There are plenty of mile markers in a major league season.

Fifty games is one. Sixty games is another, for those who believe 50 is too few. Memorial Day matters. So does June 1.

Somewhere in between stand the Pirates. They’re 30-28, two games above .500. They’ve hovered at or just above .500 every day since the sixth game of the season, when they improved to 3-3. They’ve never been more than five games better than equilibrium but haven’t been under it since March 31.

It’s too early to say, with 100% confidence, that the Pirates will miss the playoffs. But it’s also late enough to say that the data we have is real.

Advertise with us

“We've had some ups, some downs, some adversity,” manager Don Kelly said. “We continue to fight. … I think the guys have continued to prepare and compete really well during the games.”

It’s worth starting with the Pirates’ standing in the National League Central. Entering Saturday, they’re in last place despite a .517 winning percentage. The Milwaukee Brewers (34-20) are comfortably above .500, once again bettering expectations, followed by the St. Louis Cardinals (30-25), Chicago Cubs (31-27) and Cincinnati Reds (29-27, a percentage point ahead of the Pirates).

“This division has shown how tough it is so far,” Spencer Horwitz said. “I wouldn’t say we’re standings watching, but every game is going to matter at the end of 162.”

Never before have all five teams in a division had a .500 or better record at this point in the season. There are more teams above .500 in the NL Central than there are in the entire American League. It’s highly likely that’ll change during the next 100 games.

The Pirates entered the weekend series against the Minnesota Twins having scored 276 runs, fifth most in baseball. They’ve had four 10-plus-run outbursts. They’ve also been shut out six times.

Advertise with us

They’ve hit 61 homers, 13th most in baseball. Their team OPS of .723 ranks seventh.

“As a whole group, when we control certain things, we can beat teams a lot of different ways,” hitting coach Matt Hague said.

While those numbers were helped by Oneil Cruz’s early-season heater and strong play from Brandon Lowe and Ryan O’Hearn, it appears sustainable overall.

Konnor Griffin has been able to make an immediate impact. His numbers have remained constant as O’Hearn has missed time, Cruz has slumped and Marcell Ozuna has contributed very little.

Injuries are concerning, but at a minimum, the group is deeper. It’s certainly better than last year’s majors-worst lineup.

Advertise with us

Starting pitching has been a strength as well. Pirates starters had a 3.56 ERA entering the weekend, sixth best in baseball. Four of the five teams ranked higher lead their divisions.

Again, health permitting, those numbers seem sustainable. Paul Skenes remains Paul Skenes, even if his last three starts made him appear normal. Braxton Ashcraft is in the midst of a breakout campaign. Mitch Keller is Mitch Keller. Those three give the Pirates enough stability to keep pitching a strength, although there are plenty of unknowns with Bubba Chandler and Jared Jones.

It’s a deep group, one with plenty of talent.

“A lot of really good pitchers on this staff,” Jones said. “It’s going to be fun to be a part of it.”

But there are significant weaknesses, ones that have prevented the Pirates from fully capitalizing on their strengths.

Advertise with us

The bullpen has been most alarming. While the group’s overall ERA of 4.19 entering the weekend ranks 18th, middle of the pack, their 12 blown saves (in 22 opportunities) are the second most in baseball. Just two other teams have a save percentage below 50 percent: the Detroit Tigers and Los Angeles Angels, both 22-35 entering the weekend.

Maybe moving Carmen Mlodzinski to the bullpen will help stabilize the entire group. If not, there’s not a lot of other internal solutions. The bullpen’s near-collective slump has continued for more than a month, and beyond Gregory Soto as the closer, there are plenty of question marks.

Sure, the group could return to their early-season form (a 3.17 ERA before April 27 was a top-five mark in baseball), but it’s also possible the struggles continue.

Mlodzinski will have a key role in determining what happens.

“The value that he brings out of the ’pen like that — to be able to throw high-leverage, multi-inning, big innings for us — [is something] that, quite frankly, we need out of the ’pen,” Kelly said.

Advertise with us

Defense has been an issue, too. Entering the weekend, the Pirates have committed 35 errors, fifth most in baseball. Their .983 fielding percentage ranks in the bottom five.

