This mailbag feature, young as it may be, typically is centered around Pitt basketball. But given everything going on right now with the Panthers, with it relatively quiet on the basketball front and pretty jumbled everywhere else, I’m opening it up. It’s a digital Ellis Island.
Remember, if you have any questions you want answered and featured, send them my way either via email (cmeyer@post-gazette.com) or Twitter (@CraigMeyerPG).
@9timevictor: How do u see Browne vs Mac vs Pickett comp shaking out in spring? What offense is best for each?
Among a handful of reasons why Max Browne’s commitment to Pitt Friday was so important was that it seemingly answers the Panthers’ quarterback questions going into next season. Graduate transfers, given the limited amount of time they have left in college, rarely opt for a school in which their status as a starter is even somewhat of a question. Browne, who arrives in Oakland via USC, will have to earn Pitt’s starting quarterback gig, but he’s an early favorite to do so. It’s hard to envision a scenario in which he doesn’t.
That, of course, isn’t a slight at any of the younger quarterbacks the Panthers have on their roster. Thomas MacVittie is someone people often speak glowingly of. Ben DiNucci was one of the most statistically decorated quarterbacks to ever come through the WPIAL. Kenny Pickett seems like an intriguing prospect. Each player I mentioned there, however, is incredibly young, no older than a redshirt freshman. A top-ranked quarterback nationally coming out of high school, Browne could, at the very least, be a nice stopgap, a productive bridge to the future of the position.
This all obviously hinges on who the next offensive coordinator is, but that’s how I see things for now.
Read More
@BarryJ23: With all the time off since the last game will we see some changes in scheme or lineup v Rice?
I can’t imagine it’ll happen, largely because Pitt doesn’t have a whole lot of options with which to tinker. Mike Young and Jamel Artis, given their experience and production, are indispensable at this point, barring some kind of unexpected injury or disciplinary problem. Cam Johnson is the team’s best 3-point shooter and has developed into a reliable third scoring option. Chris Jones has averaged close to 11 points per game the past three games and is a smart, steady player in the team’s backcourt. Sheldon Jeter is perhaps the team’s most versatile player whose contributions often go well beyond his final scoring line. And, after a rough start, even that has been improving of late.
If any kind of change were to be made, it would likely involve Ryan Luther being injected into the starting five, because beyond him, there’s nobody on that bench ready for that sort of an increased role at this point.
@klean45: Will Dewayne Hendrix be able to get a medical redshirt?
It’s difficult to predict the NCAA’s mindset on any number of issues — to its credit, it at least has more consistency in its decisions than Roger Goodell — but I doubt it would happen. An extension of an athlete’s five-year clock is incredibly hard to come by and is usually reserved for people such as Ejuan Price who were burdened with a handful of setbacks beyond their own control.
As unfortunate as Hendrix’s injury is, especially given how early it occurred, he already sat out one year because of his transfer from Tennessee. Cold as it may seem, that’s a move that was within Hendrix’s control. If I were in charge of the NCAA and its rules, I would grant a sixth season to him, but then again, if I were in any kind of position of power in college athletics, a whole slew of things would be different.
@kocis112: Rumors about Canada trying to poach Pitt commits. Any truth? If so will Narduzzi still keep him through bowl?
I’ve seen some mention of this on social media, but I haven’t heard anything substantive about it.
Just on surface value, I’d say it’s a rumor to disregard. Matt Canada is remaining on Pitt’s staff for the Pinstripe Bowl, and his continued presence around the program is clearly something Pat Narduzzi approves. This is also a guy who made it a point to leave Baton Rouge to return to Pittsburgh to deliver the news of his departure to Narduzzi in person. Given those realities, it’s hard to imagine him going rogue by doing something incredibly taboo that would harm not only a colleague and boss, but a friend, especially when he’s going to have a number of built-in recruiting advantages at his disposal once he formally takes over at LSU.
@MostlySportsPgh: Why is it taking so long for Kevin Stallings to find a tailor in Pittsburgh?
I’m the last person to dish out fashion analysis, but his suits are a tad baggy, huh? There, of course, isn’t anything wrong with this and it can be easily explained.
