The Pirates recalled Jared Triolo from his rehab assignment on Saturday, improving the team’s makeup and defensive capabilities while also creating an interesting question.

What to do with Nick Gonzales?

Triolo is a Gold Glove defender who has struggled to find consistent offense during his major league career. He’s a defensive upgrade over Gonzales at third base, but Gonzales has hits in 11 of his last 12 games and is hitting .333, the fourth-best mark in the majors. He’s batting .457 over that span.

To recall Triolo, who had been on the 10-day injured list since April 5 with a right knee patellar tendon injury, the Pirates optioned Nick Yorke to Triple-A Indianapolis.

Advertise with us

Yorke, 23, made the opening day roster and had gotten off to a hot start, but he saw his playing time slashed as manager Don Kelly stuck with Gonzales’ hot bat. Yorke was hitting .379 on April 12, but he has batted 4 for 39 since. He had made one start in the last 10 days.

On Wednesday, Kelly had called the looming decision “a good problem to have.” He reiterated that Saturday, saying that they’ll have to find the balance between Triolo and Gonzales’ playing time as the season continues.

“We’re going to have to figure that out as we go,” Kelly said. “Gonzo has been doing a great job offensively, and he’s gotten better defensively, and [we are] just finding ways to to get them both in. I think that was a challenge with Nick Yorke, too. If Nick’s here, how do we find time for all three of them? Was going to be really challenging.”

He added he didn’t know if it would be a 50/50 split between the two. He said both could start against left-handers, while Triolo’s versatility makes him an option at all four infield spots.

Triolo batted .278 with a homer and three RBIs during his rehab assignment. He played two games at Low-A Bradenton and three at Double-A Altoona, going 5 for 13 with the Curve.

Advertise with us

“It feels good,” Triolo said. “Seeing everybody, they’re all excited. Ready to get going.”

Kelly has a couple of different options, but the situation is different than it was at the beginning of the year now that Konnor Griffin is entrenched as the Pirates’ starting shortstop.

He could have Gonzales and Triolo alternate starts, as they did early in the year. He could also stick with the hot bat, as he did with Yorke, then Gonzales while Triolo was out.

Perhaps this allows Triolo to move into a utility role, where he may be best suited.

While his best offensive stretch of 2025 came in a period when he was starting on a daily basis, a reserve role for Triolo could keep Gonzales and Griffin in rhythm. Triolo could even serve as a late-innings defensive replacement, the way Jake Mangum and Billy Cook have been in the outfield.

Triolo’s return gives the Pirates options, though it also creates the question of which player to go with and how to divide playing time at third base. But with Gonzales’ bat and Triolo’s glove, it’s a good question for the Pirates to have.