SAN FRANCISCO — Any walk-off loss is ripe for overreactions, but Sunday’s 12-inning defeat to the San Francisco Giants at Oracle Park brought one story to the forefront.

The Pirates have problems in the bullpen, and they’re searching for solutions.

Since April 27, the day after the bullpen completed a scoreless series in Milwaukee, Pirates relievers have a 6.65 ERA. That number actually improved Sunday.

Sunday illuminated the issues, as twice the bullpen blew a two-run lead. When Bubba Chandler was pulled early, a decision made partially because the bullpen was rested, Isaac Mattson gave up a two-run lead within four batters. And in the 10th, the Pirates gave Yohan Ramirez a 6-4 lead he couldn’t hold.

Advertise with us

“We can always look back on tough moments,” manager Don Kelly said after the 7-6 loss. “We had chances to win. Sometimes you focus on one thing or another. There were so many opportunities in that game for us to score more runs, hold them. Unfortunately, it just didn’t go our way.”

Mattson is one of multiple Pirates going through a rough patch. He’s made just three appearances since April 30, giving up multiple runs in two. In those appearances, he’s been charged with seven runs on six hits and two walks in just 1 1/3 innings.

He gave up five runs in 2/3 of an inning against the St. Louis Cardinals, threw a strikeout for a final out in Arizona then had Sunday’s tough outing.

“Going back to the last outing at home, I just felt like I wasn’t in the zone enough,” Mattson said. “Too many walks and put myself in a bad spot. The outing in Arizona, I felt like I came in, executed when I needed to, picked up a teammate and tried to do my job there. And [Sunday], just kind of wearing it on the chin more than anything else.”

Kelly has faith in the right-hander to rebound.

Advertise with us

“He’s a fighter,” Kelly said. “He’ll bounce back.”

Mattson’s not the only leverage arm struggling.

Dennis Santana, who entered this poor recent stretch as the Pirates’ closest thing to a closer, has allowed six runs in his last 4 2/3 innings. He escaped Sunday in part because Gregory Soto came in for the final out of the inning.

Ramirez, too, is struggling. He was a revelation to start the year, posting a 1.54 ERA in his first eight appearances, but he has gradually returned to Earth. He’s allowed eight runs, seven earned, in three May appearances spanning 4 1/3 innings. Most concerningly, he’s hit two batters in consecutive outings.

Justin Lawrence had been better prior to the Giants series. The sidewinder had a streak of seven scoreless appearances snapped Friday, when he allowed three runs in four batters. He then gave up another run Sunday.

Advertise with us

He was somewhat of a tough-luck loser with the automatic runner and a Ryan O’Hearn misplay in the series finale, but he still has a 6.46 ERA.

The Pirates’ two mop-up men have struggled, too. Cam Sanders allowed two runs, walking three, in the final inning of Saturday’s 13-3 blowout. Chris Devenski allowed a run in two of three appearances before he was suspended then placed on the injured list with an undisclosed illness.

Prior to Sunday’s game, the right-handers in the Pirates’ bullpen had a 10.80 ERA dating back to April 27, allowing 24 runs in 20 innings. It’s the worst mark in baseball.

“We’ve got to be in the moment more than anything else,” Mattson said, making clear he was including himself. “I don’t want to speak for everybody, but I think as a bullpen we definitely left some things on the table that we can get better at. Just being able to focus on the day that we have right in front of us.”

There have been positives, notably the lefties.

Advertise with us

Mason Montgomery retired all five batters he faced on Sunday and now has posted 11 consecutive scoreless appearances, dating back to April 5. In 11 innings, he has 13 strikeouts to just four walks.

Evan Sisk has quietly been consistent, lowering his season ERA to 1.80. He’s allowed one earned run in his last 11 innings.

And the biggest standout in the Pirates’ bullpen is Soto, who seems to have usurped Santana as the closest thing to a closer. He lowered his season ERA to 1.33 with 1 1/3 scoreless on Sunday and he has allowed just two baserunners over seven consecutive scoreless appearances.

“He’s been lights out,” catcher Henry Davis said. “He’s been tremendous in the back end. Really good stuff.”

The Pirates have largely been able to weather their relief struggles, still going 6-7 in the last 13 games. However, a sub-.500 pace won’t snap their postseason drought.

The Pirates need solutions fast. Can they find some?