Welcome to the Pirates mailbag, where Post-Gazette reporter Noah Hiles answers all of your questions about the ball club. If you have a question, find him on X at @_NoahHiles or email him at nhiles@post-gazette.com. Noah will answer your questions in full length each Thursday. Below are this week’s top questions:
Aaron: Are you concerned about Bryan Reynolds, and do you think the organization may be slightly concerned? Or is this a one-off year (almost like the COVID year) and we look at the overall body work and expect him to rebound next year?
Hiles: I think there’s a solid reason to be concerned about Reynolds. We talked a ton over the last few weeks about how Ke’Bryan Hayes never truly became the player the Pirates hoped he’d be when he signed that extension. I think it’s worth wondering if a similar situation is unfolding with Reynolds. He’s been good in recent years, but it’s hard to believe his best days aren’t behind him.
That’s what the numbers indicate anyway. He will likely see more time at designated hitter in the future, which is probably for the best. Keeping him out of the field will increase his value. I still think Reynolds can be a productive hitter. However, I only think that will happen if they get him more lineup protection.
I don’t think he’s good enough to be at the top of a playoff-caliber lineup, which is what they were probably looking for when he signed that extension. Next year is a very, very important season for Reynolds. If he struggles similarly to how he did this year, they might need to simply dump his salary and move on.
Aileen: Do you think Kelly handles the pitchers differently than Shelton? It will be interesting to see if Keller doesn’t fade down the stretch this season under a manager with a different philosophy/approach.
Read More
Hiles: I think Don Kelly handles the bullpen much differently than Derek Shelton, but the starters seem to be used in a similar way. I think the big difference with Keller in this second half is he won’t have to deal with a six-man rotation — at least until the start of September.
Keller is a guy who performs better on a regular schedule. I think last year’s constant shuffling of start days to build extra rest for Paul Skenes and Jared Jones messed with his rhythm a bit.
Bill: Why does Alex Canario still have a roster spot?
Hiles: I never understood why they acquired Alexander Canario to begin with. The move makes even less sense now, considering how little he plays. They can’t option him because he’s out of options. But they refuse to designate him for assignment.
He’s had four complete months in the majors to earn a better opportunity. I have no good answer other than the organization likely views him to have higher upside than any outfielder currently in Triple-A, which is a brutal but likely fair assessment.
STATZ N’ AT: You’re scrolling Baseball Reference or Fangraphs. What’s the first stat you look for when learning about a new pitcher? What about a new position player?
Hiles: Aside from the basic stats such as wins above replacement (WAR), OPS+ or ERA+, there are a few more advanced metrics I have learned to value over the years. For pitchers, I look at whiff rate, strikeouts per nine innings (K/9) and walks per nine innings (BB/9). Most of the young pitchers the Pirates acquire have nasty stuff. I’m typically looking to see just how good their pitch quality is and how well they can command the strike zone. I also like seeing the run value each specific pitch has on Baseball Savant.
As for position players, right now I’m looking at swing speed before everything else. They need guys who are going to post good slugging numbers, people who can hit the ball hard and far. Swing speed is a large component of that. Barrel rate is another important metric but one good organizations can improve. Swing speed is something that’s a bit more of a natural tool, at least in my opinion.
Derek: Why does the collective of the Pirates fanbase, including the media, approach the team like they are legitimate about sports, and how can we get to a point of applying immense pressure on the owner to either take this seriously or sell?
Hiles: Well, they are a major league baseball team. There are only 30 in existence, and one of them plays in Pittsburgh. They’re not very successful. They’re rarely competitive. But, again, they’re a major league baseball team and have been for over 150 years. Now, I get what you’re actually asking.
You’re wondering what needs to happen for people to collectively give the organization the cold shoulder, with the hope it finally convinces Bob Nutting to sell the team. I understand the logic — it’s just never going to happen. He’s not selling, no matter how upset fans are. At the end of the day, for Nutting, this is an investment, one that’s gone tremendously well.
When he took over in 2007, the team was running out of money. In his eyes, as long as the franchise doesn’t go bankrupt, it’s a success. Now, I do think he feels more pressure to win. The fans have made their frustration crystal clear throughout the season. I don’t think the Pirates truly grasped how livid their supporters were until April. But that’s no longer an issue.
The message has been received. So the fans have done their part. It’s time for ownership to change its tune.
Matthew: With Cherington’s comments about adding to the infield next year, who are some players you think they’d target in trades/free agency?
Hiles: If we’re talking realistic options, a guy I really like is Willi Castro. He’s a switch hitter and plays plus defense at multiple positions. He doesn’t fix the power problem in this lineup, but he’s a consistent hitter who would be an upgrade at either spot on the left side of the infield. I’d sign him to play shortstop until Konnor Griffin arrives and then move him to the weakest area in the lineup after.
His price tag shouldn’t be incredibly high. He also has playoff experience and would be a good mentor for some of the Latin American players, most notably Oneil Cruz. All of those reasons make him a perfect multiyear deal candidate for this club. As far as trades are concerned, if we’re talking infielders, a name I will throw out again is Coby Mayo. He’s incredibly raw, but I think there is a lot of long-term value there due to his power tool.
Those are two infielders I have my eye on right now. I’ll be sure to have a list of many more names once the season officially comes to an end.
Thanks for reading the Pirates mailbag! If you haven’t already, subscribe to our new Pirates YouTube channel here.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.