The Pirates had their first winning season since 2018, but once again were left to watch postseason baseball from home. Talk of progress and a set foundation are hollow when ending a decade-long playoff drought was the expectation.

There were clear wins. Braxton Ashcraft emerged as an All-Star. Brandon Lowe was a stellar acquisition who made an impact on the field, in the clubhouse and in the community. Young players, from Rafael Flores to Konnor Griffin to Bubba Chandler to Esmerlyn Valdez, proved themselves to be big leaguers.

At the same time, it was only enough for an 82-80 record. Paul Skenes endured a frustrating season. Mitch Keller struggled before a season-ending injury. The Marcell Ozuna signing backfired, the bullpen was a weakness for much of the year and a team that relied on its defense in 2025 became a team that struggled in the field in 2026.

The Pirates improved, but not enough to get to where they wanted to get to. Here is the Post-Gazette’s Pirates report card for the 2026 season.

Advertise with us

Starting pitchers: C

2025 grade: A

It feels harsh to issue a C to a unit that had two All-Stars, especially when a third arm was just named as September’s NL Pitcher of the Month and a fourth is a rookie who made steady progress throughout the year. But for a group in which more was expected, a better grade cannot be handed out.

Pirates starters had a 4.23 ERA, ranking 16th in baseball, after finishing sixth with a 3.71 mark last year. They ranked in the top third in opposing batting average and WHIP and around the middle in strikeouts and walks. They ranked 23rd in innings pitched (786 2/3), a consequence of 17 bullpen games (not counting Carmen Mlodzinski’s 12 starts).

Starting with the All-Stars, Ashcraft’s 2026 was a resounding success. In his first year as a starter, he pitched 165 1/3 innings with a 3.65 ERA. Skenes’ numbers (3.82 ERA, 174 1/3 innings) aren’t all that different from Ashcraft’s, but they are a step back from the sub-2.00 ERA he posted in his first two seasons.

Jared Jones was unhittable in September, although he dealt with restrictions in his return from internal brace surgery. Bubba Chandler was much better after the All-Star break, even if he issued too many walks. Keller saw his season end in August with a 5.29 ERA, his highest since 2021 and far from his 2023 All-Star self.

Advertise with us

Bullpen: C-

2025 grade: B+

Since the trade deadline, the bullpen has been an outright strength for the Pirates. The issue for them, as for the Pirates in other areas, was it was such a weakness early in the year that it may have cost the team October baseball.

The bullpen blew 26 saves, 19th in baseball. Just nine of those came after the All-Star break. Before the trade deadline, they ranked 20th with a 4.31 ERA. After, they had a 3.54 ERA despite throwing 213 1/3 innings, third most in baseball.

Mason Montgomery was unhittable from July 27 onward. Lake Bachar and Mlodzinski were very good in bulk relief roles. Yohan Ramirez was worth 2.7 bWAR after the best season of his career. Gregory Soto was better than most realize.

But the issues showed in Soto’s six blown saves, too many implosions from Dennis Santana and Justin Lawrence and regression from Isaac Mattson, to name a few. The group got better, but their early-season woes were a big reason why the Pirates couldn’t weather their midseason skid.

Advertise with us

Catchers: B

2025 grade: D

Pirates catchers were worth 3.6 fWAR, ninth in baseball. Their 102 wRC+ also ranked ninth. The group combined for 29 homers, fifth most in baseball.

There are questions about what it means going forward, but Pirates catchers did produce in 2026. Among 61 catchers with at least 120 plate appearances, Endy Rodriguez’s 153 wRC+ is the best in baseball. Rafael Flores’ 147 wRC+ ranks third. Both were small samples, but also large enough that they can’t be discounted.

Henry Davis remains a glove-first catcher, with strong defensive marks but a .172 average, while Flores and Rodriguez have to make strides defensively. Still, the Pirates got much more production from their backstops this year.

Infield: B-

2025 grade: D+

Advertise with us

Lowe was fantastic. His 35 homers and 96 RBIs were the reason why Pirates second basemen ranked third with a 118 wRC+, while 13 defensive runs saved gave the Pirates the fifth-best second base defense by DRS.

