SAN FRANCISCO — Before Don Kelly managed his 163rd baseball game in charge of the Pirates on Friday night, he was asked to reflect on the previous 162.

On May 8, 2025, previous manager Derek Shelton was fired. Kelly took over for the rest of the season, inheriting a team with a 12-26 record and low morale. He went on to earn the permanent title, entering May 8, 2026 with a better than .500 Pirates squad and positivity around the team.

He feels he’s learned, but he wouldn’t say he’s gotten comfortable.

“Every day is different when you’re talking about what comes up on a daily basis,” Kelly said before his team’s 5-2 loss to the San Francisco Giants on Friday night. “I don’t know if comfortable is the right word. We have a great staff, I love the players on the team and that’s a big part of moving forward and continuing to feel good about things, knowing everybody is putting in what they need to do to help us win tonight.”

Advertise with us

He also knows he’s made mistakes. He has felt the game slow down for him, a good sign as he’s gotten used to his managerial position and the constant decisions that come with it.

“When you’re talking about communicating with the players and staff, no, I can’t sit here and say I have been perfect,” Kelly said. “There are things you learn from as you go. I do feel like I have gotten better in some ways, but still a long way to go.”

His Pirates have a 21-18 record entering Saturday night’s game. Last year, the Pirates didn’t win their 21st game until May 28, when they were already 15 games under .500 and well out of playoff contention. This year’s Pirates seem positioned to stick around.

Through the first 163 games of his managerial career, the Mt. Lebanon native has an 80-83 record. It’s not a playoff pace, but it is a definite improvement. His players notice a difference inside the clubhouse, something Kelly helped facilitate.

“He's one of the best human beings,” right-hander Carmen Mlodzinski said. “Just a very quality human being, and somebody who cares a lot about the game. And obviously, he has such a strong attachment to the city. He's from Pittsburgh. Of anybody in this clubhouse, he probably wants us to win more than anybody, right? He's just grown up a fan. Now he's able to manage this team at the highest level. I think it's obviously very special for him.”

Advertise with us

Bryan Reynolds, who saw the bulk of Shelton’s tenure, sees that difference too.

“The culture’s really good. Good vibes,” Reynolds said. “I think he kind of got that started last year with us, and us as a clubhouse have kind of taken it from there.”

His biggest strength, players say, is his consistency. Kelly takes pride in being the same guy every day, which be thinks helps his players and uses as a mantra for himself.

It helps in good times, like the early season five-game winning streak, and in bad times, like several portions of 2025 and this year’s Cardinals sweep.

“That's something we all can appreciate, is he's never been too high or too low,” Mlodzinski said. “He's always just been kind of himself, which I think is more than good enough to do the job that he does.”

Advertise with us

Reynolds agreed, adding he hasn’t noticed any difference between Kelly in 2025 and 2026.

“He just knows the game, knows baseball, and he’s a good guy,” Reynolds said. “[He’s] just being himself.”

But it doesn’t mean Kelly’s unchanging. While he leans on advice from Jim Leyland and others in “being himself,” he’s also trying to make progress as a manager. As he made decisions earlier this season, some that worked and some that didn’t, he made sure to go to his staff for feedback and debate those moves.

That preparation and review process has evolved, Kelly said.

“I’m still learning a lot in regard to the role, communication, relationships and decision-making,” Kelly said. “ ... It’s just something that I challenge our players, our staff, I even talk to my kids about it — how do you continue to get better and work every day to do that? That’s something we’ve done and will continue to do.”