It may sound counterintuitive considering they’ve traded two of them in deals for offense, but the Pirates are in the market for pitchers.
Not top-of-the-rotation arms, mind you — they have those — more depth because several young starters will have innings limits in 2026.
For example: If Paul Skenes and Mitch Keller combine for 400 innings and Braxton Ashcraft and Bubba Chandler enjoy 20% bumps, the Pirates would still need roughly 180 innings to match last year’s total for starters (826 2/3).
So along with a hitter who plays third base, shortstop or both, the Pirates know they need to add pitching. Let’s examine a few options that would make sense.
Reunion time?
Tyler Anderson and Jose Quintana created a type for this Pirates regime: left-handed starters who leveraged opportunity in Pittsburgh to bigger and better things.
They’re cut from a similar cloth, veterans who don’t overwhelm you with velocity but used their changeups more in Pittsburgh and let PNC Park play to their advantage. Bailey Falter was similar, though there was a little more nuance there.
Read More
Anderson and Quintana, now 36 and 37, respectively, are available and would add some diversity to Pittsburgh’s all-righty rotation.
Anderson had a 4.56 ERA in 26 starts for the Angels. Quintana was better, producing a 3.96 ERA in 24 starts for the Brewers. MLB Trade Rumors projects their deals to fall in the $3-$6 million range, though that feels a little low.
Still familiar
He doesn’t throw with his left hand, but Michael Lorenzen would also make sense — in large part because he would bring needed flexibility.
There’s been no firm commitment on Carmen Mlodzinski’s role. Jared Jones will return in May or June. Thomas Harrington and Hunter Barco could push at any time. The Pirates have skewed more and more like the Tampa Bay Rays when it comes to creative pitching usage.
Lorenzen, 34, has handled starting and relieving well.
Last season with the Royals, he made 27 appearances (26 starts), logged 141 2/3 innings (second most of his career) and had a 4.64 ERA. In his mid-to-late 20s, Lorenzen was a dynamic reliever and two-way player with the Reds.
Oh, yeah, and he’s really good friends with Jones.
Lorenzen has velocity, a great changeup and spin that could be re-imagined in Pittsburgh. Plus, after a 0.4 bWAR season while making $7 million, the 34-year-old should be affordable.
Close ... but not quite
Zack Littell fits what the Pirates need: a pitcher with experience starting and relieving. But it’s tough to see the fit. And not because Littell has struggled.
He’s actually coming off two years where he’s been worth a combined 6.0 bWAR and had a 3.73 ERA — enough that Littell should command a contract beyond what the Pirates need or want to spend.
Mike Soroka is another tweener type who’s available. But with a 2.58 career ERA as a reliever and struggles starting last season, he’s probably more bullpen depth than someone who will supplement a rotation.
Miles Mikolas has averaged 183 innings over the past four seasons and certainly knows the NL Central well, having spent seven seasons with the Cardinals. However, he’s also 37 and has a concerning trend line, including career highs home runs (1.7) and walks (2.1) per nine innings in 2025 when you consider Mikolas’ six full MLB seasons as a starter.
Land of opportunity
Ready for a surprising suggestion? Walker Buehler. And, yes, he was a 14th-round pick of the Pirates (2012) who never signed.
It’s been a wild ride for Buehler, who had a 7.1 bWAR season in 2021, then underwent Tommy John surgery and a flexor tendon repair procedure the following August. Buehler missed 2023, was limited to 75 1/3 innings in ’24 and signed a $21.05 million deal with the Red Sox last offseason that flopped. Buehler had a 5.45 ERA in 22 starts and was released in August.
So, why are we here?
Because Buehler seemingly found himself after signing a minor league deal with the Phillies late in 2025, going 3-0 with a 0.66 ERA in three games (two starts) totaling 13 2/3 innings.
Would it be a gamble? Absolutely. At the same time, there’s a Vanderbilt connection with Bryan Reynolds, plus Buehler’s playoff experience could benefit Pittsburgh’s young staff — provided his Phillies resurgence was real.
Bigger dice roll
Speaking of calculated risks, you could make an argument for Patrick Corbin. But it does require you to squint.
The recent results for Corbin have been rough, the 36-year-old lefty producing a 5.47 ERA and minus-4.4 bWAR over the past five seasons for the Nationals and Rangers. However, Corbin’s 2025 season did show some signs: 4.40 ERA, 4.25 FIP (Falter was 4.91) and 1.365 WHIP (comparable to Mlodzinski at 1.303).
The argument for Corbin would be durability; he has an MLB-high nine consecutive seasons with at least 150 innings pitched. Plus, there’s the ballpark factors discussed with other lefty starters.
In 15 home games at Globe Life Field last year, Corbin had a 3.36 ERA compared to 5.38 on the road. In eight career starts at PNC Park, Corbin 3.31 ERA, .211 batting average against and .595 OPS against — all the lowest for anywhere he’s started more than three times.
Not saying Corbin is some perfect fit. You also can’t exclusively deploy him at home. But the cost would be low, Corbin has a World Series on his resume, and the Pirates have found hidden value in these types before.
Nuclear options
I certainly don’t think either of these are likely, but they’d sure be entertaining. And with their good friend Don Kelly managing the Pirates, at least they’re not completely crazy to ponder.
I’m talking, of course, about two of Kelly’s former Tigers teammates in Max Scherzer and Justin Verlander, 40-plus-year-olds with a half-dozen Cy Youngs between them who are looking for work this offseason.
Again, it’s darn tough, if not impossible, to see anything happening here. But those guys have won championships and made more money than most can even comprehend. Perhaps Kelly and Paul Skenes could sell them on Pittsburgh, being the final piece of this rotation and how special the summer could be if the Pirates win.
Yes, it’s far-fetched. Extremely so. But everyone saw how intently Scherzer watched Skenes back in August.
“Obviously he’s off to a great start in his career, one of the best starts to a career ever, but I want to see him go 200 innings,” Scherzer told Sportsnet at the time. “The biggest thing I watch for year over year is durability. … I want to see what he’s doing in 2027, not just now.”
How about 2026 instead?






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.