Colin Beazley covers the Pirates for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. Kyle Williams covers the Nationals for The Baltimore Banner. The Venetoulis Institute for Local Journalism founded The Banner in 2022, then purchased the Post-Gazette in April.

The Pirates (44-44) and Nationals (45-43) are in similar spots, hovering around .500 but in contention for a National League wild card spot.

Entering the season, the Nationals were expected to start a rebuild under first-year general manager Paul Toboni, while the Pirates were looking to finally deliver a winning season for Ben Cherington in his seventh year.

Ahead of the weekend series at Nationals Park, our reporters share some insider knowledge on each team:

Advertise with us

The Pirates and Nationals are in near-identical positions. How did they get here?

Kyle Williams, The Banner: The Nationals weren’t supposed to be this competitive in Year 1 of the Toboni regime. Not with such a young roster. Not after trading staff ace MacKenzie Gore. And not by relying on unproven pitchers Foster Griffin and Cade Cavalli at the top of the rotation.

But the Nationals have blown past expectations behind a dynamic and explosive offense that feeds off youth and athleticism on the bases. Entering Friday, the Nationals have scored the most runs in the majors despite having the fifth-lowest payroll. James Wood has been better than ever, doing a good job of curbing his slumps and lengthening out his hot stretches at the plate. CJ Abrams is hitting the ball harder and has increased his walk rate to 8.7%.

But the beauty of the team is the lineup’s depth. Luis Garcia is pairing his superb bat-to-ball skills with burgeoning power. Third baseman Curtis Mead, who was brought over just after the season began, has shown the promise that made him a coveted prospect from the Rays’ farm system. The offense has largely been able to compensate for an inconsistent pitching staff and woeful bullpen.

Colin Beazley, Post-Gazette: The Pirates expected to be in this spot, but this isn’t the path they expected to take.

Last year, they had one of the best pitching staffs in the majors. Paul Skenes was Paul Skenes, and a solid group behind him kept the Pirates in most games. The issue was a majors-worst hitting group that averaged 3.6 runs per game and managed to hit 31 fewer homers than the second-worst team in the category.

Advertise with us

The pitching hasn’t been nearly as good this year — the bullpen in particular is a significant weakness — but the offense has gone from the worst in the majors to among the best. Offseason additions Brandon Lowe and Ryan O’Hearn have been stellar and have helped elevate the group around them. Oneil Cruz and Spencer Horwitz were in the midst of breakout seasons before being sidelined with injuries. Bryan Reynolds has returned to his All-Star form. Oh, and that Konnor Griffin kid has been pretty good, too.

What’s holding them back?

KW: The bullpen’s consistent meltdowns are enough to make Nationals fans sick. Two sickening examples: They blew an eight-run lead in the eighth inning against the Giants, and they allowed the Phillies to become the first team in MLB history to hit go-ahead homers in the ninth inning of three consecutive games. The bullpen has the fifth-highest ERA in the majors (4.95) and struggles with walks, all leading to an MLB-worst 25 blown saves.

CB: Believe it or not, Pirates fans, the bullpen could be worse! The Pirates’ 17 blown saves almost seem insignificant by comparison, but the Nationals are at least better than 50% in save chances (26 for 51) while the Pirates are 17 for 34.

Pirates relievers have a 4.37 ERA overall, but it’s a 5.02 mark since April 27. Dennis Santana entered the year as the closest thing to a closer, but his ERA is 5.09. Justin Lawrence was projected to be a key setup man, but he’ll be in the other bullpen this weekend. Gregory Soto is the closer but had a 13.50 ERA in June.

The Pirates have lost 12 games when scoring six runs or more. The bullpen is the biggest reason why.

Advertise with us

Who is your team’s MVP?

KW: Abrams makes this a conversation, but I would have to go with Wood. Aside from leading off, Wood is the catalyst for the lineup. This season, he has shown a more discerning eye at the plate and currently leads the National League in walks. He’s first in runs scored (75), fifth in on-base percentage (.389) and third in offensive WAR (3.4).

CB: Surprisingly, it isn’t Skenes. While he still may be the Pirates’ lone All-Star in 11 days, the Pirates have far more deserving players.

As good as Lowe has been, Reynolds gets the nod. He reeled off a 34-game on-base streak that ended recently and leads the team with an .854 OPS. He’s played every game so far, key for a team that has struggled with injuries. Reynolds was rightly criticized for a subpar 2025, but he deserves plenty of credit for the year he’s having.

What do you expect to see from your team at the deadline?

KW: Can I put a shrug emoji? But in all seriousness, the Nationals enter this series two games above .500 and two games back of the third wild card spot. I don’t expect the Nationals to do more than add minor rotation arms. The goal for the new regime is to build a sustainable winner through player development, so now isn’t the time to trade from the farm. I do think they’re more likely to stand pat than, say, deal Abrams, which many thought was possible entering the season.

CB: Despite being behind the Nationals in the race, I do expect the Pirates to buy barring an especially bad July. It’s been more a decade since the Pirates’ last postseason appearance in 2015, so any opportunity to end that drought and add to just three playoff appearances since 1992 is worth pursuing. Bullpen help is the No. 1 priority and would make a huge difference.

Advertise with us

How important is this series — and what will make the difference?

KW: This series is important for the Nationals. It’s the beginning of a nine-game homestand that takes them into the All-Star break. The offense will likely need a big weekend to secure their third straight series win.

CB: The difference, as it always is with the Pirates, will be starting pitching. They need starters Mitch Keller, Braxton Ashcraft and Bubba Chandler to give them length.

The Pirates haven’t been two games above or below .500 since June 10. They’ve finished five of seven road trips 3-3. In a month that includes series against the Braves, Brewers, Yankees, Cubs and Guardians, a series win against a wild card rival would be key.