MILWAUKEE — So what makes a strong start sustainable?

The Pirates have gotten off to a solid start to the season, entering Friday’s series in Milwaukee with a 14-11 mark. Sure, it puts them in fourth in an uber-competitive National League Central, but it’s also a 90-win pace.

There are reasons for optimism, but in Pittsburgh, any strong start will come with a healthy dose of skepticism. It was just three seasons ago that a 20-8 start spiraled into a 76-86 year.

But one of the few holdovers sees a difference.

Advertise with us

“We just have a whole different team than what we had in ’23,” right-hander Mitch Keller said. “We had some good pieces then, but I just feel like we have a more complete package of a starting rotation and our hitting and fielding are probably a lot better than that. I don't know the stats behind that, but it just feels different.”

Before getting into the feel, it’s worth looking at the numbers. In a 25 to 30 game sample size, the Pirates have gotten off to strong starts in 2013 (17-12), 2018 (17-11), 2023 (20-8) and now in 2026 (14-11).

2013 ended with 94 wins and a playoff berth. 2018 brought a better than .500 record (82-79), the best mark since 2015 but not enough for postseason play. 2023 spiraled.

2026 remains to be seen.

In 2013’s start, the Pirates had a .244 team batting average, a .708 OPS, hit 31 homers (roughly 1.0 per game), averaged 4.1 runs scored per game, had a .291 batting average on balls in play, a 3.77 team ERA, a 4.30 FIP (fielding independent pitching), and allowed 4.0 runs per game.

Advertise with us

Each largely stayed consistent, allowing the team to maintain its hot play. Batting average (.245), OPS (.709) and BABIP (.294) were all essentially the same, so when the pitching improved (3.26 ERA and 3.42 FIP), it was more than enough for a playoff spot.

In 2018, the numbers dipped some. Through 28 games, the Pirates batted .260 with a .743 OPS. The pitching numbers (4.00 ERA, 4.3 runs allowed per game) remained constant, but when the offense dipped to .254 and .725, the team was just above average and nothing more.

The 2023 numbers were where a difference was clear. The team started the year batting .267 with an .802 OPS, scored 5.5 runs per game, hit .309 on balls in play, and had a 3.41 ERA, 3.68 FIP, and allowed 3.6 runs per game.

By the end of the season, those numbers were a .239 batting average, a .707 OPS, 4.3 runs scored per game, .296 on balls in play, a 4.60 ERA, a 4.40 FIP and allowed 4.9 runs per game.

None of the 2026 numbers scream regression the way some of 2023’s did. The team entered Friday batting .247 with a .718 OPS, averaging 4.9 runs per game and hitting .303 on balls in play. The pitching has predictably been a strength, as the team has a 3.45 ERA, a 3.70 FIP, and allows 4.1 runs per game. On the surface, each seems sustainable.

Advertise with us

Keller thinks it can stick, in part because he doesn’t think they’ve reached their ceiling.

“We're not even playing that great of baseball,” Keller said. “I think everybody in here would say that we could all do something a little bit differently on a personal level, which I think will help our team be even better. I think we haven't even hit our stride yet, which is encouraging.”

Manager Don Kelly agrees the start can be maintained. He was the bench coach in 2023, but prefers to avoid direct comparisons between teams whenever possible.

“I don’t believe we’ve played our best baseball yet,” Kelly said. “There are things that we can get better at. We can continue to grow and learn through some of these experiences that we’ve gone through and continue to compete.”

Perhaps interesting — or perhaps just a sign that Kelly’s messaging has taken hold — is the fact that both Keller and Kelly had the same response to how to make the start sustainable.

Advertise with us

Neither referenced strong starting pitching (though that needs to continue) or better-than-average offense (also true), but instead, stayed focused mentally.

“Just staying consistent in our attitude and effort every single day coming to the yard, which I think we have a really good group of guys to do that,” Keller said. “I think just consistently showing up every single day is what's gonna set us apart from years past.”

Kelly agreed. Sure, error-free baseball will help, but he also referenced the fight his team showed in Wednesday’s win in Texas and in coming back from losses.

“For me, as we continue to go through the season, continue to get better and play cleaner baseball at times,” Kelly said. “I think that’s something that stands out. If we continue that mindset, continue to get better, it’s sustainable as we go through the season.”

