In his weekly radio show Sunday afternoon, Pirates general manager Ben Cherington reiterated that his trade deadline focus was on improving the 2026 team through adding young talent, payroll flexibility and creating opportunities for young players in August and September.

He also said that payroll flexibility, and the money the Pirates saved through trading players like Ke’Bryan Hayes and David Bednar, would be reinvested into the team’s payroll in the offseason.

“I think it's important to emphasize first that if we make a trade involving a player on a contract, as we did in the case with Ke’Bryan, we would never make a trade in order to save money,” Cherington told team broadcaster Joe Block. “That's never part of the calculus.”

Cherington described three questions that he asks whenever a trade like that is made — what are the Pirates getting back, what do the Pirates have internally to replace who they’re trading, and what can the freed-up payroll space be used for?

Advertise with us

The hope is that those three lead to the Pirates having “a better chance to win,” in Cherington’s words. “The story hasn’t been fully written on that one,” he admitted.

“The trades themselves, and if we’re trading players with salary for example, in almost every case, just about 100% of time, that [money] is going to go back into the payroll,” Cherington said. “If we think about next year, we're trading a player — again, Ke’Bryan as the example who had a salary guaranteed next year — that's not to save that money. That's so that we can use that money in some other ways on players.”

Cherington was also asked why he felt the deadline was the right time to deal Bednar. He said that there had been conversations with Bednar about a contract extension throughout Bednar’s time in Pittsburgh, though not in recent weeks. It came down to the value Cherington believed the Pirates got in return for Bednar, as well as payroll flexibility.

Bednar will be entering his final year of arbitration and his salary (currently $5.9 million) will rise, which Cherington said Bednar fully deserved. However, Cherington believed the Pirates would be better served spending on something other than a closer.

“There are going to be places on the roster where we take a shot and invest money, whether that's a free agent or whether that's an internal extension, etc.,” Cherington said. “We’ve got to pick our spots, and that's more often than not going to be on a position player or a starting pitcher. Every once in a while, we can do that with a relief pitcher, even a really good one like David, though sometimes we have to make these tough calls. It was indeed that. It was a tough call, very hard, but also clear. We felt that this is the right thing for the Pirates, and we wish him the absolute best.”

Advertise with us

Veterans stay put

Cherington was asked about a recent Post-Gazette story in which veterans Tommy Pham, Isiah Kiner-Falefa and Andrew Heaney were asked for their reactions on not being traded. All were expected to be moved, as their contracts expire at the end of the season, but all were kept.

Each believes there’s benefit in keeping veterans like themselves, with Kiner-Falefa saying, “By keeping us around, we’re here for the young guys to ask us questions” and adding they can help the Pirates “build something.”

Cherington agreed, listing each player individually,

“You mentioned Tommy — what a great example to see someone fight back from really a difficult start to the season,” Cherington said. “That requires toughness, patience, resilience, really a want-to that is a really important character trait for players on a winning team. Izzy is just someone who just brings it every day. He brings it every day in the lineup. Defense, baserunning, offense, consistent quality situational at-bats, making plays defensively. Just a player that's always prepared, setting that example that way.

“And Heaney is competing his tail off with stuff that — look, let's be honest, is not what it once was for him. But he's doing it and he's more often than not, when he's out there, [he’s] giving our team a chance to stay in and a chance to win games. And he's been a really good veteran influence and experienced sort of voice for younger pitchers. You see him on the top step of the dugout when he's not pitching.”

Advertise with us

Prospect rankings

Cherington also said that having a better farm system puts you in a better position — both in the most obvious sense, where prospects can be promoted to help the major league team, but also, as trade pieces.

Cherington spoke about prospect rankings, saying that while the Pirates do sometimes use public rankings, like MLB Pipeline, they mainly use it to cross-check against their own model. This seemed to be in response to his Thursday comments on the return in the Bednar trade, as he said the Pirates were offered higher-ranked packages than the Yankees’ return of Rafael Flores, Edgleen Perez and Brian Sanchez, but preferred that offer.

“We simply believe that the process we have internally and what we create internally, in terms of the final ranking, which includes those external [rankings] as an input, is even more precise and more predictive than the external ones,” Cherington said. “... It doesn’t make the decision by itself, but it’s a really strong starting point.”