MLB Trade Rumors on Friday published its arbitration projections for every eligible MLB player, including 10 with the Pirates. Over the years, those salary figures have proven to be fairly accurate.

The Pirates have a number of contracts coming off the books, including Marcell Ozuna, Brandon Lowe and Gregory Soto. However, most of those savings will go toward raises for those arbitration-eligible players.

Unless the Pirates commit to increasing their payroll in 2027, they may face some tough choices this offseason.

Teams will have until mid-November to decide whether to tender a player a contract, although agreements — and hearings, if necessary — would not occur until the expected MLB lockout ends.

Advertise with us

While that lockout could dramatically shift the league’s financial structure, the Pirates in the meantime must make decisions as if nothing will change.

Here’s a breakdown of the Pirates’ projected arbitration figures and what they should do with each player:

RHP Paul Skenes — $7.2 million

This is an arbitration hearing the entire league will be watching. Skenes, after being paid essentially the league minimum for his first three seasons, is set up to start earning significant money. However, in his first season of arbitration, he will still be on a team-friendly salary.

Skenes will undoubtedly be tendered a contract. The only question is whether Skenes breaks the first-year pitcher arbitration Dallas Keuchel set at $7.25 million in 2016. Even after a down year, it seems likely that Skenes will.

CF Oneil Cruz — $6.3 million

Cruz showed what he can be in 2026, tallying a career-high 2.8 bWAR in just 97 games by batting .280 with 20 homers, 30 stolen bases and a career-high .854 OPS. The Pirates were 55-39 when Cruz started.

Advertise with us

Cruz will get a well-deserved salary bump from the $3.3 million he earned in 2026, and the Pirates will certainly give it to him. The two sides could even pursue a longer-term deal to keep Cruz in Pittsburgh past 2028, although current CBA uncertainty makes it tough to project.

INF Nick Gonzales — $3.1 million

From here onward, debates can be had.

Gonzales took a step forward in 2026, finishing as one of just seven MLB players with a better than .300 average, but he also finished with minus-15 defensive runs saved at third base — the worst number in MLB.

The Pirates will have decisions to make with Gonzales this offseason, mostly with where his best spot is defensively, but a non-tender seems unlikely. After all, he could be the team’s second baseman on opening day.

Even if the Pirates find a way to bring back Brandon Lowe, there will still be a role for Gonzales at third or off the bench. Or he could become a trade piece.

Advertise with us

1B Spencer Horwitz — $2.5 million

Like Gonzales, Horwitz isn’t prohibitively expensive. Unlike Gonzales, he’s coming off of a down season.

When he’s hitting, $2.5 million is a steal for one of the better hitters in baseball, which he was from July 2025 to June 2026. If he’s not, it’s tough to justify spending that on a backup to fellow lefty Ryan O’Hearn.

Still, Horwitz is a worthwhile bet.

RHP Jared Jones — $2.1 million

Jones returned from internal brace surgery and had a 3.72 ERA in 21 starts, striking out 123 in 101 2/3 innings. He finished the year by earning National League Pitcher of the Month honors in September.

Spending $2.1 million and tendering a contract to the talented young right-hander may be the easiest decision the Pirates make on this list. Even if they still have to be mindful of his innings next season, it’ll be money well spent.

Advertise with us

INF Jared Triolo — $1.8 million

Triolo posted his fourth consecutive positive-WAR season in 2026. His batting average improved. He did a lot of different things for the Pirates.

He also ended 2026 with a .610 OPS, the lowest of his career.

The Pirates believe there’s more in Triolo, and regardless, $1.8 million isn’t much to pay for a utility infielder. If budgets are especially tight, it might be worth seeing if Duce Gourson or Jack Brannigan can fill the same role for cheaper. If not, Triolo is still useful off the bench.

RHP Carmen Mlodzinski — $1.6 million

Mlodzinski had a productive 2026 season, throwing 123 innings and finishing with a 3.95 ERA. His splits remained significant all year. He had a 2.55 ERA in 70 2/3 innings as a reliever and a 5.85 ERA in 52 1/3 innings as a starter.

Regardless of his role in 2027, Mlodzinski is well worth $1.6 million as a bulk reliever or an emergency starter.

Advertise with us

And if he makes it clear he wants to start and the Pirates don’t have a rotation spot, he can be a valuable trade chip.

It should be a simple decision, no matter the role the Pirates see him playing next year.

RHP Yohan Ramirez — $1.5 million

Last offseason, the Pirates offered him a contract for $825,000 — instead of the projected $1.2 million arbitration figure — and Ramirez responded with by far the best season of his career.

The Pirates probably shouldn’t count on Ramirez to post another 2.7 bWAR season with a 2.86 ERA and 102 strikeouts in 85 innings, but they’re certainly glad he did this year.

Ramirez is worth bringing back as part of what needs to be a better bullpen in 2027.

Advertise with us

C Henry Davis — $1.4 million

Davis had his third consecutive season with a sub-.200 batting average in 2026. He was strong defensively, but a .585 OPS relegated him to backup duty.

Still, 32 catchers were paid more than $1.4 million in 2026, per Spotrac, including Austin Hedges’ $4 million.

The Pirates went 45-40 with Davis catching this year. For a glove-first backup catcher, a little more than a million isn’t a bad price to pay, even if the Pirates had hoped for more from the former top pick.

C Endy Rodriguez — $1.2 million

Rodriguez appeared to be in the midst of a breakout year, only for injuries to derail a third consecutive season. He’ll be away from baseball activities until March at the absolute earliest.

So what should the Pirates do with Rodriguez? His future at catcher is in doubt. His time with the Pirates could be, too.

He has a minor-league option remaining, so it’s probably worth keeping him on the roster for narrowly above the minimum and seeing where his rehab leads. Still, with his extensive injury history, it’d be understandable if the Pirates were ready to move on.