ST. LOUIS — After yet another rough night for the bullpen on Tuesday, the Pirates are shaking up their relief corps.
The Pirates recalled right-hander Wilber Dotel from Triple-A Indianapolis on Wednesday, sources told the Post-Gazette. In his place, they optioned right-hander Isaac Mattson.
Dotel, 23, is the Pirates’ No. 11 prospect, per MLB Pipeline. He made his MLB debut earlier this season and had a 1.35 ERA in 6 2/3 innings with the Pirates. That included four perfect innings against the St. Louis Cardinals.
Mattson, 30, entered the season as one of the Pirates’ top setup options but has pitched sparingly in recent weeks. He has made just five appearances since April 30, allowing multiple runs in two of those. Prior to that rough stretch, Mattson had posted 15 consecutive scoreless outings.
“Tough decision with Matty. He's meant a lot to us,” manager Don Kelly said Wednesday. “There's some things that we've targeted for him to be able to work on when he gets down to Indy. Just looking to get Dotel up and had to make a move. And Mattson had options left.”
The Pirates are 8 for 20 in save opportunities this season. Their 12 blown saves are tied for the most in baseball. Only one team, the Los Angeles Angels, has a lower conversion rate than the Pirates’ 40%. Save opportunities are not just limited to the ninth inning.
Read More
Pirates relievers have a 5.86 ERA since April 27, the second-worst mark in baseball. Only the Cincinnati Reds’ bullpen has been less effective.
“It’s something that we continue to talk about, continue to beat up,” Kelly said after Tuesday’s loss in which the bullpen gave up six runs on three homers. “What we’ve talked about, too, there’s gonna be opportunity for guys, guys who are currently on the team [and] externally, as well. Just looking for guys to step up and claim that opportunity.”
Analysis
Optioning Mattson is one of the few moves the Pirates could make without designating someone for assignment. Yohan Ramirez and Justin Lawrence, who both have ERAs above 8.00 in May, are both out of minor league options.
Dennis Santana, who has a 9.64 ERA this month, is also out of options, though it seems far less likely the Pirates would cut ties with a player who entered the bullpen’s rough stretch as the closer.
“We're trying to get better, having conversations on what that looks like, the urgency to get better and to win games,” Kelly said Wednesday, asked if he hoped changing the makeup of the bullpen would change results. “It's vital that we find a way to continue to do that. And that is going to be through guys that are in the bullpen right now. They've done it before, they've got good stuff, and I think that we've seen flashes of that throughout the course of the season. 'How do we not put too much pressure on ourselves and allow our elite stuff to play?' is the balance that we're trying to strike right now.”
Mason Montgomery, who has been strong throughout the season but allowed key homers in each of his last two outings, said as much after Tuesday’s loss.
“We’re a little frustrated with the results, but you can’t get hung up on that,” Montgomery said. “We just gotta keep working and keep focusing on what we need to focus on. It’s a long season, so there’s plenty of time to get back on the saddle.”
Perhaps Dotel can help the Pirates find some results. He’s the latest new reliever hoping to stop the bullpen’s slide, as the Pirates have brought up Chris Devenski, Brandan Bidois and Cam Sanders without a shift in the group’s fortunes.
Dotel shouldn’t be seen as a savior, but he does appreciate the faith.
“It feels good to be here and for the fans and organization to have the trust in me to come here and try to do my job,” Dotel said, with major league coach Stephen Morales translating. “That’s what I’m trying to do, come here and try to help the team win. Anytime I have the ball in my hands, I want to do my best.”
Kelly declined to share specifics on Dotel’s role, though he noted he can pitch multiple innings. Dotel pitched in relief in two of his three most recent appearances in Indianapolis.
Mattson’s 6.00 May ERA isn’t the highest on the Pirates, but he hasn’t been as steady as he was earlier in the season and in 2025. He’s been a staple of the bullpen since he was last recalled June 7.
Just Evan Sisk (0.93) and Gregory Soto (3.12) have largely avoided bad outings this month, as Pirates relievers’ other May ERAs include Bidois (4.15), Montgomery (5.39), Mattson (6.00), Devenski (7.71 since April 29), Lawrence (8.31), Ramirez (8.59) and Santana (9.64). While one bad appearance can balloon a reliever’s ERA, no one has necessarily been safe.
Moving away from Mattson and adding Dotel isn’t the most drastic change the Pirates can make with their bullpen, but it is a shakeup. If struggles continue and the Pirates continue their four-game slide, bigger shifts could follow.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.