For the first time in a while, the Pirates are experiencing life without David Bednar. It hasn’t been as smooth a transition as they’d hoped.

The Pirates have dropped four of six since the trade deadline — not entirely unexpected, given they traded established players for prospects. The greater surprise is how the bullpen has struggled, as it blew a late lead in three of the four losses.

Some of it stems from the starting pitching, as the Pirates haven’t had a starter go longer than five innings over the past week. But some of it comes from the ripple effects of the Bednar trade. Much of the bullpen is now pitching in higher-leverage roles than before July 31.

“We've talked about that opportunity that guys are going to get ... to step up into mid-leverage, high-leverage roles, and they're going to get an opportunity to pitch in those situations,” manager Don Kelly said Wednesday after a 4-2 loss to the Giants, during which Isaac Mattson and Dennis Santana struggled in the final two innings. “Again, today, it's hard. Mattson and Santana have been so good for us. It's hard to blame them at all for what happened. I thought they threw the ball pretty well. Other guys are going to get opportunities, too, as we go through these last two months.”

Advertise with us

The post-Bednar bullpen has included new faces and new roles. Santana has pitched the ninth both times the Pirates have had a lead to protect. Kyle Nicolas, Dauri Moreta, Cam Sanders and Thomas Harrington (briefly) have all joined the Pirates ’pen, in part due to the deadline moves.

Santana’s first three outings as the top leverage arm haven’t gone to plan, but he’s confident it’s just a tough few days and he’ll get back to his early-season self.

“It’s been tough lately since Colorado,” Santana said. “ ... The first half was incredible, so I know that they got the player who had six months without giving up many runs.”

While bullpen roles can be replaced quickly, it’ll take longer to fill Bednar’s role among his colleagues. Bednar had established himself as the leader of the relievers and a leader on the team as a whole.

He’s missed on the field and in the community, but he’s missed in the clubhouse, as well.

Advertise with us

“Huge loss,” lefty Ryan Borucki said. “Obviously from the pitcher that he is, but just more importantly, the person that he is, that he brings to the field every day. He was one of my best buddies, so I was really sad to see him go.”

Borucki said Bednar served as an example for younger players. Yes, his routine and mindset were something to emulate, but he also took pride in being the closer and being a Pirate.

“You would never know if he just blew a save or rattled off four, five saves in a row,” Borucki said. “He just came as the same person every day. I think that’s all you can ask for, especially as a teammate. He never rode too high, never rode too low. He just always had a big smile on his face and worked hard. He did everything the way that a pro is supposed to do it.”

Bednar, at least publicly, wasn’t a rah-rah type of leader. He wasn’t the clubhouse hype man or someone who would be confrontational or publicly call out teammates. But he was someone who was willing to have tough conversations.

Mattson had one of those with Bednar. A month ago, Mattson had a rough series, allowing a walk-off single one night and a solo homer the next in Kansas City. The latter was the first (and so far only) loss of Mattson’s major league career. Bednar kept his message simple.

Advertise with us

“ ‘Hey, there's going to be times throughout the course of your career where things don't go your way, and just [be] able to frame that and learn from it,’ ” Mattson, speaking before Wednesday’s game, remembered Bednar saying. “Hearing that from a guy like him, knowing what he's gone through over the last couple of years, battled through and gotten back to who he is as a closer and as a professional, to see that growth in him and then be able to have those conversations in the midst of struggling, his willingness to have those conversations is huge.”

Santana looked up to Bednar, too, as he did Aroldis Chapman last year. With both gone, he could step up as a leader.

That said, Santana also wants to stay true to himself and his own style of leadership.

“I think I’ve got to be the same guy,” Santana said. “If I’ve got to help my teammates, I’ll do it. With them gone, if I’ve got to take Dave’s spot and help anybody, I’m going to be like, ‘That’s good with me.’ ”

As Kelly mentioned, other Pirates will have additional leverage responsibilities with Bednar in New York. Santana will keep the bulk of ninth-inning opportunities, while Mattson and Braxton Ashcraft will continue to take on new challenges. New faces could emerge, too.

Advertise with us

The clubhouse replacement will be harder to find, which is where Bednar will truly be missed.

“He's just a pro,” Borucki said. “He was Pittsburgh. He loves this city, loves this team and everything that went about being the closer and he did it in such a professional way. It's definitely sad to see him go.”