Last month, as he addressed the media during the tail end of the Pirates’ first homestand, general manager Ben Cherington delivered a quote that caught my attention.

He was asked about his team’s outfield defense. It had been nothing short of atrocious from the first inning of the season — and Cherington wasn’t exactly surprised.

“Probably about what we expected,” he said on April 7. “It’s still probably a little early to know for sure where we’re going to land. The work’s certainly been there. The effort that those guys are putting in and the review of the games has been consistent in terms of how they’re reviewing it and learning from it.”

At that time, Cherington’s answer flew under the radar. Not only was the season less than two weeks old, but rookie phenom Konnor Griffin had just arrived. A day after that quote was delivered, the Pirates made Griffin the highest-paid player in franchise history.

Advertise with us

That was the story. But now, the issues in the outfield can no longer be overshadowed.

On Tuesday, the Pirates’ outfield woes struck yet again. It was the bottom of the first inning. The Arizona Diamondbacks had two outs and a runner on second base. Rookie right-hander Bubba Chandler had been shaky but was only one pitch away from escaping the jam before things truly went south.

Ildemaro Vargas sent a drive to deep right-center field. Although the ball was struck well, it had plenty of carry, allowing Oneil Cruz and Bryan Reynolds to track it down. Both of them were in position to make the catch. Neither did. Instead, the ball fell to the outfield grass, allowing the runner on second to score.

Chandler, who had just thrown his 23rd pitch, was visibly bothered by the mishap. Cameras caught him yelling into his glove after his two teammates failed to make the play. That frustration immediately impacted his performance, as he walked the next two batters.

He eventually regrouped and recorded the third and final out but not until after he threw 15 additional pitches. By then, the damage had been done. Once again, the Pirates’ outfield defense had dramatically altered a game.

Advertise with us

A bad pairing

With manager Don Kelly serving a suspension Tuesday, bench coach Kristopher Negron addressed the media in his place following the loss. He was asked about the latest fielding blunder.

“I was talking with some of the guys. The wind was swirling a lot up there,” he replied. “When the ball carried, it started going more and more into the gap. I haven’t talked to them completely about the play, so I can’t give you anything on that, but throughout the game, even the balls that were barreled out to center field were kinda moving around and not moving as far as we thought.”

I can’t be the only one who’s tired of these excuses. On opening day, it was the sun. During the home opener, when Cruz and Ryan O’Hearn nearly collided, it was because of crowd noise. On Tuesday, it was the wind.

At what point can they just call it like it is?

The outfield defense is a major issue, something that’s holding this team back from reaching its true potential. It all falls on the shoulders of Cruz and Reynolds. It’s still early May, but by now, the Pirates should have seen enough to understand these two simply can’t play next to each other.

Advertise with us

Let’s start with Reynolds, who deserves the bulk of the blame for Tuesday’s mishap.

He’s struggled with balls in the gap all year, and this was no different. In some cases, it’s been due to his inability to track the ball down. But that wasn’t the case this time. He was in perfect position to make the catch but pulled up, likely out of fear he’d collide with Cruz.

Cruz, meanwhile, had a far more difficult route to the ball. When Vargas made contact, he was shaded more toward left-center, leaving him to cover extra ground. He still could have likely tracked down the deep fly, but he was correct to assume it was Reynolds’ play.

The fact these two were yet again not on the same page highlights the larger problem at hand.

Neither Reynolds nor Cruz is a good defensive outfielder. The former used to be. Reynolds was a Gold Glove finalist in 2021. Since then, he has regressed dramatically. Since 2022, he’s boasted a negative fielding run value and outs above average every season, this year included.

Advertise with us

Cruz, on the other hand, remains a wild card. His fielding metrics are worse than Reynolds’ — largely due to a few egregious mishaps that negatively impact his overall body of work. He’s shown progress at times, but every two steps forward are often met by at least one step back.

The solution

Cruz might eventually figure things out, and Reynolds could perhaps get by as an everyday right fielder. But neither is going to improve playing alongside the other on a day-to-day basis.

I’m not insinuating they don’t get along. I haven’t heard or seen anything throughout my time around the team to suggest that would be the case. Some players just don’t jell together on the field. That’s the reality here.

I’m also not suggesting the Pirates should get rid of Cruz or Reynolds — at least not right now, anyway.

Both are key players within the organization. Both are hitting the ball well and are an overall net positive to the team. But their respective values diminish when playing alongside each other in the field, and the Pirates aren’t in a position to settle for less from anyone on the roster.

Advertise with us

Marcell Ozuna’s continuing struggles at the plate offer an easy solution. Reynolds and Cruz need to see more time at designated hitter. You still get both bats in the lineup, and by removing one of their gloves from the field, the team as a whole gets better — especially its greatest area of strength.

The most frustrating part about the Pirates’ outfield defense is the impact it has on the pitching staff. Chandler’s outing Tuesday was a perfect example.

Had Reynolds caught the ball hit by Vargas, Chandler would’ve finished the first inning with a reasonable pitch count and only one run allowed. He still had adjustments to make, but he was still in position to go reasonably deep into the game if his execution improved.

But as noted above, the outfield mistake changed everything. Chandler lost his composure and let the inning go far longer than it needed, something he acknowledged after the loss.

“Plays could be made, but at the same time, I gave up a hit or I gave up the ball in the air. Like, don’t do that,” he said. “There’s no reason the six hole or whatever it was should be having an at-bat in the first. Plain and simple, shouldn’t have walked [Corbin] Carroll. Down 0-2, walked him. It’s pathetic.”

Advertise with us

After logging 38 pitches in the first frame, the fact Chandler delivered five complete innings with no additional runs allowed should be considered a win. It could have — and should have — been a better outing, which he knows. But right now, he’s a young pitcher, one who can’t afford extra mistakes while he’s on the mound.

And he’s not the only one in this camp.

The big picture

The Pirates’ pitching staff has plenty of talent, but a lot of that talent is raw.

A handful of their arms can struggle to find the strike zone. That issue, paired with workload restrictions that loom over them each day they arrive at the ballpark, create a unique mental challenge. They know there is little margin for error, and when you’re unable to trust those behind you in the field, that only further complicates things.

For a team built to win through its pitching, defense cannot continue to be this big of a problem. Bill Murphy’s staff doesn’t need eight Gold Glovers in the field, but it deserves a team that can make routine plays — or even mildly difficult ones.

Advertise with us

The infield has, for the most part, met that criteria. The outfield has not.

It’s still early May, but Cruz and Reynolds’ defensive woes have existed long before this season. Individually, they’re bad defenders. Together, they’re a disaster.

Cherington and the front office don’t need more time to think it over. There’s nothing more to be learned here.

Playing Cruz and Reynolds next to each other hurts the team. It’s time for this undeniable fact to be addressed.