In each of the past two offseasons, the Pirates had Andrew McCutchen’s contract completed by Christmas.
This winter, with the organization behaving differently than it has in years while harboring legitimate hope for 2026, the issue has gone unaddressed, moved to the back of the stove while other tasks are completed.
Here’s hoping no one gets burned. Because this should end a certain way — McCutchen finishing his career as a Pirate, with no bad blood between the organization and one of the most popular players in its history.
Asked about McCutchen in December, Pirates general manager Ben Cherington said the team had to learn more about its offseason before committing to anything.
That remains true in mid-January, the Pirates still pursuing a third baseman, a pitcher and maybe one additional piece. But the stasis won’t last forever.
“The relationship between the Pirates and Andrew is important,” Cherington said. “We want to do what we can to preserve that.”
Read More
Here’s how that can and should happen:
’We gotta win’
For as long as I’ve covered him, McCutchen has resisted putting a definitive timeline on retirement, preferring to stay in the moment.
McCutchen worries it could come off as selfish or affect his performance.
“I don’t want to make the whole year about me,” McCutchen told me last March. “Guys will think, ‘Hey, it’s Cutch’s last year. We have to honor that.’ No, you don’t. We gotta win. It doesn’t have anything to do with my last year.
“I also worry that I could check out. It’s easy to sit here and be like, ‘I’m done.’ It’s not fair to the people around me. And it’s not fair to me.”
The line of thinking makes sense. I actually agreed with McCutchen at the time. But for this story to end appropriately, an adjustment is required.
Establishing the finish line would help more than hurt, but we’ll loop back to that thought.
Another important part of this includes considering the past and future, using both to inform our belief on the present.
Past and future
The past has been discussed over and over: the All-Star nods, the National League MVP and top-five finishes, the fact that only Mike Trout was worth more wins above replacement (per FanGraphs) from 2011-14.
Prime McCutchen was dominant, the best hitter we’ve seen in Pittsburgh since Barry Bonds, the Pirates’ most popular player for decades, all that fun stuff.
It’s equally as easy to say McCutchen should remain an important part of the Pirates family once his playing days are done, in whatever form or iteration that takes.
The present is where reasonable people can disagree.
The case to move on might be McCutchen’s .239 average or .700 OPS in 2025, as well as the 39-year-old averaging fewer than six games in the field over the past three seasons and the Pirates’ obvious need for offensive improvement.
The case to keep McCutchen involves getting on base (.333 on-base percentage, third best among Pirates regulars in 2025), his immense legacy and the fact that he has hardly represented money wasted.
Ignoring off-field stuff — his popularity or how people think about the Pirates based on what he says or does — McCutchen since 2023 has given them $18.4 million of production (based on current WAR estimates) for $15 million in salary.
But it’s also not that simple. Let’s dig deeper.
Finding a role
Given McCutchen’s past and what can be reliably assumed about his future, the decision on his present comes down to fit.
Does McCutchen fit on this roster?
It’s tough to see as currently constituted, but there’s also a good chance that changes, clearing a role that would be more palatable for both sides. The place to focus is catcher.
Henry Davis was the primary catcher last season for Paul Skenes, Mitch Keller and Bubba Chandler, catching nearly 80% of their innings. Joey Bart caught roughly 60% of Braxton Ashcraft, but that’s it among the Pirates’ top four starters.
Furthermore, when looking at FanGraphs’ calculation of defensive runs saved, Davis (8) was 11th among the 57 MLB catchers with at least 300 innings behind the plate in 2025. Bart (minus-6) was 48th. For much of general manager Ben Cherington’s tenure, he has emphasized how much the Pirates value defensively sound catchers.
First base would be tough because Spencer Horwitz and Ryan O’Hearn need at-bats, so Bart would effectively become a backup catcher and part-time designated hitter who hits lefties well. It could block Rafael Flores and Endy Rodriguez if they push in Triple-A. That’s also a tough ask of Bart — expecting production with sporadic playing time.
The last input becomes attractiveness.
Bart had an .891 OPS against lefties in 2025, .996 the year prior. He was actually worth 2.2 wins above replacement (per Baseball Reference) in 2024 when he had a .799 against all pitchers and homered 13 times in 253 at-bats.
The Pirates have value in Bart. But they should apply it in a trade, perhaps for an everyday third baseman who would let Jared Triolo function more as a utility type. Doing that would also open a role for a right-handed hitter without a set (or any) defensive position who hits lefties well.
In other words, McCutchen.
Use your words
You don’t have to trade Bart to bring back McCutchen, but that role shift does make it easier to manage roster-wise.
There’s also this, and it may be the biggest of them all: finally and decisively saying this is it.
It has benefits for both sides, too.
For McCutchen, it would mean not uprooting his family, as well as finally realizing what he told me in that March interview was his vision all along — more postseason baseball at PNC Park.
“I’ve been visualizing it,” McCutchen said. “There’s a reason I came back. I didn’t come back just to lose for three years, and that’s it.”
McCutchen deserves it. The same for anyone who’s been through the frustrating stuff. It just wouldn’t feel right if the Pirates finally figured it out and McCutchen was playing in the American League.
The team, meanwhile, could use the 2026 season to blow it out, to recognize and celebrate what McCutchen has done for the organization while also creating flexibility at DH in 2027 and beyond.
On the outside, fans could enjoy one final ride, the same as they did for Albert Pujols and Adam Wainwright in St. Louis, Clayton Kershaw in Los Angeles or Miguel Cabrera in Detroit, McCutchen contemporaries who announced their retirement ahead of time.
(McCutchen doing this would almost assuredly net him a deserved “Legend Pick” in this year’s MLB All-Star Game in Philadelphia, allowing ol’ Uncle Larry to go out with one more laugh.)
Bottom line, one side needs to talk to the other and get the ball rolling, McCutchen and the Pirates agreeing on the this-is-it script that has worked well for stars with similar attachments to cities.
McCutchen matters too much to Pittsburgh and the Pirates for this to end any other way.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.