Colin Beazley: Hello from Milwaukee. Plenty to talk about today from the trade deadline to Mitch Keller's injury and more. Looking forward to taking as many of your questions as I can over the next hour.
Uncle Leo: Hello Colin! Kelly seems like a good guy and someone you’d like to see your team grow with. At the same time, there is clearly a lot of urgency to this season, and I can’t help but feel like a manager who’d won before (like Francona for example) would have squeezed at least five more wins out of this team to this point with better in-game decisions and mgmt of starters and bullpen. Most recently, I’m stunned that Kelly opted for a bullpen game to start the cincy series. Beyond the base running and errors, why can’t these guys hit sacrifice flys or bunt someone over? I hope we don’t regret what could have been…
Colin Beazley: Hello Uncle Leo! In my opinion, while I do think Don Kelly has made a number of questionable decisions this year, it's near impossible to evaluate exactly how many wins a manager is worth. There's so much that goes into decisions, including stuff that we don't know about. And no manager is perfect.
With the bullpen game, I get it. The Pirates are playing 17 games in 17 days with a number of young pitchers on limits and plenty of question marks. While managing health comes into it, the Pirates also saw that a number of their pitchers are more effective with one extra day of rest. And they almost won that game, too...
Sunner in Orlando from Lebo: Hi Colin, thanks for the chats! I was pleasantly surprised with the deadline additions in getting relief help without giving up too many of the top prospects. Does Carmen now go back into the starting rotation with Keller done for the year? Also, any timelines on Cruz, and Griffin coming back as we need their bats now that Ohearn might be done until the playoffs?
Colin Beazley: Hi Sunner, thank you for your questions! My expectation would be that Carmen Mlodzinski would go back into the starting rotation, but the Pirates have not confirmed that yet. Honestly, I'm not sure what other options they have. Maybe Antwone Kelly or Hunter Barco from Triple-A? Connor Wietgrefe has been Indy's best starter of late, but that would be a big jump after he was recently promoted.
Read More
I'd be very surprised if it wasn't Mlodzinski.
Gene: When is Cruz scheduled to come off the IL
mikomark: Since the Bucs' medical staff is not exactly transparent, I keep seeing that Griffin will return "sometime in September." True or False, Colin?
greg patton: where is Cruz at on returning to the lineup?
Michael: Realistically when can we expect Cruz to return? Because Mangum is playing so well doesn’t it make sense to keep him in center and DH Cruz?
Colin Beazley: Lot of Cruz questions (including yours, Sunner. Not ignoring you). I'll throw Griffin in here, too:
The last update we got on Ben Cherington's radio show (Sunday) was that Oneil Cruz's hand was healthy, they're just making sure all goes well in terms of him continuing to swing a bat. I'm not a hand specialist, but that's normal. Cherington was hopeful Cruz could begin a rehab assignment this week. He's first eligible to come off the 60-day IL on Aug. 8, I believe. That won't happen, but it doesn't sound like he's too far away.
Griffin's timeline was 8-10 weeks, with the care primarily being rest. He's been around the team. Given that the treatment is mainly rest, can't give much more of an update there other than he's itching to get back into games. We're at about five weeks here, so guess we'll start to hear a little more soon.
Colin Beazley: Also want to shout out the Pirates for actually being fairly transparent on injuries. Very few teams (maybe only the Pirates) have a team doc address the media for questions on a near-weekly basis like Tomczyk does. I've heard from other reporters that they wish their teams did what the Pirates do.
That said, sometimes they genuinely don't know. They also have had a few injuries this year where follow up scans showed a far-worse injury than expected. Know thats where the transparency complaints come in.
Sunner in Orlando from Lebo: Does Ozuna eventually get DFA'd or will the Pirates keep him around to mentor and help the Latin players because his bat has not been worth the 12 mil he is receiving.
Don kelly: Does Ozuna get dfa today ?
Colin Beazley: Time for the weekly Ozuna question (and what are you doing here, Donnie?)
His bat has not been worth 12 million, yes, but he gets paid regardless. The Pirates didn't trade for an Ozuna replacement. I don't think he's going anywhere.
