CINCINNATI — The worst month of Paul Skenes’ career ended in the fourth inning in Cincinnati.
The worst night of a brutal Pirates stretch had only just begun.
Skenes was charged with five earned runs for the second consecutive start, but the Pirates rallied back to take a two-run lead in the eighth. What followed was a bullpen collapse and a game-deciding error, as the Pirates lost to the Cincinnati Reds, 8-7, on Friday night at Great American Ball Park.
A bad loss got worse in the ninth, when Ryan O’Hearn pulled up running to first base with a quad injury. He was helped off the field and was using a crutch to navigate the clubhouse postgame.
“Every loss hurts, but to couple that with the loss of a guy like O'Hearn — nothing ever feels good when that happens,” Brandon Lowe said. “We're just praying that it's not as bad as it could be.”
It’s a gut punch, Don Kelly said, adding O’Hearn’s injury “didn’t look good.”
Read More
“We've shown a lot of resiliency, and this is going to be something that we’ve got to dig deep and find a way to overcome,” Kelly said. “Collectively pull together and find a way to get over this loss and with Ryan and be ready to play tomorrow.”
The reeling Pirates have lost four in a row right before the trade deadline. They are 55-56, under .500 for the first time since July 3.
They had a 7-5 lead in the eighth when Wilber Dotel came in to face 8-9-1 in the Reds order. Dotel allowed two singles to start the inning, struck out Elly De La Cruz, then allowed a game-tying, two-run single to first baseman Sal Stewart. It was the Pirates’ 20th blown save of the season.
Mason Montgomery was brought in to keep the game tied. He did his part, getting a routine groundout. After an intentional walk, Nathaniel Lowe hit a grounder right at Nick Gonzales that Gonzales caught, double clutched, then threw to Brandon Lowe at second instead of the easier play at first.
The throw was at Lowe, but Lowe couldn’t come up with it, allowing the game-winning run to score. Both blamed themselves postgame. Lowe was originally charged with the error, but it was changed postgame to Gonzales.
“I should have thrown it to first [and] got the out there,” Gonzales said, “so it's on me.”
“I just didn't catch it,” Lowe said. “[That’s the] biggest thing.”
The Pirates went quietly in the ninth against closer Emilio Pagan. They have now lost seven of their past nine.
On a losing streak, the Pirates needed a stop from their ace. Instead, Skenes was charged with five runs on seven hits and four walks in four innings. He threw 100 pitches.
The Pirates gave Skenes two runs to work with in the top of the first. O’Hearn beat out what would have been an inning-ending groundout when Stewart and pitcher Hunter Greene failed to get to the bag, then Gonzales had a two-out, two-run single. The hit extended Gonzales’ hitting streak to 15 games.
But Skenes couldn’t hold it. He allowed two two-out runs of his own in the first, then JJ Bleday’s leadoff homer in the third. He gutted through a 36-pitch first inning, threw 31 more in the third (and stranded the bases loaded), then allowed two more in the fourth on a De La Cruz triple and a next-pitch Stewart home run.
Skenes finished six July starts with a 6.25 ERA (22 runs in 31 2/3 frames). He’s felt like he’s thrown the ball “pretty well” in the past five. Friday was different.
“Today was just straight up the sloppiest outing of the year for me,” Skenes said. “... The month as a whole, I don't think has been terrible. Today was pretty terrible."
Antwone Kelly pitched three scoreless innings in relief, allowing two hits and two walks with three strikeouts. He was in line for his first major league win before the bottom of the eighth.
It was over when…
Gonzales was hit by a pitch with two outs in the ninth. Endy Rodriguez struck out and challenged the last pitch, a 3-2 fastball, but it was found to have nicked the outside part of the zone. The Cincinnati crowd, waiting for a postgame concert from DJ Marshmello, erupted.
On the mound
Skenes said it took him a full inning to find his delivery. It’s not unusual to take time to find a rhythm, he said, but it doesn’t typically take 36 pitches.
“Usually it doesn't look that bad in the first inning,” Skenes said. “Yeah, just pretty sloppy all around.”
He was looking forward to his next outing, something he doesn’t usually say.
“It's been an interesting year, a little bit, but it could be a lot worse,” Skenes said. “We'll figure it out. I'm gonna figure it out, but it could be a lot worse."
Dotel was the right choice for the eighth inning with two right-handers due up. His loss only magnified the Pirates’ need for a right-handed reliever. The trade deadline is less than 72 hours away.
At the plate
The Pirates scratched together five singles in the eighth against Caleb Ferguson and Pierce Johnson, including RBI singles from Henry Davis, Jake Mangum and Lowe. It was a streak-ending rally until it wasn’t.
Mangum went 2 for 5 with a third inning home run, a walk, a stolen base and the RBI single. The Pirates scored four in six innings against Greene.
While Don Kelly didn’t have a full postgame update on O’Hearn’s injury, which happened minutes prior, no one was particularly optimistic. Gonzales was emotional over the injury.
“That's a big-time player on our team, but also a leader. I love that guy to death and feel really bad for him,” Gonzales said. “Feel really bad for the team for losing him and everything. It's really unfortunate."
Bucs bites
• Before the game, the Pirates optioned left-hander Hunter Barco to Triple-A Indianapolis and recalled Kelly. The move was made for bullpen depth, as Barco threw 72 pitches on Thursday night.
• Evan Sisk (left elbow inflammation) will require at least one more rehab appearance in Indianapolis before returning to the Pirates, Don Kelly said.
• Both Rafael Flores and Spencer Horwitz seem to be progressing from their respective concussions. While Kelly did not offer an update pregame, Flores ran the bases and Horwitz took grounders pregame.
Up next
The Pirates and Reds will play the third game of their four-game series on Saturday at 6:40 p.m., if the weather cooperates. Rain is in the forecast for a matchup expected to feature Braxton Ashcraft (10-4, 4.05) against Reds lefty Andrew Abbott (5-6, 3.85). The game will be televised on SportsNet Pittsburgh and broadcast on the radio on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.