BRADENTON, Fla. — When the remaining position players report to Pirate City next week, barring something unforeseen and frankly very strange, Andrew McCutchen will not be among the group. The feeling will be a little odd.
At the same time, it likely won’t be long before McCutchen winds up in camp somewhere in either Arizona or Florida.
After the Pirates decided to move on from McCutchen by agreeing to a one-year, $12 million contract with Marcell Ozuna on Monday, we’re left to ponder the age-old question of, “What’s next?”
There are a few layers here, but let’s actually start with this: Neither side is wrong. It’s simply unfortunate that it had to end this way.
The Pirates had the worst offense in baseball last year. They say they’re trying to compete in 2026. Their biggest previous impediment was offense. Meanwhile, among the 25 MLB designated hitters who logged at least 200 plate appearances last season, only three were worth fewer wins above replacement (minus-0.2) than McCutchen.
There’s obviously context missing — a lack of lineup protection, the fact that nobody was very good and the fact that the Pirates probably asked more than they should have out of someone who should’ve been cast as a bottom-third-of-the-order hitter.
Read More
It’s also hard to blame McCutchen for feeling hacked off.
For all he’s done for the Pirates, plus the role he’s played for baseball in Pittsburgh, not to mention living up to his contract of the past three years … McCutchen is the one they decide to jettison with the possibility of winning baseball ahead?
Both sides have valid points and gripes. We’re also not going to reach a definitive conclusion that pleases everyone.
But the world does keep on turning — and we’re likely not far off from seeing McCutchen in another uniform, which would be his fifth other than the Pirates.
Sources close to McCutchen indicated that he’s very much interested in continuing to play, something he stated himself last season — he’s not done. Where that happens is the intriguing part.
Two potential destinations are plenty familiar to Pirates fans — the Cleveland Guardians and St. Louis Cardinals. Those are somewhat realistic. There are also two long shots.
In St. Louis, there’s been a youth movement, and McCutchen would obviously add plenty in that department. He also knows the NL Central and could have the chance to play some outfield, which McCutchen has insisted he’d have no problem doing. Ivan Herrera is their primary designated hitter option and will play, though there should be room for another experienced bat.
It’s not a contending team but certainly one that could seemingly benefit from what the 39-year-old has to offer and could promise some level of playing time on a young roster.
In Cleveland, the Guardians were reportedly one of the teams who checked on Ozuna before he signed with the Pirates. While they have a few young outfielders (George Valera and Chase DeLauter), McCutchen could potentially help.
There’s no real designated hitter to speak of, though Progressive Field is one of the worst conditions-wise for right-handed hitters. (Busch Stadium, for what it’s worth, is middle ground for righties.)
Now, the extremes. The Blue Jays didn’t land Kyle Tucker and lost Bo Bichette. They could theoretically play George Springer in the outfield and have reportedly been in the mix for another bat. Springer has been hit-and-miss against lefties in his career, something McCutchen still does well, and McCutchen wouldn’t have to wear any sort of mentor hat.
Rogers Centre in Toronto is also a top-10 ballpark for right-handed power, which would be music to McCutchen’s ears after his frustrations the past three years with PNC Park’s dimensions.
It would be a similar contending-team scenario in Chicago, where the Cubs have been in the market for a part-time DH to pair with 22-year-old Moises Ballesteros, who’s a left-handed hitter.
Unlikely? Yes. But at the same time, you never know what another team might value, if they’re deploying McCutchen in more of a niche role versus counting on him to anchor a lineup the way the Pirates have.
Where McCutchen lands should be learned soon enough. These are also fits, not formal offers.
If nothing legitimate arises, part of me hopes McCutchen stays ready and there’s a scenario for him to rejoin the Pirates midway through 2026.
That’s also very unlikely to happen, which brings us to the final part of this discussion. The Pirates and McCutchen must get to a better place with everything. Above all, the one outcome they needed to avoid here was a rift existing between team and player.
I’m not saying that’s happened. Both sides care too much to permit it. But at some point, they will need to talk and make up and figure out how to appropriately celebrate McCutchen’s legacy.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.