BRADENTON, Fla. — Ben Cherington called it an organizational strength — and it may indeed be that.

It’s also been a revolving door, occasionally a black hole, and this spring it might offer the most intrigue of any position on the diamond.

Talking, of course, about Pirates’ catchers, specifically Henry Davis, Joey Bart, Rafael Flores and Endy Rodriguez, four players Cherington believes can shoulder a “primary” workload.

“You feel good about catching until someone takes a foul tip,” Cherington, the Pirates general manager, said over Zoom on Tuesday for Grapefruit League media day. “We’ll hold onto that depth as long as we can.”

Advertise with us

Sounds like a plan for the Pirates.

In the meantime, the rest of us can watch and speculate on how this ultimately shakes out, hopefully for their sake with Davis realizing his offensive potential and matching his performance at the plate with some impressive defensive growth.

Because that’s what needs to happen here.

Davis is a first overall pick (2021) who works as hard as any player on the Pirates’ roster, who’s smart, who’s garnered a ton of respect among his peers … yet who also has a .181 career average and .556 OPS in 186 MLB games.

Those numbers have to be better. Davis knows it. The Pirates know it. And I believe Davis’ offense will improve in 2026. He has too many tools — physical talent, mental makeup — for it not to happen.

Advertise with us

“Man, he looks really good,” manager Don Kelly said when I asked for his early impressions of Davis this spring. “His swing looks really good. He made some adjustments this offseason. Excited to see those play out over the course of spring training and through the season.

“The thing that stands out to me about Henry is his work ethic and his desire to be great at what he does.”

Kelly’s answer then took a sudden detour to the Pirates’ experiment with Davis in right field, which now seems absurd in hindsight. But it’s also why I’m refusing to count out Davis with a bat in his hands.

A few years ago, he lacked a defensive position. In fact, he struggled mightily at two.

Behind the plate, Davis improved his work from one knee, decreased his pop time, became a better receiver and continued to move well enough to put up solid blocking numbers.

Advertise with us

After he was worth -4 defensive runs saved (per FanGraphs) in 2024, that number shot up to 8 this past season.

Doubt anyone would’ve predicted that then, so I’m not sure why we’re reaching conclusions on his offense now.

“We didn’t think he was going to be able to catch, and he’s turned himself into a guy that got Gold Glove votes last year,” Kelly said. “I would not bet against Henry Davis in making adjustments and getting better and he showed that this offseason offensively.”

If that was the only storyline, it would certainly be worth following. But that’s hardly the case when talking about Pirates catchers.

(For the record, Davis shut down my November questioning on what he’s been working on, saying he’d rather not talk about it until he starts producing better results.)

Advertise with us

Equally as fascinating here is Bart, who’s second on the Pirates in wRC+ (110) and third in wins above replacement (FanGraphs, 2.6) among position players in Pittsburgh since Cherington acquired him from the Giants via trade in April 2024.

After a strong first season with the Pirates, it was a step back for Bart in 2025, his OPS dropping from .799 to .696. But Bart was excellent the year before and crushes left-handed pitching (.891 OPS against it in 2025), which is why he could be attractive on the trade market.

Asked Tuesday about next steps, Cherington explained that he continues to hunt for a left-side infielder, as well as a starting pitcher. Free agency or trade, there’s work to do. But given the Pirates’ payroll allocations — close to $105 million now — trading for a third baseman makes the most sense.

Bart was part of discussions between the Astros and Pirates for Isaac Paredes in a deal that has since gone quiet. It would make sense if Bart’s name surfaced again. Other teams could have more opportunity to offer, while playing time in Pittsburgh could be tough for Bart to find.

Davis catches Paul Skenes, Mitch Keller and Bubba Chandler and gives the Pirates more defensively, something they should value given how the Marcell Ozuna addition complicates their current alignment.

Advertise with us

Where and how will Bart play? Or will the Pirates look to mortgage his trade?

My prediction is the latter, which is why I found it interesting how Cherington started with a tire-pumping of Bart when he was asked to assess the battle the Pirates will have at catcher.

“Certainly coming into camp, you think about what Joey Bart’s done at the major league level — he’s accomplished some things,” Cherington said. “He’s a really talented offensive player who continues to work on his defensive game. We believe in him back there. He’s entering into a time of his career that sometimes guys at that position take the next step. That’s not unheard of. We believe the best days are ahead for Joey.”

They certainly need to be for someone, Bart or otherwise.

Pirates catchers had a .606 OPS last season, fourth worst in MLB. It was nearly as deficient as third base — which obviously remains unaddressed.

Advertise with us

The difference here is that third likely will get a fresh coat of paint. Catcher, the majority of improvement must come in-house.

The Pirates will be looking for development out of Flores (.822 OPS in 36 games with Triple-A Indianapolis last season), as well as Rodriguez remaining healthy and hitting; Rodriguez has the loudest tools of any catcher on the 40-man roster, but he hasn’t been able to stay healthy and has a .587 career OPS in big league games.

They both need to play and earn their opportunity.

So while there might be strength in numbers, there’s also a bunch we don’t know about Pirates catchers, including whether Bart is included with a trade and Davis can realize his potential as a 1-1 pick.

For the record, I think both will happen.

Advertise with us

“Henry has worked his tail off to become a really good defensive player,” Cherington said. “There’s a history of offense in the minor leagues. It just hasn’t matriculated to the major league level yet.

“The good news is he went into an offseason for the first time with full clarity on that; he had basically a full major league season worth of feedback. When Henry gets feedback and he’s focused on doing something about it, usually good things happen.”