for membership in another conference unless it was sure it was going to be invited."
As uncertainty grips college athletics and conferences continue to expand and contract, the reasons for Pitt and Syracuse to leave are many. Revenue, fear and prestige are likely the driving factors for Pitt, said Malcolm Moran, Knight Chair in Sports Journalism and Society at Penn State's College of Communications.
"If this development winds up leading to additional, similar developments, and the ACC emerges as one of the so-called superconferences, the difference could be millions" in annual revenue from football TV deals, he said.
Two things could stand in Pitt's way from making an immediate departure. The Big East has a $5 million exit fee and a member must give the conference 27 months notice. A person familiar with the situation said neither is expected to stand in the way if Pitt and Syracuse want to leave.
Pitt and Syracuse will become the fourth and fifth schools to leave the Big East for the ACC since 2003. Virginia Tech and Miami left the Big East for the ACC in 2004 and Boston College joined the ACC in 2005.
Pitt and Syracuse, two of the earliest members of the Big East, formally applied for membership in the ACC this past week, but the process of Pitt leaving the conference was put into motion following the conference's summer meetings.
According to a league source, Pitt athletic director Steve Pederson made it clear at the time that Big East commissioner John Marinatto needed to be more proactive in expanding the conference and that while Pitt's first preference was to stay in the Big East, the school would not hesitate to leave if a better opportunity arose.
Mr. John Marinatto released the following statement late Saturday night: "Although I was obviously very disappointed to learn the news about the ACC's being in discussions about membership with the University of Pittsburgh and Syracuse University, I continue to believe the Big East Conference is well positioned for the future and that the events of the past 24 hours will unify our membership. We have been working steadily to solidify and strengthen the Big East Conference and position us for our upcoming TV negotiations and I am confident that we will again emerge from this situation and remain strong."
Pitt spokesman E.J. Borghetti and Pitt football coach Todd Graham declined comment when asked about the move after the Panthers 31-27 loss to Iowa.
Louisville athletic director Tom Jurich didn't waste time denouncing the move.
Mr. Jurich said during a video interview on the website of the Louisville Courier-Journal that Pitt Chancellor Mark Nordenberg has violated the trust of the rest of the conference members and called the matter "slippery."
He said that Pitt and Syracuse should be ashamed of themselves for not at least picking up the phone and informing the conference they were leaving.
"[Why this is happening now], I think is a question for Pittsburgh's [Chancellor Nordenberg]," Mr. Jurich said. "I think that is a question a lot of people would like answered.
"I talked to [Big East commissioner John Marinatto] today a couple times, he was stunned. I think he at least deserved a phone call, he didn't need to hear about it from" a reporter.
Mr. Jurich added that he was surprised by the developments because he doesn't believe Pitt adds anything to the ACC.
"I didn't believe it because Pittsburgh was involved in it," he said. "I just didn't see the value they would bring to that league at all. That is no slap at Pittsburgh, but I didn't see where that fit was. And then [Nordenberg] was the chair of the executive committee in our conference and he was keeping everyone together and asked everybody to be unified, and so I think everybody trusted him."
The ACC recently renegotiated its television contract with ESPN, and will receive $155 million annually, divided out evenly among all member schools.
The Big East's current deal with ESPN, which expires in 2013, pays the conference an average of $36 million annually, divided among all 16 (soon to be 17) member schools. In April, Sports Business Journal reported that the league was in talks with ESPN for a new deal, which could be worth between $110 million and $130 million per year.
The Big East believed it was in the best position of any conference to strengthen itself by adding members, so much so that it turned down an ESPN deal worth about $1 billion earlier this year in hopes of getting a better deal next year.
At the Big East summer meetings, Mr. Marinatto said he thought that the conference would be able to lure either Boston College and Maryland away from the ACC with the promise of riches from a better TV deal than the ACC had, or it would be able to offer a soft landing place for Missouri, Kansas and Kansas State should the Big 12 Conference collapse.