The outfield has been worth negative-9 outs above average, the worst in baseball. The outfield’s negative-9 fielding runs value (FRV) is second worst. Griffin has committed seven errors, fifth most in baseball, while Nick Gonzales has below-average metrics at third.

The Pirates sacrificed defense for offense in the offseason. Griffin will continue to get better, though there still are concerns.

The Pirates are what they are as the first real milestones come up: an average team with some clear strengths, but also some alarming trends.

There’s reason to believe their strengths will keep them competitive. Yet in a historically good division, there are some real holes to address.

Advertise with us

I’ll be watching …

Marcell Ozuna’s return to Atlanta. Late May is when Ozuna has gotten himself out of his worst slumps across his career, but he still entered the weekend series batting .186. He had hits in four of five games entering the weekend, but his average barely budged. Ryan O’Hearn should return this week. That isn’t expected to lead to an Ozuna decision, but it could cut into his playing time.

Dennis Santana’s confidence. It’s no secret that Santana hasn’t been himself, as his ERA ballooned from 0.69 on April 25 to 4.94 entering the weekend. He has walked batters in three consecutive appearances and went nearly three weeks between strikeouts in early May. Santana has the experience and track record to recover. The Pirates need him to.

How the Pirates fare in a tough June. May isn’t quite done yet, but the Pirates were in a relatively soft part of the schedule. In the next few weeks, the Pirates will face the NL-best Atlanta Braves, the two-time reigning champion Los Angeles Dodgers, dangerous Athletics and Seattle Mariners teams and the Philadelphia Phillies, among others. There aren’t easy games in the majors, but it’s shaping up to be an informative June.

They said it …

“I was hard on this body. I played all sports — or tried to at least. Football is hard on the body. Baseball is hard on the body. When you don’t know how to take care of yourself, it leads to complications down the road. Early in my career, I think that’s a lot of what I’ve dealt with. Now, with the understanding of how to take care of my body, how to do preventive work, it makes it a lot easier to be healthy” — Braxton Ashcraft

Prospect pictures

No. 7 prospect Antwone Kelly had a rough start to life in Triple-A Indianapolis, allowing 15 hits, 10 earned runs and nine walks in his first two starts (6 ⅔ innings). He didn’t get out of the first inning in his third, walking three and allowing five unearned runs. But he’s settled down since, pitching to a 3.61 ERA in his last nine appearances over 42 ⅓ innings entering the weekend. In his last appearance on Thursday, he spun 5 ⅓ scoreless innings with four strikeouts. There are things to work on in the minors, as the 22-year-old has given up a few too many homers. However, if he continues to improve, he’ll be in line for a major league debut later this season and can become the first Aruban pitcher in the majors since 2009.

Advertise with us

On deck

H-Town Proud

The Houston Astros rank among the most disappointing teams in baseball, though they’ve been playing better of late. Three of their starting pitchers, including ace Hunter Brown, and closer Josh Hader are on the injured list, which is a big reason why the Astros have a team ERA above 5.00. Only the Colorado Rockies have a higher ERA.

Brilliant Braves

After finishing 76-86 in 2025, the Atlanta Braves have the best record in baseball in 2026. They’re healthy, their pitching is among the best in the league, and Matt Olson and Drake Baldwin have been stellar. On the plus side for the Pirates, they seem likely to avoid Cy Young contender Chris Sale.

Bottom of the ninth

By moving Carmen Mlodzinski to the bullpen, the Pirates are acknowledging just how dire their relief situation is. Few would deny that Mlodzinski has been better than Bubba Chandler this season, but Mlodzinski should be a better reliever than Chandler would be and the Pirates need a better bullpen more than they need a better rotation right now. Mlodzinski is more valuable for the Pirates in relief, even if the rotation is what gives the bullpen a lead to protect. However, it’s also tough to blame Mlodzinski if you see it from his perspective. He’s done all the Pirates have asked of him and has performed well enough to continue in his dream role, only to be demoted because of how others have performed. The move will help the team win, but it doesn’t mean Mlodzinski has to be happy about it.