BRADENTON, Fla. — The battle for the fifth starter spot is underway at Pirates camp. Five pitchers are fighting for the final spot in the rotation, as left-hander Hunter Barco and righties Jose Urquidy, Carmen Mlodzinski, Thomas Harrington and Mike Clevinger are all under consideration for the role.
It’s still early, but major league games will be played later this month. All candidates have performed well so far, something that gives manager Don Kelly confidence.
“It’s going to be tough decisions, whether we’re talking fifth starter or bullpen, bench spots,” Kelly said. “Guys are playing well. It’s a cool thing to see the competitions that are going on. … I’m looking forward to seeing how the rest of camp shakes out.”
Paul Skenes, Mitch Keller, Braxton Ashcraft and Bubba Chandler should have rotation spots locked down, while Jared Jones is on track to return to the majors once eligible to come off the 60-day injured list in late May.
Here’s a look at how the others have performed through the first week-and-a-half of games:
Jose Urquidy
Urquidy is the toughest to evaluate, as he made just one start in a Pirates uniform before Tuesday’s game against the Colombian national team at LECOM Park. On Tuesday, Urquidy pitched three scoreless innings and allowed just two hits and a walk, striking out three, though the lineup he faced did not include any hitters currently playing in the major leagues.
Read More
The previous outing was so-so. His line isn’t pretty, as Urquidy was charged with three earned runs on two hits and two walks in 1⅓ innings. However, two of those runs came after Urquidy hit his pitch count and was removed for a minor leaguer.
The 30-year-old’s experience likely gives him the inside track for the No. 5 role, but it’ll certainly be a competition for Urquidy.
“I know we’ve got a lot of starters here, so I’m here to compete to win that spot,” Urquidy said. “They know I’m able to be in the starting rotation or relieving, wherever they want me. … I’m trying to compete, trying to put hitters away. That’s what I’ve got to do.”
Carmen Mlodzinski
Despite his success out of the bullpen in 2025, the Pirates are once again giving Mlodzinski the opportunity to start in 2026. A big part of the reason is a splitter he’s developed, part of the reason for his 2.15 ERA as a reliever and his overall 1.93 ERA in the second half.
He’s relied on the splitter heavily so far, using it the majority of the time in his most recent outing on Monday. So far, in two outings (one start and once in relief), Mlodzinski has completed 4⅓ innings and allowed one run on three hits and two walks. He’s struck out five.
Mlodzinski, 27, is in a unique spot, given his 2025 success makes him a lock to start the season in MLB. Starting can help the Pirates, while they know what they have in relief. He’s enjoying the depth the Pirates had.
“Overall, it’s been fun and competitive,” Mlodzinski said. “At the end of the day, this year compared to the other years I’ve been with this club, we’re definitely deeper and we definitely have guys who can go multiple innings, which is always nice in the bullpen.”
Hunter Barco
Barco, 25, made his major league debut at the tail end of 2025, appearing twice in relief on the final road trip of the season and pitching three scoreless innings. After compiling a 2.81 ERA in 27 appearances (23 starts) at Double-A Altoona and Triple-A Indianapolis, Barco comes into 2026 with momentum and as a top-100 prospect (No. 96, per MLB Pipeline).
He’s confident in his offseason work, saying he was hoping to prepare himself to throw 150-160 innings in 2026 and handle a major league workload after his first healthy season in 2025. He’s also drastically increasing his arsenal, adding a sinker, a changeup and a sweeper to his previous three-pitch mix of a four-seam, a slider and a splitter.
It’s worked so far. He’s pitched 4⅓ hitless innings, allowing just one unearned run. The downside is he’s walked five, though six strikeouts and 19 whiffs (on 35 swings) shows just how filthy Barco’s stuff is. He has a shot if he can continue that, something he embraces.
“That’s definitely the goal, to go out and win a job,” Barco said.
Thomas Harrington
Harrington’s been in this position before and actually made his major league debut with a start on the Pirates’ season-opening road trip in Tampa Bay last season. The rest of the season was a struggle for him, as he allowed 15 runs in 8⅔ major league innings. He struggled in Indianapolis, too, finishing with a 5.34 ERA there before a groin injury shut him down in August.
The 24-year-old has made just one spring training appearance so far, allowing one run in two innings against the Boston Red Sox. Harrington walked two and didn’t have any strikeouts.
Harrington is confident in the offseason work he did, saying he’s healthy and that he’s learned from his taste of the big leagues. Adversity helped him grow, he believes, and he’s excited for the competition.
“It's really exciting to have a group that's so deep and that are able to compete with each other and then obviously make each other better,” Harrington said. “So yeah, just excited to get rolling. It'll be a great spring.”
Mike Clevinger
Clevinger, 35, is the lone non-roster invitee with a shot at the rotation. He signed a deal in early February and has made two appearances so far, pitching five scoreless innings and allowing three hits and four walks with four strikeouts.
He brings a different angle to the competition, as he’s pitched in the big leagues since 2016 and has made 142 major league starts. Clevinger is also pitching with essentially nothing to lose, as he’s on a minor league deal and has already had major league success. His fastball got up to 97 mph on Monday.
The Pirates would have to make a roster move to add Clevinger to the 40-man, but he has shown he still has something to offer. Whether it comes as major league rotation help, in the bullpen, or just as Triple-A depth, it’s somewhat intriguing.
“Looking at this team, and we could do something special,” Clevinger said. “So whatever it is to help this team win, whether it’s long relief, starting, back and forth, just trying to get October is the main goal.”
Wild cards
It’s far more likely than not that the final rotation spot comes from the five names up top, but a few others have performed at major league camp ...
Right-hander Wilber Dotel, 23, has made two appearances for the Pirates, winning both games, and allowed two runs on six hits and a hit batter in four innings. He’s struck out four. … 22-year-old right-hander Antwone Kelly rebounded from a tough opening outing to pitch three innings of one-run ball against the Cardinals. He has left Pirates camp to pitch for Team Netherlands in the World Baseball Classic. … 23-year-old right-hander Khristian Curtis, a non-roster invitee, has also been a pleasant surprise for the Pirates. While he allowed two runs in an inning against the Red Sox, he pitched 1⅔ scoreless innings with a walk and three strikeouts against the Cardinals.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.