Sunner in Orlando from Lebo: Do you think Skenes is protecting himself from injury not ramping up his fastball to the upper 90's or is there another reason for his declining numbers?
Colin Beazley: Paul Skenes changed his arm angle and isn't throwing as hard this season to help stay healthy over a long year. He's told me (and I've reported) that he's feeling much better physically at this point in the season than he has in years past.
I'm sure he didn't expect this level of decline in performance to come with it. I think it'll even out and he'll find solutions (i.e. he's not "washed") but I'm not counting on seeing 2025 Skenes (or even April Skenes) at any point again this year.
Mark: Why did BC wait so long to address the bullpen problems? It’s almost too late to rectify them now.
62 Stack Monster: Why didn't Cherington make these bullpen acquisitions earlier?
Colin Beazley: It would have been nice to have seen these additions be made sooner, but that's typically not how the market works. Teams want to wait as long as possible to drive up the trade markets and see where their team stands. For example, look at the Red Sox. They went from clear sellers in June to aggressive sellers at the deadline. Likewise, other GMs were able to play other teams off of each other and drive up prices as the deadline loomed.
I don't think the Mets would have done a Weaver for Stafura trade in July, as they would have wanted to wait to see if another team offers something better. The Marlins were potential buyers two weeks ago. I do think maybe something could have been worked out for Yates or Doval, but even then the Angels or Yankees might have wanted to see other interest.
Essentially, if you want to make a major trade weeks before the deadline, the other team has to be confident they won't get a better offer (which means a drastic overpay). Right decision or not, the Pirates didn't do that.
Mike: Colin, thanks for doing the chats, much appreciated. I think the Pirates are in trouble despite last night win. Keller now out for the year, O'Hearn with his injury may have put the final nail in the coffin. I think we needed another bat, DFA'D Ozuna, he is done. I think Carmen should take a spoke in the rotation and will help. Plus we need Lowe to start providing power again. Tell me I am wrong
Colin Beazley: You're wrong. (Sorry, you told me to!)
I'm more optimistic than you are mostly because I want to see how much addressing the bullpen actually helps. But I also don't disagree with any of your points on their own. Keller is a blow, even as much as he's struggled. Horwitz coming back makes me a little less concerned about O'Hearn, though he'll certainly be missed. I'm not expecting Ozuna to turn it around. I would have liked to have seen them add another bat against lefties -- even an Alex Call would have done. And I agree Carmen should be the one in the rotation and a few homers from Lowe would help.
Colin Beazley: That said, the Pirates are deeper than they've been in the last few years and have weathered several injuries. The offense remains strong. The rotation still can figure some things out and I'm encouraged by the last starts from Bubba/Ashcraft/Jones. The bullpen was the biggest weakness and, on paper, seems to be addressed. I do wish they'd made one more deal and they're still on the outside looking in on the wild-card race, but I'm not counting them as dead yet.
Dan N: Got to see both Carmichael and Murf Gray last week…Really glad those 2 weren’t included in any deals…
Colin Beazley: I'm a little surprised neither ended up being moved, but I'm high on both of them, too. Hoping to make a trip to Altoona soon and see both of them.
Greg: While everyone has been speculating about what's happened to Paul Skenes, the obvious has been overlooked---it's the "Cochran Curse"! Look what happened to Kenny Pickett after he appeared in their commercials...at least Skenes' car wasn't stolen while he was making them.
Colin Beazley: Could be the "Sheetz Scourge" too.
Gene: Is Weaver the closer or will they do it mix it up depending on the situation?
Colin Beazley: We asked Don Kelly about this yesterday and he did not call Weaver the closer. I'd expect Weaver to handle the highest leverage spot of the game, whenever that is, regardless of if that's the ninth. If 2-3-4 are due up in the eighth, I'd think that's when the Pirates will use Weaver instead of tying him to the ninth.
No issues with that, in my opinion. The new Pirates bullpen should be very flexible, which will be a good thing.
Michael Bleier: How much longer can the Pirates wait for O. Cruz to figure things out- hitting for average, fielding and base running. If he doesn't what can they get for him? Has his trade value declined over time?
