Jason Mackey: Hello, everyone. Welcome to my weekly Pirates chat. Thanks for stopping by. An hour early today to accomodate other stuff on our site relative to football. We'll get started at 11 a.m. Thanks for your understanding.

Jason Mackey: And away we go ...

Your Name: What are the odds we see a different kind of offseason from the norm, I.e. more aggressive trades, and perhaps one mid market free agent signing, as opposed to spreading the money around on replacement level players who never pan out? 0%? 1%?

Jason Mackey: I think what you're describing is actually realistic. Maybe I'm nuts. But if you look at their current salary commitments, they're not much. They know they need to win, that people are ticked. Even if you tell me payroll is $88 million, you have a starting staff for peanuts. You should be able to spend that on actual bats. So, yeah, they better do what you're saying. And then some.

Advertise with us

PhilinCT: Mr Mackey, welcome back to baseball full time. As well as you did with your column, it's good to have you back dealing with just baseball. As much as I hate to trade starting pitching, it cannot be denied that it is the one commodity the Pirates have in relative abundance. If they decided to trade Keller, Oviedo AND a younger cusp starter (Burrows, Harrington, etc), either separately or together, what is the realistic return on offense that could be expected? Not advocating, just wondering. Thanks as always for your time and knowledge.

Jason Mackey: Thank you! The possible return: whatever an organization is willing to give up. I'm being sarcastic, but there's some truth there. I don't know. Nobody does. Depends on desperation. I will say this:

1) They better not trade all 3 and probably only one of the guys you mentioned.

2) I also think it's fair to want/require at least one every-day position player coming back in the deal, maybe more depending on what you're giving up.

BadBoyBurv: Ex-baseball coach here, Pirates lover. I’m amazed every year watching the Bucco’s, hitting and the lineup should be based purely on stats. If a player doesn’t like his place in the order, tell them to “get better”, but the Pirates base their order on potential or reputation. Let the players know, the best players play. Stop making the order on salary or potential. Find minor leaguers with his batting averages, not these .204 guys we sign. Also have some clubhouse discipline, players and kids in general crave discipline. Sign me up, I’ll knock some sense into those yahoos…

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Oh, boy. Yep, we have a solution here.

I do agree, though, that the Pirates would win more games if they got better players. I think that's a logical statement.

Jeff M.: Hi Jason, is there anything that makes you believe the Pirates will actually sign more than a couple past their prime vets to one year deals and tout the leadership the bring to the clubhouse? Not that we should trust GMBC to add any major league hitters.

Jason Mackey: I think they will try, Jeff. Will they be the right ones? I don't know. Recent evidence ain't great. But I outlined above the space they have to do it. Again, I'd like to see payroll go up, but there's still space to sign actual MLB players. They know they're in a tough spot. I can't imagine Ben Cherington wants to get fired. I can't imagine Paul Skenes is simply going to tolerate losing. I don't think Don Kelly wants to preside over a lousy team. It's just a matter of CAN they make the right moves to fix this.

Jim Maruca: Jason. It’s great to see you back on the beat. I missed your chats. Welcome back.

Advertise with us

Do you think the possibility of a lockout next offseason will affect free agency throughout the league? Correct me if I’m wrong but I don’t think the teams are liable (have to pay) for salaries during a lockout so I don’t see the risk of multi-year contracts.

Jason Mackey: Yeah, got this one last week, Jim. It's a good Q. Don't have a magic answer. Maybe some ... but I still think it'll be mostly normal. It's not guaranteed, mind you. If anything, they'd really like to avoid it.

Scott from NJ: I think the Pirates need to take advantage of teams and be creative. If I was GMBC, I would be calling Minnesota about Ryan Jeffers , Trevor Larnach, and Matt Wallner. We have a surplus of young pitching and there rebuilding. To me that would help us fill several wholes on the team and be a perfect match with us.

Jason Mackey: I agree with you that there are a lot of calls to be made involving teams with young positions players who can swap them out for pitching. A's, Orioles and maybe even the Giants are a couple more.

demosthenes98: I have a general baseball question to ask, if you don't mind answering it. Is it just me, or do MLB pitchers all throw a wider variety of pitches than they used to? Every time I watch a baseball game, whether it's a Pirates game or not, and they show a pitcher's arsenal, it never seems to be fewer than four or five pitches. The days of Mariano Rivera getting into Cooperstown with basically one pitch seem long gone.

