BRADENTON, Fla. — Andrew McCutchen’s second tenure in Pittsburgh has officially come to a close.
The Texas Rangers have signed the 2013 National League MVP to a minor league contract with an invitation to spring training, a source confirmed to the Post-Gazette. McCutchen will compete for a major league role on a Rangers team that struggled offensively last year and got little production from primary designated hitter Joc Pederson.
McCutchen, 39, wanted to return to the Pirates, the team that he had spent more than a decade with from 2009 to 2018 and again on three consecutive one-year deals from 2023 to 2025. The former first-round pick is a five-time All-Star, a four-time Silver Slugger winner, a Gold Glove award winner and the Roberto Clemente Award winner in 2015 — all in his tenure with the Pirates.
However, the Pirates seemingly signaled their intentions with McCutchen in early February when they announced they had signed designated hitter Marcell Ozuna to a one-year, $12 million deal.
“As far as I’m concerned, Andrew will always be a Pirate,” Pirates general manager Ben Cherington said at the time. “I think most people feel that way. I certainly speak for the organization and that’s how we feel, that no matter what Andrew is a Pirate, and certainly our desire will be to continue to have a really strong relationship with him into the future, whatever that looks like.”
McCutchen never ruled out playing elsewhere, always saying he wanted to continue his career.
Read More
He vocally shared his disappointment with the Pirates throughout the offseason, including an impassioned reply — since deleted — where he said he wished he could have been at PiratesFest, said “this was bigger than baseball” and added, “Rip the jersey off of me. You don’t get to write my future, God does.”
When the Ozuna signing was announced, he removed all mentions of the Pirates from his social media bios.
Still, part of the reason McCutchen wanted to continue playing was because of his desire to win with the Pirates.
“If this was a team that wasn’t very good and I was looking at it again like ‘I don’t see it,’ I’m probably home,” McCutchen told the Post-Gazette in September. “I’m probably just packing it up and just, what’s the point of putting me and my family through this? But ultimately, I do feel like this is a good team.
“I’d just love to be a part of that winning. Hopefully get that opportunity to have that again. And I do feel like it’s possible. If it wasn’t possible, I don’t think I’d be doing it. Maybe I doubt the Pirates would even bring me back. I think it’s there.”
At the same time, McCutchen did say the Pirates were “beating the same drum” in terms of how they’d operated over the past few offseasons.
The Pirates had a different offseason this year, trading for All-Star second baseman Brandon Lowe, signing first baseman/outfielder Ryan O’Hearn to the first multi-year contract the franchise had given out since 2016 and then bringing in Ozuna.
They also did things differently by moving on from McCutchen, instead of re-signing him to a fourth consecutive one-year contract.
On Thursday, a few longtime Pirates were glad McCutchen was able to continue his career. Right-hander Mitch Keller, one of just three current Pirates who joined McCutchen on the 2023 opening day roster, was “disappointed” the Pirates didn’t re-sign him.
“I think any team could have benefited from him on a roster, because he’s just — one, he’s a great player, and he’s just a great human being,” Keller said. “Disappointed that we couldn’t get him over here. Obviously, I think, just having been here with him the last three years, he’s been vital for me personally and just everybody in this locker room that’s got to spend time with him.”
Outfielder Bryan Reynolds figured McCutchen wouldn’t be back once Ozuna was signed. Still, he’s glad McCutchen is still playing.
“You always root for your friends,” Reynolds said. “Hope he makes the team out of spring, like I said, and has a great year for them.”
Keller recognized that McCutchen was an all-time great Pirate.
“He truly emulates what a Pittsburgh Pirate is: hard work, day-to-day going through the grind and playing your hardest,” Keller said. “So yeah, it sucks that he’s not here, obviously, but I’m really happy for him. Looking forward to playing against him again.”
If McCutchen earns a major league role with the Rangers, the Pirates will face their former star when they visit the Rangers in Texas on April 21 to 23.
While McCutchen has not announced how long he wants to continue playing, Thursday’s news makes it less likely that McCutchen retires with the franchise that he had his best seasons with.
McCutchen will always be known as a Pirate, but he may play his final baseball games in a Rangers uniform.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.