Michael: Doesn’t it make sense to keep Mangum in center and DH Cruz when he returns? Mangum is really providing an excellent spark to the lineup.
Colin Beazley: Not sure if this is the same Michael who asked both questions, but you do realize Oneil Cruz was on pace for a 30/30 season, right? A career-best, .800+ OPS year? He was hitting for average and baserunning well when he was healthy.
That said, the Pirates could use Mangum more in center when Cruz returns now that Ozuna is no longer the penciled-in DH. Cruz is not going to be the full-time DH, as the Pirates like to rotate it, but that is an option. Mangum has performed well.
Pittfan: Hi Colin. Do you believe Esmerlyn Valdez is going to be a one season wonder or can we look forward to him being the Pirates everyday right fielder?
Colin Beazley: Not sure, but there are signs this is real. Shoutout to the NL Rookie of the Month.
While Valdez has slumped lately, he's also still drawing a ton of walks. Strikeout numbers are high, but he is getting on base. He was never going to continue the Linsanity run he was on for the rest of his career, but he has done the little things right to show that he is a major leaguer.
To be the every day right fielder, you need to do that and show some of the power that got our attention. I bet that'll return soon, but I'm not signing him to an extension just yet.
Michael: Can we look forward to a lot more bullpen games this season?
Colin Beazley: Kind of. Whoever it is in the rotation (it should be Mlodzinski) probably won't be a seven-plus inning starter. I'd guess Bachar will be a bit of a Mlodzinski replacement in the bullpen with Carmen back in the rotation, but he'll need to be built up again.
Ethan: Will the three new guys all be in uniform tonight?
Michael: when Sisk comes back who is he likely to replace in the bullpen?
Star Spangled Yinzer: What roster moves will be taken to work the new bullpen guys in?
Colin Beazley: I asked a couple people if all three will be active tonight. They weren't sure, but I'd expect we'll see them. I'm expecting Evan Sisk to be active, too.
I won't say exactly who I think will be optioned, but I will say that none of the three who pitched yesterday will be going anywhere. Four are coming in today (or tomorrow at latest I assume). Yohan Ramirez is out of minor league options and has earned his spot. There's your eight right there (or nine if you don't want to move Carmen to the rotation quite yet).
Ryan: Good afternoon Colin what do you think about the play of Yohan Ramirez so far this season i think he looked good vs Cincinnati on Thursday
Colin Beazley: Yohan Ramirez has quietly been very, very good lately. He's a fun player to be around in the clubhouse, so it's good to see him succeed.
cmose: cmose from LA. Now with the trades for bullpen help firmly in place what expectation for the final 2 months playoff bound?
Colin Beazley: CBeaz from LA! A playoff push is the expectation, I'd say. If this team continues the track it's been on pre-deadline and falls out of contention, that's a clear disappointment.
Pirates are shooting for playoffs "period full stop." They'll have to catch a few teams in front of them to get there, but they at least have a shot.
YinzerWally: unusual amount of injuries. I realize this is year 1 of the don Kelly regime but if you do analytics I bet you see that injuries game lost are at steep pace and could be significantly worse than Shelton.
Colin Beazley: I got an email yesterday of MLB teams by weighted severity of injuries. Here's the link from Rotowire, which shows the Pirates directly in the middle (I don't believe it's been updated for Keller's injury). The difference with the Pirates is, as a small market team, they don't have as many ready made replacements.
Pirates had been really fortunate with the rotation's health up until yesterday. The position player side has been hit hard.
Punxy Dave: Let’s see. Paul Skenes year one, Rookie of the Year. Paul Skenes year two, Cy Young Award. Paul Skenes year three, Ugh. Where does this go from here?
Colin Beazley: We'll see. In my opinion, the stuff that made him elite in years one in two will help turn this year into a blip. That said, that doesn't help the Pirates now in a year they need him to be better.
Randy: Do you expect any changes to how they approach left handed pitching moving forward? Such as callups or lineup changes? With zero bats added at the deadline and ozuna going nowhere this seems to be their greatest weakness.