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Ha. I'm not sure Rivera or those types ever getting into Cooperstown was a trend. But I do see what you're saying. Anecdotally, I agree with you -- pitchers are throwing more pitches, maybe too many. Sweepers, cutters, etc. The forkball has been used less, but it's really a splitter or splinker twisted another way.

demosthenes98: It is the calling of the journalist to speak truth to power. In professional sports, a team's ownership/management group is the power. Does this dynamic ever make things awkward for beat writers such as yourself?

Jason Mackey: Not at all. It's a beat writer's job -- while we're defining these things, I guess -- to cover a team objectively, to report news. These lines have certainly been blurred. As teams take away access, we lean more into brands and analysis. Just a state of the business thing. It's a columnist's job to give opinion. The Pirates know how this dynamic works. They've never been anything but completely professional to me in either role. Doesn't mean they haven't gotten mad. Conflict is inevitable. But you're doing your job. Also, I cover baseball, the overthrowing of government or an active war zone. Let's not get too dramatic with the speak truth to power stuff.

D9 Dave: Do you think the Pirates would ever consider making Oneal Cruz the DH? He seems to a defensive liability whatever position he plays. Perhaps his hitting would improve if he just concentrated on it. Would also give the Pirates more leeway in the outfield.

Jason Mackey: Maybe one day. But Dave, he's one of the fastest players in MLB and has one of the strongest arms. I know the defense hasn't been great. But me personally, I'd try a little harder to make it work. It's in there.

Advertise with us

Jim Maruca: It seems like every hitter the Pirates send down to Eric Munson in Indianapolis improves noticeably. Triolo, Davis, Suwinski etc. Why not promote him to the Pirates staff? My theory is he’s not as obsessed with analytics as Cherington is and seems to focus more on slight technical adjustments and athleticism which is just what hitters like Cruz and Davis need imo. Am I totally off base?

Jason Mackey: I don't know much about Eric Munson. Maybe they will, too. I don't know. But I also hear complaints about them not being able to develop hitters. So, we're gonna fix that by promoting the Triple-A hitting coach?

Truthfully, Jim, I don't know. I don't know enough about Munson's process. I will say this, though, the Pirates would do well to have guys thinking less. That's something I know that from talking to people has been an issue. So if that's Munson's MO, cool. Less numbers and locking guys up. More feel.

Matt L: Should the Pirates consider moving Cruz to 3b to give them more flexibility in acquiring bats via trade and free agency?

Jason Mackey: No Absolutely not.

Advertise with us

Cullen: So Esmerlyn Valdez has to be added to the 40 man right? His power seems real and he performed pretty well after some initial struggles in AA as a 21 year old. Underlying stats seem to be pretty good and it would be tough to lose him in the rule 5 draft.

Jason Mackey: He does, yes. He's making it very easy.

Cullen: If the Pirates trade for a guy with a year or two of control like Lowe, would they look to extend him? For a team like the Pirates it would be hard to give up trade capital for only a rental...

Jason Mackey: Lowe has one year. And I think it would depend on the situation. Not right away, I'd imagine. Maybe partway through the year if things are going well. Love you, Cullen. But it's hard to predict an outcome of someone they have not yet signed.

Steve Jeremko: Welcome back to the Bucco Bes

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Thanks, Steve.

Cullen: Could Carmen be a trade candidate if both he and other teams believe he can be a starter? His value seems to be at an all time high after another brilliant season. Could be a good time for the Pirates to cash in if we believe his ceiling is a long reliever/back end bullpen arm while still preserving our starter depth.

Jason Mackey: I'd hope not. And I doubt it. They need back-end bullpen guys. He's been outstanding. I hope he comes to that realization. I hope they encourage him. There's nothing wrong with being a dominant, late-inning reliever. Those guys have long careers and make a lot of money. If Carmen is a reliever, he's a regular in the 7th/8th, and the Pirates are much better for it.

