At this time last year, Esmerlyn Valdez was preparing for the Arizona Fall League. He was a 21-year-old outfielder, fresh off of a breakout year at High-A Greensboro and Double-A Altoona, but the Pirates weren’t certain whether they wanted to add him to the 40-man roster.

So they sent him to the desert. Valdez went on to lead the league with eight homers and 27 RBIs, finishing second with a 1.355 OPS and earning the league’s Offensive Player of the Year honor.

In November, the Pirates added him to the 40-man roster. By July, he was the National League Rookie of the Month.

The Arizona Fall League begins again on Saturday. The Pirates are sending eight prospects to Arizona to play extra baseball for the Glendale Desert Dogs, all hoping to match Valdez’s rise. Here are three storylines to follow in this year’s competition. All prospect rankings via MLB Pipeline:

Advertise with us

This year’s Valdez?

There are some similarities between Valdez and another Pirates slugger heading west.

Jhonny Severino, the team’s No. 28 prospect, had a breakout season at High-A Greensboro. He hit just .256 but finished second among Pirates minor leaguers (behind Murf Gray) with 31 homers and 95 RBIs. He’s just 21, like Valdez was, and he’s Rule 5 eligible this offseason. He could earn himself a spot.

Then again, there are some differences. Severino, acquired for Carlos Santana in 2023, was signed for $1.23 million by the Milwaukee Brewers out of the Dominican Republic to Valdez’s $130,000. Valdez is a right fielder, while the Pirates tried Severino at third base, left field and first base this year. Valdez had reached Double-A at this point and appeared in the All-Star Futures Game, while the Pirates kept Severino in Greensboro all season. There’s also some reason to be skeptical about Severino’s power, as homers were up across the minors this season.

But if Severino can shine in Arizona the way Valdez did, he could certainly end up in a similar spot — on the 40-man roster and part of the Pirates’ immediate plans.

Highest-ranked prospects

The two highest-ranked prospects the Pirates are sending to Arizona are No. 5 Wyatt Sanford and No. 8 Easton Carmichael. The two are in different spots moving forward.

Advertise with us

Sanford, 20, is heading to Arizona primarily to get more reps. He missed nearly two months at High-A Greensboro with a hand injury. He saw his power surge when healthy, as he hit 19 homers with a .963 OPS in 77 minor league games, but he also saw his strikeout numbers spike. Sanford could also see some time at second base, as the Pirates’ shortstop spot seems filled for the foreseeable future at the MLB level.

Carmichael, a 22-year-old catcher, is a more surprising selection after a full year between High-A Greensboro and Double-A Altoona. He hit .303 in Greensboro, compared to .244 in Altoona, but played in 111 games (including 80 starts behind the plate). He’s performed well as a catcher, so he was likely selected for more at-bats against upper-level pitching.

Both Carmichael and Sanford don’t need to be added to the 40-man roster until 2028, so there’s no Rule 5 pressure on either prospect. It’s worth following how both perform, as the Pirates see both as part of their future.

Which pitchers will benefit?

The Pirates are sending five pitchers to join the Desert Dogs, including right-handers Brandon Cain, Zander Mueth and Michael Walsh and lefty Cristhian Tortosa. Right-hander Bryan Mena will be a late replacement, a source told the Post-Gazette, as right-hander Cameron Keshock has a fractured rib.

Of those, it’s Mueth who has the most to show. The 21-year-old right-hander was the Pirates’ second-round draft pick out of an Illinois high school in 2023, following Paul Skenes, but injuries have held him to just 61 1/3 innings over the last two seasons. In 35 1/3 innings this season between Low-A Bradenton and the Florida Complex League, Mueth had an 8.66 ERA, walked 34 and struck out 28. He’s looking for innings and results.

Advertise with us

Cain, Walsh, Tortosa and Mena are relievers who are mostly there for added reps. Mena and Walsh both dealt with injuries, while Cain is a converted outfielder who had some success at Bradenton and Greensboro this year. Tortosa spent much of the year in Altoona.

The position players are the headliners, but there are still a few pitchers worth monitoring.