Kevin Stallings is a man who is well-established at this point in his life. He turned 56 a couple of months ago and has been a Division I head coach for the past 23 years. Who the hell’s he trying to impress at this point? Look at some of your more suavely dressed basketball coaches on the local scene. Andy Toole’s a sharp coaching prospect who is still at a really early point in his head-coaching career. Guys such as Jeremy Ballard (Pitt) and Danny Lawson (Duquesne) are young assistants trying to work their way up the ladder, both through their acumen and skill, but also in the way they present themselves. This is as much an argument about age as it is formal sideline fashion.
Heck, even our president elect, an ostentatious billionaire who can certainly afford an army of top-tier tailors, parades around in roomy suits. Stallings is far from the only wealthy man of a certain age to not rock completely form-fitting attire.
@mpopchock: Assistant coaches come and go, even at successful programs. Why did Joe act like it only happens to Pitt?
I’ll give my general take on the situation before delving into how others feel about it: Pitt losing Matt Canada had much more to do with the absurd amount of money LSU and other top-tier SEC schools spend on coordinators than Pitt’s unwillingness or inability to do so. Pitt’s discussion of a two-year, $2 million contract with a guy who was fired by N.C. State 11 months ago should show that commitment. But there’s only so much you can do when competing against a school that is shelling out $1.8 million next year on a defensive coordinator (but, yeah, there’s no way we could afford to pay the players).
I can see why the label of “Pitt Stop University” angered some fans. If you read beyond that, however, a lot of the points Joe made in his column are reasonable and accurate. Pitt is an excellent school with a football program that has a lot to offer, but it has a clear place in the college football hierarchy behind the sport’s upper crust. That’s no kind of shot at the Panthers — they just happened to lose a prized coordinator to one of a handful of programs in the country that 97-98 percent of the Football Bowl Subdivision can’t go head-to-head against. It’s something I believe a lot of Pitt fans acknowledge and discuss among each other, but when someone from the Post-Gazette writes it, especially with that “Pitt Stop” label thrown in there, it becomes something inflammatory.
We’ve seen coaching turnover locally at Pitt, West Virginia and Penn State in recent years, and for good reason. Below the most coveted positions, college coaching is a transient profession. That’s not changing anytime soon.
@BrunoPittsburgh: What freshmen that redshirted this year are you hearing/seeing the most buzz about for next year?
We only get to watch so much of practice — a 30-minute window that’s mostly stretching and special-teams drills — but from talking to people, you do get a sense that certain guys have turned heads, even in limited moments.
Rashad Weaver appeared on the team’s most recent depth chart at defensive end. Therran Coleman was listed earlier in the year among the top few players at cornerback. And while he hasn’t made the same visible impact, it’s hard not to be impressed with what a player like Kaezon Pugh may be able to accomplish in his time at the school.
@CoreyECohen: Have you seen Moana yet? What's your favorite song? Inquiring minds would like to know.
I haven’t seen Moana yet, mostly because, despite being from Kentucky, I haven’t had any children by the age of 27. I’ve heard a lot of good things about it, though, and I’m never above seeing a good kids movie. Maybe I’ll catch it on on-demand after basketball season winds down.
Since I haven’t seen the movie, I haven’t heard any of the songs in it, but I’ll run with this and just list my favorite songs of all-time.
1. “This Is How We Do It”, Montell Jordan: The greatest artistic achievement in the history of Western Civilization. I will hear no arguments stating otherwise.
2. “You Dropped a Bomb on Me”, The Gap Band: If not for the previously stated No. 1 song, this would hold that aforementioned honor. A perfectly ’80s tune with the correct amount of cheese dispersed in both song and video. My college roommate and I were known on occasion to get home from a night out and blast this song. It always felt right.
3. “Electric Avenue”, Eddy Grant: An ear worm if there ever were one. On that note, it’s now stuck in my head.
4. “Changes”, Tupac: I’m forever a Biggie guy when it comes to the debate between the two, but this song’s a masterpiece with a meaning that still resonates.
T-5. “Alright”, Kendrick Lamar: It came out a more than a year-and-a-half ago, but this song still bumps in the same way it did when it came out.
T-5. “The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald”, Gordon Lightfoot: It’s weird putting a ballad about 29 dead sailors on this list, but it’s nothing short of poetry. Also, if you ever want to clear out an especially crowded bar, play this on the jukebox. Trust me, it works.
Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.