A rare Honus Wagner trading card whose existence was unknown to the public for nearly 120 years has sold at auction for $5.124 million.

It is the third-highest sale price for the iconic T-206 card featuring the Hall of Fame Pirates shortstop and Carnegie native.

The card was featured in the third season of the Netflix series “King of Collectibles: The Goldin Touch.” It had been owned and preserved by brothers Dennis and Douglas Shields of California since their grandfather, Morton Bernstein, pulled the card from a pack of Sweet Caporal cigarettes in or about 1909.

The Shields brothers consigned the card to Goldin Auctions on the show.

Advertise with us

“I’ve never been able to trace a Wagner that has stayed in only one family since the day the card came out,” Ken Goldin, CEO of Goldin Auctions, said in a statement. “The Shieldses’ care and respect for their grandfather’s collection have preserved one of the hobby’s true grails, and the importance of this cannot be overstated.”

The card’s scarcity can be traced to its removal, at Wagner’s quick insistence, from packages of various brands of cigarettes sold by the American Tobacco Co. Theories about why include that Wagner was adamantly opposed to smoking and his belief that American Tobacco didn’t pay him enough for use of his image.

Previously, a T-206 Wagner sold privately for $7.25 million in August 2022, and another sold for $6.61 million in August 2021 to an undisclosed buyer at auction. Both of those cards also were graded in better condition than the Shields Wagner, as the card has become known in the sports collectible community.

The Shieldses’ nephew, Matthew Salter, told The Mercury News of San Jose, Calif., that he wasn’t sure what his uncles would do with the money.

“Neither of them are big spenders,” he said.

The Shields Wagner is the 16th T206 Wagner to sell for at least $1 million, according to the online database Card Ladder. A 17th will join that club when it sells on Heritage Auctions. With three days remaining in the auction, that card carries a high bid of $2.38 million.