The Pirates beat the Washington Nationals, 2-0, on Wednesday night at PNC Park. Carmen Mlodzinski earned the win, improving to 1-0, while Nationals starter Jake Irvin dropped to 1-2. Dennis Santana pitched the ninth for his second save of the season.
The Pirates scored both runs with two outs in the first on RBI singles from Marcell Ozuna and Nick Gonzales. Mason Montgomery pitched the first inning as the opener, Mlodzinski threw six, then Gregory Soto and Santana finished the shutout.
A full recap can be found here. Below are three of the Post-Gazette’s takeaways from the contest.
Why the Pirates used an opener
When the Pirates approached Mlodzinski about using an opener, he wasn’t thrilled. He’s said before that his career goal is to be a starter, so a move to the bullpen — even for one inning — felt like a demotion.
“I think it's a reality check for me,” Mlodzinski said.
Explaining the move pregame, manager Don Kelly said it was because the Nationals use a lot of lefties atop their lineup. Montgomery is effective against lefties, so it made sense to match him up against James Wood, Daylen Lile and CJ Abrams.
Read More
Left unsaid was the part Mlodzinski considered a reality check: In three starts, Mlodzinski has really struggled to get lefties out. Opposing lefties entered batting .355 against him with a .813 OPS. Those splits aren’t consistent with prior years, but it was still enough for Kelly to make the move — and for Mlodzinski to be bothered by it.
“I need to be better against left-handed batters,” Mlodzinski said, noticeably a little miffed despite the strong outing. “I want to progress as a pitcher and be able to handle both sides of the plate equally. Especially as a starting pitcher, it's super important. I don't want to just be a matchup-based pitcher. Little bit of a reality check to be able to push forward and say I need to be better getting left-handed hitters out.”
Regardless of whether Mlodzinski pitched mad or not, he was especially effective Wednesday. He allowed just two hits in six innings, although he did walk two more and hit a batter.
With the exception of Abrams, who reached in all four plate appearances (including against Santana in the ninth), Mlodzinski generally mowed down the Nationals. He struck out five, lowering his ERA to 1.77.
“Carmen came in and was really, really good tonight,” Kelly said. “It looked like everything was a little bit better synced up delivery-wise from Chicago. It was in the zone. Stuff was electric. He was able to throw everything for strikes and then go for swing-and-miss, too, when he needed to.”
And the opener, Montgomery, did his job well, too. Right-handed Curtis Mead doubled, but Montgomery was able to get out of the inning scoreless.
“I appreciate the opportunity,” said Montgomery, who now has four consecutive scoreless appearances. “I think it just helps to show I'm capable of doing whatever I need, and ultimately, that's what I want to be able to do. Just whatever they need from me, go out there and get the job done.”
Could it be used more?
After the strategy worked perfectly Wednesday, it’s worth asking if it’s repeatable.
Could the Pirates always do this? Does this guarantee a shutout every single time? Have they broken baseball?
The answer: not really. And it’s not a unique strategy, as the Tampa Bay Rays used openers 42 times between May 2018 and 2019. But it may work particularly well with Mlodzinski.
Mlodzinski continued to struggle against left-handers on Wednesday, as each baserunner he allowed (a walk, a hit batter and a double by Abrams; a Jorbit Vivas single; walking Luis Garcia Jr.) was left-handed. He also has experience pitching out of the bullpen, so the routine shift isn’t as jarring.
“I'm willing to do whatever they want,” Mlodzinski said. “Kind of have done a little bit of everything. Nothing's going to surprise me. It's just making sure I'm prepared, which I was going into this one for sure."
Braxton Ashcraft and Bubba Chandler also have experience in relief. However, they don’t have the same splits or struggles a third time through an order, so there’s not the same incentive. There’s certainly no need to get fancy with Paul Skenes or Mitch Keller. They’d likely only try it with their fifth starter: Mlodzinski.
If the Pirates use an opener later in the season, perhaps it could be Jared Jones, at least to start. Jones’ pitch count will have to be monitored, so while he’s ramping up, maybe he’ll throw two or three innings before they turn to Mlodzinski.
Jones is still a month-plus away from returning, where he’s eligible to come off the injured list in late May or early June, so it’s too early for Kelly to consider that type of strategy. But speaking pregame, Kelly didn’t rule out future openers.
“If there would be an opportunity in the future that we thought made sense with another guy, I think we'd have that conversation,” Kelly said. “Wouldn't want to close the door on that. But felt like this was one that made good sense to try today.”
Coming back, getting even
While it’s early, the Pirates have not lost games on consecutive days yet this season. Their only consecutive losses came in the first two games in New York, on March 26 and 28. Since, they’ve responded to every loss with a win.
That continued Wednesday. The win, plus the five-game winning streak against the Reds and Orioles, have contributed to the Pirates’ 11-7 start.
“I just see a bunch of guys that are showing up every day to compete and win on that day, not worried about the day before,” Kelly said. “How it went, whether it was good, bad, indifferent. They're showing up, having fun, working hard every day.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.