Perhaps more important than that carrot is the stick that schools like Pitt and Syracuse faced if other schools left the Big East before they did, threatening its viability as a football conference, said Mr. Moran.
Now the Big East's remaining football powers, West Virginia and the University of Connecticut, "have got to be scared to death, because when the music stops, there's not going to be a place to sit down."
West Virginia athletic director Oliver Luck, through the WVU sports information department, had no comment Saturday. The Mountaineers are Pitt's longtime rival.
There's debate as to whether membership in athletic conferences has academic implications, said Mr. Moran. No one really knows whether smart high school seniors choose colleges based on their sports programs, but being associated with top-notch academic schools can't hurt, he said.
"When Miami left the Big East to go to the ACC, part of the appeal was the chance to link itself with institutions like the University of Virginia and North Carolina," he said. "These are considered top-tier institutions."
The ACC doesn't as yet have anything analogous to the Big 10's Committee on Institutional Cooperation, which cements academic cooperation between the schools, Mr. Moran noted.
A move to the ACC would be a step up academically for Pitt. The 2012 U.S. News & World Report rankings place Pitt as the 58th-best national university. The current 12 ACC schools boast an average U.S. News & World Report ranking of 49, with Duke, Virginia and Wake Forest in the top 25. According to the rankings, Pitt would rank ninth in a 14-team ACC.
Without Pitt and Syracuse, the Big East has an average ranking of 110. Georgetown and Notre Dame rank in the top 25, but the conference has seven schools ranked 100 or lower. Providence and Villanova are classified as "regional universities," and are not in the national rankings.
The Big East has long faced tension between the schools that rely on basketball for revenue, and the eight with football programs. But it has weathered crises before, and responded to three defections in 2003 by attracting teams that strengthened its basketball roster while shoring up football, Mr. Moran said. Its survival "really depends on whether it can respond the same way it did last time."
Pitt men's basketball coach Jamie Dixon could not be reached for comment, but he and other Big East basketball coaches have been outspoken against conference expansion.
When asked about Pitt possibly going to the Big Ten in December 2009, he said: "I can't see how any [Big East] team would improve where they're at by movement. To me, for every situation, you have to look at why you're doing it. How do you improve yourself? I can't see how moving from the best conference in college basketball history would be a good thing for anyone."
However in October, Mr. Dixon said Pitt would be in good position no matter what happened in conference expansion.
"Ultimately, I know we'll be in a great situation," he said. "We have a very good basketball program, a very good football program. Academically, we're an institution on the rise. Financially, the school is in terrific shape and growing. All of those things are what are needed to sustain and grow. Having that in the back of mind gives me a positive feeling."
The ACC may be looking to poach more Big East teams, Mr. Moran said. And the moves made by Pitt and Syracuse mark a significant acceleration in the reshuffling of the conferences.
"If these moves, in fact, take place, and the dominoes lead to other, similar moves, then it seems pretty clear that the institutions that have enough to sell can position themselves in a more secure, power-conference type of arrangement," he said. "We're already seeing a polarization of haves and have-nots, and that's only going to become more dramatic as this thing goes on."
News of the two schools heading for the ACC "hit me like a brick this morning," said Jake Crouthamel, Syracuse's athletic director from 1978 through 2004 and a founding father of the Big East. The moves make sense, he said, given the Big East's unstable position on the periphery of college football's Bowl Championship Series hierarchy.
"I think it's a preemptive move rather than sitting around, waiting for the ax to fall," Mr. Crouthamel said. The two teams "want to get the heck out before it falls."
The loss of Pitt and Syracuse leaves the Big East with six football schools, and a seventh on the way when Texas Christian University joins the conference next season. To be eligible for an automatic Bowl Championship Series game, the most lucrative of the college football bowl games, a conference must have eight football teams.
The Big East will need to scramble to find an eighth team, which could come from the crumbling Big 12 Conference, to remain eligible for the BCS bid.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.