The way Mason Montgomery described it, the start to his 2024 season felt like one gigantic roadblock, with the Tampa Bay Rays minor league pitcher of the year two years prior encountering the same problems as a starting pitcher for the Class AAA Durham Bulls.

Despite wielding impressive velocity and a biting slider, Montgomery couldn’t fool hitters for long enough and had a 7.04 ERA after allowing four earned runs on seven hits, including two homers, on Aug. 4, 2024.

Since that moment, which sparked a switch to the bullpen, the journey has been different for Montgomery — and it could accelerate in Pittsburgh after the Pirates acquired the 2021 sixth-round draft pick from the Rays on Dec. 19 in a deal that also netted Brandon Lowe and Jake Mangum.

It hasn’t been perfect, but Montgomery’s shift from starter to reliever has made him an enticing prospect, a southpaw slinging triple-digit heat who might become a truly elite setup man if the Pirates can complete his development.

Advertise with us

“I had spent five or six months that season trying different things and trying to seek out success,” Montgomery said Tuesday on a Zoom call. “Whenever I moved to the bullpen, it opened up my mind. It changed my mindset a little bit from a marathon mentality to a sprint.

“Like, ‘Hey, I’m gonna give it all I have for 25-30 pitches. No need to make your arm last or work around guys. … It’s probably the best thing that has happened to me as far as my career has gone.”

Whatever the 25-year-old native of Austin, Texas, native did to transition quickly, it worked.

In Montgomery’s next 10 outings, he didn’t allow a run over 9⅔ innings, walking five and striking out 20, earning a promotion to MLB.

The results were also excellent there — a 1.86 ERA in nine games, where he walked just five and struck out 17 in 9⅔ innings — but Montgomery’s 2025 season was not ideal.

Advertise with us

Big-league hitters adjusted to Montgomery’s heat. They produced a .311 batting average and .466 slugging percentage against his four-seamer. The slider was solid (43% whiff rate) but inconsistent.

Overall, Montgomery saw his ERA jump to 5.67 in 57 outings totaling 46 innings, a 1.652 WHIP that indicates more traffic on the bases than any late-inning reliever would like. But there was one positive.

“Being up for the majority of a big-league season, it was good to get that experience and see what it’s like to travel every three days across the country,” Montgomery said. “I’m excited to have that experience.”

That’s where the Pirates come in.

Montgomery said he has spoken with manager Don Kelly and pitching coach Bill Murphy — quick calls to say hello, which Montgomery appreciated.

Advertise with us

The pitcher actually has never been to Pittsburgh, though he said he’s excited about the ballpark and reception. Both have come with rave reviews.

What Pittsburgh does with Montgomery’s immense talent will matter a great deal. For his career, yes. But also for the team’s success, as the Pirates could use another piece or two in the bullpen.

You also don’t turn down left-handed pitchers throwing 100 mph.

“I’m very grateful to have the opportunity to even be considered for a role like that,” Montgomery said of joining what should be a solid Pirates bullpen. “It’s exciting. I think it’ll be fun. I think it’ll be lots of opportunity, and it’ll be cool to kind of see how it goes transitioning organizations.”

Montgomery has been tinkering with a bigger breaking ball and a changeup, though not enough to commit — at this at least this point — to using either in 2026. The Pirates also likely need to help Montgomery find more consistency in his delivery.

Advertise with us

The 6-foot-2 pitcher gets a lot of extension — similar to Bailey Falter — and throws extremely hard (98.7 mph average, 97th percentile). But he loses that advantage by pitching behind in counts and allowing hitters to essentially gear up for a heater or brace for a sweeping slider.

The good news is the Pirates have done this before with Falter, Tyler Anderson, Jose Quintana and a few others on a smaller scale. They were all left-handers who might have needed to refine mechanics, develop another pitch, tunnel better, induce more vertical break or any number of pitching-process tweaks.

Montgomery is the Pirates’ latest project. And a good one.

“Really dynamic stuff — young, up to 100 mph from the left side with a plus slider,” Pirates general manager Ben Cherington said recently. “We think the underlying stuff was better than the surface ERA. [Montgomery] is someone we think we can really grow with. We believe he can be a particularly good fit at PNC Park given how left-handers have fared there.”

Montgomery said he’s comfortable pitching in any situation; the Rays are more fungible with that stuff than any other MLB team. He also has been chatting with Lowe and Mangum about the opportunity the Pirates will have along the Allegheny River this summer.

“They were like, ‘You should be excited. This is one of the better pitching staffs in the league,’” Montgomery said. “It’ll be fun. There are going to be some learning opportunities. … I’ve heard good things. I’m excited.”