Steve Jeremko: Welcome back to the Bucco Beat, Jason! I always enjoy your writings and podcasts. My question concerns two players that I like very much but who've struggled mightily .. Henry Davis and Jack Suwinski. When players such as these guys need help, what is generally done in the offseason by the organization? Or is it left up to their own devices until Spring Training.

Jason Mackey: There's never one thing, Steve. Depends on what the players need. Henry works out at Driveline. Jack owns his own place in Chicago. Vastly different. There's obviously individual stuff they're working on and need to fix, and the organization supports that. They also communicate with private coaches.

Advertise with us

Steve Jeremko: Question 2: What is your best guess of the probability that Ben Cherington is mercifully relieved as GM before the season?

Jason Mackey: If that was going to happen, it would have been done by now.

Steve Jeremko: Question 3: Oneil Cruz is a baffling mystery wrapped inside an enigma. How much rope do you think he has with Don Kelly? ... or with the organization?

Jason Mackey: Plenty. I think he's with them at least through this season and probably longer, assuming he's not absolutely horrible in 2026. (I don't think he will be.)

Bzer: What free agent who could be projected to hit 30 home runs or more is available and would be within the Pirates price range?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Maybe Trent Grisham? I'm not sure there is a 30-homer guy within their price range via free agency. There's a lot of 20-plus guys. I also don't think the number of homers should be the ultimate determinant. They need to score more runs. Look at the Brewers. That can happen other ways.

Will in N. Hills: What’s the word on potential new pitching coach? And do we really trust BC to get a good return for Keller? Don’t we need a veteran member on the staff? I think he’s worth keeping.

Jason Mackey: Not much. Been very quiet.

I think it depends on the return with Mitch. Believe me, I don't want to see Mitch guy. Like him a lot. Good dude. Solid pitchers. But they need offense. Gotta give to get. They can replace him for cheaper. I understand the argument. If he would fetch something via trade, I think you have to consider that.

Clint: The cat’s out of the bag - Cherington’s only job duty is to keep payroll low by selling off assets when they become expensive. Now that he’s feeling heat from the media, is there a chance he tries to make a splash move to actually improve the team?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Payroll is gonna be about the same way as it was last year. Was Cherington clearing out what he could to set the Pirates up to maybe chart a new(ish) direction this winter? Yeah, I think that's possible. I don't even think that's a flawed strategy. Just have to go do it, and they haven't done a good enough job of that to this point.

DennisSC: Are you hearing any possible names to replace Oscar Marin?

Jason Mackey: No. That's been oddly very quiet. Believe me, hasn't been for lack of effort.

T: Mr. Mackey, with the return of the same hitting coach what could bring us hope that once top hitting prospects of Cruz and Davis could find their way?

Jason Mackey: This overly simplistic, I know, but changing the process? It's not just Matt Hague. There's a lot that goes into it with tech, approach, adjustments, other types of coaching, data, etc. I understand why it frustrates people -- it's not a great look to keep the hitting coach but fire the pitching coach after this type of year -- but players like Cruz & Davis can still figure it out.

Advertise with us

Matt D.: This is a go all-in or bust year. There's no room for another 70-75-win season. They need to clean house if they don't have a winning season.

Do the Pirates go out and sign a guy to a multi-year deal? Do they actually try something different this year, or are we going to be on the edge of our seats waiting for a Tommy Pham-type signing in February?

Jason Mackey: I agree with you -- they need to win or it's gonna be over. I think they will try to sign a multi-year deal. They've also tried in the past. That's not as easy as it might sound because why would a player with other options -- if you're good enough to earn a multi-year deal, you probably don't stink -- want to come to a place where they haven't made the postseason since '15? The Pirates must earn that. They need to do that by rolling out a plan, signing better players and winning games.

FirstTimeLongTime: Jason - I know it's highly unlikely given his professional nature, but wouldn't it be great to see Skenes come out and say they need to spend more and acquire some legit FA's. Would really put ownership in a PR nightmare (if it could get any worse).

Jason Mackey: Ha. You nailed it with the last part. What, are people gonna be mad about the Pirates? Are they gonna call the owner cheap or say the organization is poorly run? Also, Paul did say a lot of this stuff without saying it if you read between the lines here. I also think if they don't win or make a more obvious effort, yeah, he's probably gonna say more. It'll be warranted, too.

