The moment Ben Cherington stepped into the press conference room at PNC Park to address local media Saturday afternoon, the same question was likely hovering within the minds of many, perhaps his included. Would this be the final time he spoke to reporters as the Pirates’ general manager?

In the midst of his 20-plus minute availability, Cherington was indeed asked if he had any future assurances with his current employer. So, will he be back in 2026?

“I'm certainly doing the job that way,” Cherington responded. “We talk all the time. Haven't heard anything to the contrary.”

Cherington continued on, noting that he, nor most others who are currently in the workforce, truly never have full assurance of their professional futures. And after making that point, Cherington reiterated something he has expressed countless times since starting with the Pirates in 2020: His primary objective is to build a winner on the North Shore.

Advertise with us

“I want to help the Pirates win more games,” Cherington said. “That's it. I don't do the job because of the job. I do the job because I want to be a part of making this thing work. Winning more games and being able to leave PNC Park at night feeling better and everybody feeling better. That's why I do it. I still want to do it. I badly want to do it.”

Cherington hasn’t ignored the team’s struggles under his watch. He openly discussed the club’s many low points this year, saying this most recent stretch, where the Pirates had lost 12 of their past 13 entering Saturday’s game against the Athletics, has been especially frustrating.

“It’s been really tough,” Cherington said. “I think that we have to win more games. There are some things that have happened at the major league level this year that have been really good, but certainly not nearly enough. Good things have happened. While we really do believe that with the players in the organization that we have, the players on this team, that not only can we be better than this, that we will be better than this.

“To some extent, the last two weeks make you really confront the things that you have to get better at, that we have to get better at. It’s not just one thing. The roster needs to improve. That’s going to be a combination of guys who are already here and strengthening the roster in the offseason. And we also need to play a really consistent, smart brand of baseball. We haven’t done that consistently enough in the last couple of weeks. It’s not a lack of effort. We just haven’t executed the way we need to to win games. It’s been very difficult but also incredibly motivating. We’ve gotta be better.”

Don Kelly’s future

Cherington’s future wasn’t the only one discussed Saturday. The Pirates general manager was also asked if he anticipates Don Kelly returning as the club’s manager in 2026.

Advertise with us

“Obviously it's a topic on all of our minds, and certainly on my mind as we get to the end of the season,” Cherington said. “I do think we'll get to the end of the season so we can have a full assessment and then all attention will turn to that, I think very quickly.

"My view of the job that Donnie's done is one that's not surprising to me. I had confidence when he took the job in May that he would do a really good job. He's an excellent communicator. He's dogged in his approach to the job. He has a high self-belief. He believes in people. I said before I believe he cares about other people more than he cares about himself. He's got a lot of really, really strong qualities for the job, and I've seen that play out.”

Cherington noted that he has been particularly impressed with Kelly’s willingness to approach certain elements of the job that are especially hard for a manager in his situation. He also noted that despite the dismissal of Derek Shelton in early May, that he holds no regret of retaining Shelton heading into the 2025 campaign.

“We learn from everything,” Cherington said. “At the time, based on the information I had, I felt like that was the right recommendation for the Pirates, and we also learned from it and I learned from it. We got into the season and felt like we had to make a change. Learn from everything, get better, take responsibility. Don't regret the recommendation.”

Oneil Cruz concerns

Of the many disappointing Pirates performances in 2025, perhaps none have hurt the team more than Oneil Cruz. Cherington spoke about Cruz’s down year, noting two simple areas of regression.

Advertise with us

“It’s definitely something that we’re really, really digging into and focused on,” Cherington said. “It’s really important. We thought he was there for a couple of months. He got off to a little bit of a rough start, stabilized and then was proving he could play center field. That part, I think he mostly has done. It looked like for a couple of months that he was about to reach that next level, but it hasn’t happened. I think particularly since the All-Star break, the offensive production just hasn’t been there.

“He’s aware of that. We’re digging into it with him. I think the offseason is going to be really important for him. Mostly, it just comes down to approach and swing decisions with him. When he makes contact and barrels the ball, still really good things are happening. It’s just what pitches he’s swinging at and how consistent in that approach. It just hasn’t been there for him in the second half of the season.”

Cherington also weighed in on Cruz’s on-field effort, which has been at best, inconsistent this year.

“It’s one thing that Donnie’s been very engaged in,” Cherington said. “It’s not just Oneil. It’s anytime we see anything short of what we think the standard should be, Donnie’s right on top of that, no hesitation. Every player is unique. Oneil is his own person. We’ve seen the exceptional gifts. We’ve seen him play hard. We’ve seen him play through injury. We’ve seen him play through stuff that other guys probably wouldn’t play through. And there’s also been times where it looks like he could hold himself to a different standard.

“He knows that. Every time it’s happened, there’s been a conversation. There’s also been other times where he makes incredible things happen – and that’s also a conversation. You want to affirm that stuff, too. That’s just as important. Every player is unique and mature in their own way. We’ve got to hold the standard high, keep the standard high and keep working with him on it.”

Advertise with us

Konnor Griffin coming soon?

Perhaps the final subject of note revolved around Konnor Griffin, a 19-year-old shortstop who has been rated not only the Pirates’ top prospect, but the No. 1 prospect in baseball by both Baseball America and MLB Pipeline. Griffin’s dominant first year as a pro concluded earlier on Friday, as Double-A Altoona was eliminated in the postseason by the Erie Seawolves.

A known big piece of the future, many Pirates fans are excited to see Griffin begin his reign at shortstop on the North Shore. Cherington was asked about Griffin’s major league timeline, particularly if the young standout has a shot to make the big-league club out of camp next year.

“I think we've got to be really careful about it, honestly,” Cherington said. “He's had a remarkable season. He's 19 years old. He'll be 19 next April, still, I believe. That means that — while he's had a remarkable season, we're obviously incredibly excited that he's a Pirate — there's still more to learn.

“He hasn't played above Double-A. So I do think we do need to be careful with it. This is a player that's really important to the Pirates. It's important to him, too, that he's set up to have the longest, best career possible for him. We have some influence on that in terms of how we guide the next months, years of his entry into the big leagues, however long that takes. So I do think we need to be careful about it.”

Cherington was willing to admit that in certain cases, a player’s talent allows an organization to go against the norm. And Griffin could force such a scenario next year.

Advertise with us

“I guess you never know until you know, right, until it's actually happening,” Cherington said. “I think the thing that has stood out about him is, to the very end of the season, yesterday, is his desire to keep getting better to the very last day of the season and showing up yesterday wanting to work on something. Having most of his offseason mapped out and all that is an encouraging sign for a 19-year-old.”

Cherington said that Griffin’s season is over. He will not see any time in the major leagues next week. He also added that as of now, there haven’t been any talks of a contract extension with the young shortstop.

“We haven't even thought about that yet,” Cherington said. “I think that, as a general rule, we want to be in a position to have those kinds of conversations with young players that we believe in the most. So we'll see what comes of that. Not singling out him, but there are other guys that — we've had a chance to do some of that. I hope we do more of it going forward.”