I’ll be watching…

… Konnor Griffin’s at-bats. Griffin, who turned 20 on Friday and celebrated his birthday with a homer, wasn’t at any risk of getting benched or being sent down even before the blast. The Pirates believe there’s value to continuing his development in the majors, which makes sense given he will be their major league shortstop for the next decade. Griffin had a hitless series in Texas, but it’s worth being patient with him. However, I’ll be watching whether he seems comfortable, like he looked in the most recent homestand, or if the discomfort from Dallas continues.

Advertise with us

… what’s up with Bubba Chandler? Chandler seemed to have found his command in his last two starts, only to walk three and hit another in a loss on Thursday. There’s no question that the stuff is there, but consistency is what’s missing with Chandler. I’m still confident that Chandler will find what he’s searching for and become a very good pitcher for the Pirates, but the combination of erratic command and hard contact when in the zone on Thursday raised some concerns.

… Nick Yorke’s slump. Yorke’s 3 for his last 32 (.094) dating back to April 12, but he’s also still in the 89th percentile for hard-hit rate (52%) and whiff rate (16.4%) this season. Each has remained consistent during the slump. However, he’s in the ninth percentile for launch angle sweet spot percentage, a fancy way of saying he doesn’t hit enough line drives. Minimizing strikeouts and hitting the ball hard generally leads to success, but Yorke may need to tweak his launch angle to get out of his slump.

They Said It

A smiling Paul Skenes, on celebrating Konnor Griffin’s 20th birthday on Friday: I had talked with [Jake] Mangum about doing something for Konnor, but a bouncy house would have been a little tough in the clubhouse, so. That was the idea that was thrown out. I think the cake, I have a feeling we'll see more cakes this year. I mean, he turned 20. Big whoop. Who cares.

Prospect pictures

I’d expected the Pirates’ farm system to be top-heavy with the bulk of their best prospects in Triple-A or the majors, but both Indianapolis and Altoona have struggled to start the year. Greensboro and Bradenton have both been interesting to follow. No. 7 prospect Wyatt Sanford, who I wrote about Monday, already has as many homers at Greensboro as he did last season. No. 2 prospect Seth Hernandez is doing Seth Hernandez things and has dominated in Bradenton, including five scoreless innings with one hit and nine strikeouts on Friday, while No. 18 prospect Murf Gray has three homers and an OPS above 1.000 and could also be a promotion candidate. Finally, No. 3 prospect Edward Florentino is healthy again and has two homers in five games in Bradenton. He’ll join Greensboro soon. Sure, the real test always comes in Altoona and Indianapolis, but the next wave of Pirates prospects look like they’re beginning their moves up.

On Deck

Central Cee

Advertise with us

The Pirates are in the midst of 10 games in 10 days, all against NL Central competition. All five teams entered Saturday above .500, including next week’s foes the St. Louis Cardinals (four games) and the Cincinnati Reds (three games). Considering how competitive the division has been so far, each has added importance.

Hometown kid

It was expected to be a rebuilding year for the Cardinals, but they entered Saturday in the hunt in the Central. Jordan Walker’s eight homers are part of the reason why, but so too is Mars graduate JJ Wetherholt. Wetherholt, MLB Pipeline’s No. 5 overall prospect, leads the Cardinals in stolen bases (four) and is second in homers (three) as the team’s starting second baseman. The 23-year-old was selected out of West Virginia two picks before the Pirates took Konnor Griffin.

Bottom of the ninth

This week’s entire situation between now-Ranger Andrew McCutchen and the Pirates was weird. For one, it was weird to see him in a Rangers uniform. Another is that McCutchen, the Pirates’ three-time reigning media good guy award winner, is almost always accessible, but he avoided his locker pregame and only spoke postgame, when all the traveling Pittsburgh media showed up in the Texas clubhouse. By not wanting to talk, then declining to answer questions on the Pirates’ communication and his feelings about leaving, he made his thoughts clear. I think the Pirates made the right choices and improved their team with their offseason moves, and I can’t say I blame McCutchen for wanting to continue playing. I hope McCutchen can be welcomed back and recognized by the Pirates in the future, but it’s a shame his playing career is ending this way.