But the Pirates didn’t get a ton out of the other three infield positions. Their first basemen ranked 25th in both DRS and wRC+, with two injuries to Ryan O’Hearn and an injury-affected slump hurting Spencer Horwitz. Shortstop defense was solid, as Griffin and Jared Triolo combined for the seventh-best mark by DRS, but Griffin’s injury led to an 84 wRC+, ranking 22nd.

Nick Gonzales batted .303, one of just seven players in MLB with an above-.300 average, but Pirates third baseman had a 99 wRC+, ranking 15th. Gonzales struggled defensively, as his minus-15 DRS at third was the worst in baseball.

Injuries certainly played a role, as the Pirates spent a good chunk of the season without O’Hearn, Horwitz and Griffin. But at the same time, there’s room for growth at three of four infield spots.

Outfield: B+

2025 grade: F

Advertise with us

The Pirates’ offensive boom was powered by their outfield.

Bryan Reynolds played in every game, led the majors in doubles and returned to his typical self. Oneil Cruz’s breakout year was derailed by injury, but he addressed his platoon weakness against lefties and posted a 20-30 season in just 97 games. Valdez hit 17 homers as a 22-year-old and won the NL Rookie of the Month award in July. The team’s 111 cumulative outfield wRC+ was fourth best in baseball.

There are things to criticize. The Pirates were in the bottom five defensively in DRS in both center and right field. Reynolds and Valdez both had significant slumps, including Reynolds’ regression from an .878 OPS and 14 homers in the first half to a .659 OPS and just three blasts in the second.

While that certainly played a role in the playoff miss, there was still more good than bad.

Designated hitter: F

2025 grade: D

Advertise with us

Perhaps it’s wrong to issue an F on a position based upon a player who was released in August. Then again, it’d be wrong to try to separate what players such as Lowe, Reynolds and O’Hearn did as designated hitters instead of at their primary positions.

The Pirates had better production when they started rotating the DH spot between those three, Cruz and Gonzales, but they got virtually nothing from Ozuna while he was active. In 70 games, Ozuna batted .203 with eight homers, a .612 OPS and a 68 wRC+. He also struggled against lefties, a weakness that his signing was meant to address.

Not only did Ozuna not hit, but rostering him hurt the Pirates defense, too. He was a model veteran, but that wasn’t enough to make his signing worthwhile.

Coaching: C

2025 grade: C+

The biggest thing a coaching staff can control is culture. The Pirates kept fighting all year. After losing 15 of 20, the team dragged itself back above .500. After being swept in Los Angeles, they went 19-9. Cruz, often criticized for a perceived lack of hustle, was sprinting in the final series of the year and tried to play through a left knee contusion in a meaningless game. Those are signs the coaches are doing something right.

Advertise with us

But it’s also impossible to argue that Don Kelly made every correct on-field decision, even if combustible bullpens make any manager look silly. It’s on pitchers to perform, but some did regress under pitching coach Bill Murphy. There were some baserunning mistakes — which, again, falls mostly on the players — but coaching isn’t entirely blameless.

Kelly and his staff have plenty of support inside the building, and the front office believes that the right group is intact. Still, there’s room for progress for Kelly and Co. in 2027.

Front office: C-

2025 grade: N/A

This report card only considers the 2026 baseball season, not the entirety of Ben Cherington’s seven-year regime. Perhaps it’s too generous after Cherington himself admitted “we didn’t win enough games.” After all, nobody would say it’s been a successful tenure after one winning season and zero playoff appearances.

But on a this-year basis, there were some shrewd moves. The trade for Lowe was one of the most one-sided deals in recent baseball history. O’Hearn has been a strong addition. The bullpen reinforcement at the deadline worked, helping stabilize the group for next season. A core is in place.

Advertise with us

However, the mistakes mattered. Signing Ozuna was a disaster. Regardless of what options were out there, the bullpen took too long to address. A lack of depth and non-bullpen trade deadline activity left them shorthanded for most of August, when realistic playoff hopes were sunk.

Progress was made, and Cherington’s front office deserves credit for some of the foundation they’ve helped lay. Still, in a year in which playoffs were the expectation, it wasn’t quite enough.