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: "Worse? How can it get any worse, Ellen? Look around. We're on the threshold of hell!" -- Christmas Vacation

RPKinsella: What confidence can any of us have that GMBC is the right person to evaluate the pitching to trade and the hitting to acquire given his record? Priester for Yorke. Holmes for Park and Castillo. Taillon for Smith-NJigba, Escotto, Contreras and Yajure. Bednar for Flores.

Jason Mackey: Totally fair. There's nothing I can say here that will undo any of those trades. They haven't been good enough. And until they make better trades, that criticism is completely valid. They need to earn confidence and really haven't yet, other than some pretty good young pitchers.

Seth: Do you think the team considers trading Reynolds this offseason? I understand he’s the only consistent bat in the lineup and isn’t protected, but he’s getting older and more expensive. Do you think they could move him for younger and/or cheaper?

Jason Mackey: I don't. This would be a terrible time to do it, too. Coming off one of his worst seasons? They're better served to ride it out and expect him to improve or for the numbers to correct. Personally I think they will.

Advertise with us

Steve Jeremko: I wonder about Bob Nutting's perception ... he appears to be an involved owner, but why is he so reluctant to make the big changes needed to improve this franchise. He has got to be aware of the criticism levelled at him from all directions Does he really believe the snake oil peddled by Cherington, Williams and others?

Jason Mackey: Another fair question. Nutting is more involved than many think. Those I talk to close to him also consistently cite his over-abundance of loyalty. Or, more to the point, being too slow to make necessary changes, almost convincing himself that they're gonna work out (when they often don't). He's certainly aware of the criticism. I know that for a fact.

CC Bucco Fan: I have two names that I would like to see the Pirates explore for their pitching coach. First would be A.J. Burnett if he would be interested. He could teach that young staff how to be mean and intimidating with the stuff they have. The second would be Joel Hanrahan although he might be done with the Pirates for the way he was treated in the past.

Jason Mackey: I don't think there's a chance of either. I don't think Burnett would want that. I think Hanrahan would, but his way of operating isn't at all what this group believes in. They love numbers, data, cameras, all that stuff. Not that Joel doesn't but I just don't think they're cut from the same cloth. Big fan of both of those guys, too. Great pitchers. Have such a great feel and head for the game. Just answering your question honestly.

Matt: Hi Jason. It was interesting to hear that player sentiment played at least some part in Oscar Marin not returning. Have you heard anything about what players thought of Matt Hague?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I have not. But lemme say this: I don't think player sentiment was THE reason Marin was fired or not brought back. It was an input. If player sentiment was bad on Hague, same deal, it wouldn't be THE reason. There are a lot of factors here.

That being said, I would like to know more about why Hague remains, what the plan is gonna be to do thing differently and all of that.

Lastly, I think hitting coaches generally get too much blame and credit. Hitters have to perform. A GM needs to built a roster. I'd say both sides came up short in 2025. It's not just the hitting coach here.

PrinceBob: Do you see anything obviously different now from what the Pirates were doing in the mid teens when they were getting into the post season? Obviously there's a different GM and manager. Is that it? Do you think it would be better now if Littlefield was still GM? Has baseball changed in a way the Pirates haven't kept up with?

Jason Mackey: I was not covering the Pirates back then, so it's tough to say for sure. One thing I hear often is a feel of cohesion around the team, something that I think Hurdle brought, I think that's also spurred by winning.

I'm not saying things are terrible right now. They're not. But it's a lot more tense or an over-arching search for a solution than it is the cohesion or confidence that existed back then.

I also think the group back then did a better job of helping players or finding someone who wasn't productive with another organization and getting more out of them. This one hasn't found that speed, and it has been a problem.

PrinceBob: Are the Angels an even more incompetent organization than the Pirates are? They spend actual money on players, for a while they had arguably the two best players in the game, and yet the Pirates have been in the post season more recently.

Jason Mackey: Probably, yes. I don't know a lot about Angels operations. But dollars spent versus team success is pretty brutal.

Rick: I believe McCage who was with the pirates previously and now in the Brewers organization would be a good hire

Jason Mackey: I don't hate it. Also not gonna happen. They got rid of him last offseason.