Colin Beazley: I agree, especially when the teams around them have Imanaga, Sanchez/Luzardo and Rodriguez. I don't think there is an option in Triple-A to help -- that should be Password, but I can't say I've been too impressed with what I've seen so far. And it shouldn't be on Cruz and Griffin returning, Griffin's 20 and Cruz had struggled badly against lefties up until this year.
That's one of the reasons why Ozuna has stuck around. He's the only player on the roster who can singlehandedly fix that issue if he turns it on and hits. I'm not confident that that's coming around.
Michael: What do you think of the Brewer manager replacing his young starting pitcher in the middle of an at bat? No concern seemingly of hurting the kid’s confidence. Can you compare with how the Pirates handle their young pitchers. Which is the better approach?
Colin Beazley: I found that really interesting and I did feel like it showed up Sproat. That said, I follow a few Milwaukee reporters and the Murphy had made clear to Sproat that he needs to be better, so it's not like that came out of nowhere. He'll probably be optioned today.
As someone who grew up pitching, that would have killed my confidence. I didn't like it and would have wanted him to finish the AB. But the Brewers are also notorious for doing all the little things right, so who am I to criticize?
Mole: How are the pirates realistically going to address the rotation? 3/5 of the rotation is facing an inning limit soon.
Colin Beazley: Wrote about some options for Keller's spot in the rotation above, but if the Pirates were planning on shutting down Ashcraft/Bubba/Jones, there would have been more urgency to address the rotation. Evidently, they're confident these guys have enough in the tank to get through however long this season goes.
Frank the Tank: Can Oscar Marin please return??
Jim: Colin, Do you think the Bucs will get a new pitching coach soon?
Don kelly: Does the pitching coach return next year ?
Colin Beazley: Well it's kind of your decision, Donnie. But Bill Murphy's not going anywhere. While a message can get stale (Oscar Marin's apparently did), there are benefits to having a guy around for multiple seasons. I do think it's right to be a little bit critical of how the Pirates pitchers have performed this year.
Syd: What do you think will happen when Cruz comes back? Does Ozuna get DFA’d and Garcia stays or do you think they’ll keep Ozuna and send Garcia down?
Sunner in Orlando from Lebo: When Cruz does return do they keep Mangum in CF and DH Cruz or do the put Mangum in left and let Reynolds DH? I'd rather keep Mangum in CF and put Cruz in left but I doubt they want to reinvent the wheel on that front.
Rich in Hawaii: When Cruz returns, who is going to lose the most at bats, Magnum? Or could they slot him into DH more with Ohearn out?
Colin Beazley: Aloha, Rich. Answered one of your other questions earlier in this chat.
They're not going to move Cruz to a corner midseason. He will play center field a good bit, though the Pirates have a bit more flexibility with where they play him. I'd expect Mangum to lose the most at-bats (Reynolds and Valdez aren't being sidelined), though I do think it'll all be flexible with some shared DH at-bats and Mangum's versatility.
Buzz: With a lockout likely on its way do you think “the window” of opportunity to make the playoffs will still be open in 2028 if the 2027 season is lost? Also would the pirates consider trading Paul skenes that year even if they are contending similar to the tigers with Tarik Skubal?
Tourman: I'm approaching my mid 70s and possibly running out of time. Do you see the Pirates as being SERIOUS contenders any time soon? Would a strike be the best thing to happen to this team in the long term?
Aces High: I get the national media not wanting to go against the players union, but how do these long time reporters like Buster Olney and Jeff Passan continually report that a cap isn't needed and the Dodgers aren't good for baseball? 2 regions seem to be against a Salary Cap. NY and LA. The rest see the common sense in it. Why not the long time baseball reporters?
Colin Beazley: Sure, why not, a few salary cap questions as we go through the final few questions here today.
It's hard to predict the future given we don't know what baseball will look like in 2027. Maybe it's capped. Maybe it isn't. Maybe we miss the entire season. Maybe the Savannah Bananas take over. Who knows?
Under the current system, I do think the Pirates have a real chance in 2027 and 2028. The moves they made at the deadline set them up well for 2027 at least. There are some questions with how the salaries all fit with a number of first time arb eligible players like Skenes, but as of now, the only two players you'd want back that are not currently set to be back are Lowe and Soto. Everyone else is under control.