JollyRoger8: Regarding a possible work stoppage that wipes out the 2027 season; would the Pirates lose a year of control on Paul Skenes or would they maintain an extra year of control through 2030?

Jason Mackey: They would not lose a year of control. No work, no earning of service time. Everything is basically paused.

Jim: If MLB has a work stoppage, do the minor leagues shut down as well?

Jason Mackey: Yes. MiLB players became unionized in late 2022, so I would fully expect both to be shut down.

Your Name: What’s with Cherington’s obsession with trading for/claiming on waivers/signing utility players? Does he really believe you can construct a roster without power hitting corner players?

Jason Mackey: Every organization does some version of this -- and I'm not saying the Pirates should do it this much or anything. My point is that look at someone like Justin Turner or Max Muncy. They were minor league free agents the Dodgers helped. That happens in baseball. The Pirates a decade ago did it with pitching. It makes sense. This regime just hasn't been very good at it. They should also pay money for more sure things.

Matt L: In response to “no absolutely not” do you think Cruz can’t handle 3b? He has the arm, good enough glove and range, and is not a good outfielder. They have a glaring hole there. 3b requires reaction time more than deep focus, which he clearly lacks

Jason Mackey: We've found 2 defensive positions he struggles to play. Why are we going to add a third? Also, if you want to move him to the infield, fine. I don't agree with you, but I guess I see the logic. Just play him at short and move Triolo to third. Aren't we overcomplicating things here? Also, my preference would be to let Cruz get more comfortable in CF and push him to do it. I'd prefer that a billion times over shoehorning him into third base.

Danno: Obviously money is the major deciding factor but with the pitching staff do you think players will maybe choose the Pirates if the money is the same?

Jason Mackey: Every one is different, Danno. Is it multiple years? Are they part of the rotation? What's the org's plan for their pitch mix, usage, mechanical tweaks? What other moves are happening? Do they like the pitching coach? So many variables.

BrettofIndy: This is going to sound crass, but have the Pirates considered testing Cruz for AADD? It seems like something that could be an issue and might have been missed in the DR.

Jason Mackey: I'm assuming you mean ADHD? Unless there's something medically I'm unaware of. This isn't crass. This is from the parent of a child with ADHD: It ain't that simple. Same deal with Cruz.

Here's a little of what I mean: In the DR, players want to get out, right? Not the best area. They want to make money. They want to get scouted, etc. How do you do that? Skills. Running, throwing, hitting, stuff that pops during showcases. Not learning the nuance of the game.

Cruz has had some of that. A lot of Latin players do. Also, he's 27. I don't know about you, but I didn't have everything figured out back then. Doesn't have to be a diagnosis. Anyway, I know you just asked if he's tested. I would imagine if there are enough symptoms exhibited, which I don't think has been the case. I just think he needs to grow up a little as a player.

FirstTimeLongTime: Is it possible for a GM and a city to just not click? I'm talking spiritually lol... because it sure seems like analytics are cursed in this town. This is Pittsburgh. The Steel City. 3 yards in a cloud of dust. Like the universe is saying go get GM and coaches that are old school (buck the moneyball trend) and everything will work out because it's the burgh.

Jason Mackey: Analytics were a huge driving force behind the last time the Pirates won. Shoot, the Penguins relied heavily on that stuff in 2016-17. I think it's an oversimplification here. We wouldn't be talking about this stuff or worrying over it if the Pirates just won more.

GodHelptheBuccos: Jason - Who do you see as the starting rotation in 2026? Is it Skenes and the young guns or is Keller part of it? Do you see the Pirates to be willing to trade D. Santana?

Jason Mackey: I don't think they'll trade Santana. He's too important to the bullpen. Skenes, Chandler, Ashcraft for sure. Probably Oviedo. Keller if he's not traded. Burrows has a very good shot. Also wouldn't surprise if they added a veteran lefty type.

FirstTimeLongTime: Do we have enough middle infield prospects who don't hit in the organization or should we try to acquire more? Also what is the obsession with smaller guys who profile as contact hitters.

Jason Mackey: Yeah, I think they're good there. Go acquire some guys who can hit and hit for power.

Jason Mackey: Good chat, everyone. Thanks so much for accommodating the early start time. Let's do this again real soon.