Colin Beazley: Does that make them SERIOUS contenders? Depends on your definition of SERIOUS. It's not the Dodgers, but it is a good team. And they are a good team this year.
I don't want to speak on behalf of the national media, but it would be tough to be against the players union and agents while continuing to maintain relationships there.
As for Skenes, the Pirates certainly won't let him go for nothing. The Tigers have a higher payroll and still got some return. As a lower payroll team, when the time comes, the Pirates will have to nail that trade.
greg patton: Nick G is not a 3rd baseman correct? - he needs to play 2nd base and let Brandon L DH but what do you do when Cruz returns
Steve: Nicky G loses more games with his glove at third than he wins with his singles. Should the Tree be permanently planted at third?
Colin Beazley: Don Kelly made the defensive replacement for Gonzales last night, even in a one run game, and it was immediately proven as the right decision. I'd expect we see more of that going forward.
Colin Beazley: Hit enter too soon, but don't think that defense allows Gonzales to be the long term answer at 3B. The slide over to second is almost certainly best for him. Pirates will have options next year if they don't re-sign Lowe.
Don kelly: I liked the bunt last night with the runner on 3rd and less than 2 out. Might we see more of that ?
Colin Beazley: It's your choice, Donnie! It was a good spot for a squeeze.
Sunner in Orlando from Lebo: With the bullpen additions, will Donnie have a shorter leash than a longer leash on the starters knowing he has better arms in the bullie than before the deadline?
Colin Beazley: It'll be interesting to see. Kelly kept the short leash even when the bullpen was in its previous state, so I doubt it'll get longer. But it's also hard to see that leash getting even shorter than it was.
My guess is it'll stay the same, but it'll look like better management when the new arms perform better.
South Texas Buc: Colin. If they lose another starting pitcher to injury who do they go to? Surely no one they have currently can fill in that role after the loss of Mitch. And a BP game every fifth day for a team chasing a playoff spot probably isn’t going to cut it.
Colin Beazley: I'd assume you'd have to go to a Triple-A arm after Mlodzinski (again, assuming it is Mlodzinski). Maybe it can be Khristian Curtis once he's back and healthy.
Ethan: What went into optioning Billy Cook and keeping 3 catchers? Seems like you'd want to optimize versatility on the bench, especially when they insist on giving one of those spots to a DH-only player who isn't hitting
Colin Beazley: I think Endy Rodriguez and Rafael Flores both playing some first base played into it. I see the argument here. Maybe Flores has an opportunity to be the platoon first baseman against lefties?
Molly: Do you think if they put Mlodzinski back in the rotation that they will use an opener for him?
Colin Beazley: That's entirely possible against teams with a lot of lefties. Think the Pirates will have to be creative with that spot, regardless of whether they go with the obvious and stretch Carmen back out or not.
MD Bob: I've been a Pirate fan for over 75 years and have never been upset about their play as this year. I really believe that Kelly has been the reason for what I think is another lost season. I go to bed at night unable to fall asleep thinking about the lost opportunities! I don't have many yeas left, but I'd like to see the Pirates be a contender.
Colin Beazley: Final question, from MD Bob...
Colin Beazley: I'm not saying you're right or wrong about the manager. No manager is perfect, etc etc. But I'll spin it this way -- isn't it nice that this is a team worth being frustrated over? Little the Pirates did at this point of the season last year mattered. This year, they've got intriguing young talent and a real chance (23.9%, per FanGraphs) at the playoffs.
They do some maddening stuff. 20 blown saves will do that to you. But this isn't yet a lost season.
The Pirates have problems, both before and after the trade deadline. I don't know whether they did enough to address them. But this is, at minimum, an interesting team.
We'll see how it all works out — and this year, it is a team worth watching.
Colin Beazley: Thank you all for participating in this live chat, much appreciated. Always fun talking with you guys. No chat next week, as I'll be doing a mailbag with the Monday off day, but feel free to email me or tweet at me with your questions. Thanks for following along!




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.