DENVER — Pirates general manager Ben Cherington approached the 2025 MLB trade deadline with one goal: put the club in a better position to be competitive in 2026. When all was said and done, Pittsburgh added nine new players to its organization, only one of whom has played in a major league game.

By the time the deadline expired, there were many who had more questions than answers. From notable departures to questionable returns to perhaps simply not doing enough, we will cover it all below. Here are the Post-Gazette’s five takeaways from the Pirates’ trade deadline activity:

Better in 2026?

At the end of the day, the only question that matters is this: Are the Pirates on track to be a better ball club next year?

As things currently stand, it’s hard to understand any argument suggesting that to be the case.

Advertise with us

The Pirates added nine new players to their organization. None of those nine newcomers will join the major league club Friday in Denver. None of the eight prospects can be found on any top-100 list, and most of them aren’t even close to reaching Double-A.

High-A Greensboro’s odds of competing for a league title dramatically increased Thursday evening. The big-league club? Not so much. This, however, is a positive in the eyes of Cherington, who contends the team’s added minor league depth will create more opportunities.

“I think we took an important step,” Cherington said Thursday evening. “We’re certainly not finished, but we thought about it as we want to take a step on three things. We want to accomplish three things. One is we want to add more young talent in the organization, talent that we can grow with. Number 2 is to create the right opportunities for August and September for players and pitchers that we believe have the best chance to be part of that team in 2026 that we’re building toward.

“And then finally, if the opportunities were out there that made sense, create some maneuverability, some options for us this offseason, where we can reallocate payroll perhaps into other parts of the team. We wanted to try to accomplish parts of all three of those things, and we believe we did. We certainly have more work to do once it hits November.”

Cherington contends some departures — most notably the ones of Ke’Bryan Hayes and Bailey Falter — will create opportunities to improve the club, either from opening a space on the major league roster or through having additional money to commit toward the major league payroll. We’ll address both of those notions later on, but for now, let’s just say it’s easy to understand why such remarks have been met with heavy skepticism.

Advertise with us

The one they got right

This might not be a popular take for some, but this writer contends the best move the Pirates made was trading Hayes to the Cincinnati Reds. This was simply a marriage that needed to end. Neither side was getting what it expected when the two agreed to a long-term commitment, and it was better for all parties involved to rip the Band-Aid off and move on.

“We can look back and think about the moment that we did the contract — and I certainly haven’t forgotten what I said at the time — and we believe that that contract made sense and certainly believed in Key at that time. And Key’s done a lot of good things on the baseball field for us in a Pirates uniform,” Cherington said. “ ... We got to a point where we decided that the combination of the talent we get for Key, the opportunity that opens up for other players and the opportunity that it gives us this offseason to reallocate some of those dollars into other parts of the team added up to making sense.”

A combination of bad injury luck and poor attitude prevented Hayes from reaching his full potential in Pittsburgh. The Pirates are equally guilty, as they failed to create a winning environment around their third baseman. The fact Cherington still managed to land Sammy Stafura — perhaps the second-best prospect acquired through all six trades — and Taylor Rogers, who was flipped about 24 hours later, should be considered a win.

The Pirates now have a clean slate at third base. Jared Triolo, Hayes’ likely replacement, is far from the final answer. But with money to spend and more assets to move, they have a key — pun intended — spot in the lineup to upgrade.

The Bednar return

With the exception of drafting Paul Skenes first overall in 2023, David Bednar was the best acquisition Cherington has made during his time in Pittsburgh. Cherington has acquired hundreds of players throughout his Pirates tenure. Only one of them made an All-Star team. And that individual will now be wearing pinstripes.

Advertise with us

The idea of trading Bednar made sense. The Pirates have other capable options to pitch in the ninth inning. After watching his value absolutely plummet last season, it was smart to strike after the right-hander re-established himself as one of the best relievers in the game. His additional year of control made him an even more attractive asset, as the Pirates could set their price.

But it’s worth wondering if they got the most for this asset.

Bednar’s departure brought back three prospects: Rafael Flores, Edgleen Perez and Brian Sanchez. Flores is, as Cherington put it, “the headliner” of the deal. There are things to like about the 24-year-old. He boasts solid size, measuring 6-foot-4, 230 pounds. He has dominated the High-A and Double-A levels, recently earning himself a promotion to Triple-A, which is where he will start his tenure with the Pirates. He was also the Yankees’ No. 8 prospect and is expected to rank even better within the Pirates system.

This didn’t have to be the case.

The Post-Gazette spoke with front-office members from multiple teams that made a strong push for Bednar throughout the past week. On Tuesday, sources said Pittsburgh’s asking price for Bednar was, at minimum, a top-five prospect from an organization. That price went up Wednesday, as two separate clubs indicated the Pirates were asking for a top-75 prospect in baseball.

Advertise with us

That return would have been appropriate, as it would have matched similar payouts for other elite closers who were moved at this deadline. But as Cherington explained Thursday evening, it wasn’t the return he and his staff decided was best.

“Feel really strongly about the return,” Cherington said. “We had access to players who were ranked [on top-100 prospect lists]. We did, and we preferred this package. Obviously every team is going to assess the players a little bit differently, and sometimes that could be different from the public rankings, also. It was our estimation and our opinion that this was not just a really strong collection of talent to get for David Bednar, but also the best one that we had access to in this market.”

Flores has potential to be a decent big-league power hitter. And the Pirates should pray he turns out to be that, if not more.

While Bednar’s time in Pittsburgh included a rough stretch toward the end, he will overall be remembered as a very productive Pirate, one who represented the club and the city well. Flores will forever be known as the man who replaced the hometown hero. He is now the second-most important hitting prospect in the organization behind Konnor Griffin. And if he doesn’t perform instantly in Triple-A — and then again whenever he reaches the majors — fans are going to make their frustrations known.

On the flip side, Flores having immediate success also creates an issue for the Pirates. His two primary positions — catcher and first base — are currently occupied by players who represent large commitments by this current regime. Henry Davis is a first overall pick. Endy Rodriguez is a former top-100 prospect. Spencer Horwitz was the big acquisition from last year.

Advertise with us

If Flores is a starter next year on opening day, does that mean the Pirates are giving up on one of those three aforementioned names? If so, even a big win would include yet another development loss for this regime. How unfortunate — yet appropriate.

You’re still here?

Perhaps the most surprising move the Pirates made this trade season was sending Bailey Falter to the Royals. The return didn’t net much, but as Cherington explained, the move’s true purpose was to create an opening for other young arms within the system.

“We liked the players we got for Bailey, and as we looked forward toward 2026, it was really looking toward, ‘OK, what starting pitchers in the organization have the best chance to be part of that rotation in 2026, and how do we give those guys the best chance to be ready for that?’” Cherington said. “As you know, we’ve got a lot of other guys. I mentioned [Johan] Oviedo. There are others. Obviously Michael Burrows is already getting starts. So as we look toward that period of time in August, September, really trying to set up guys towards going into 2026, we felt the combination of the players we got back and the opportunity it opened up for others made sense.”

This logic makes sense ... until one realizes Andrew Heaney is still on the roster. Make no mistake — this is not a jab at Heaney, who has been nothing short of a pro during his time in Pittsburgh. But his numbers are worse than Falter’s, and he is on an expiring contract — unlike Falter, who has three more years of remaining club control.

So why wasn’t Heaney moved? Per Cherington, there just wasn’t a market for a veteran left-hander with postseason pitching experience.

Advertise with us

“Once we knew that the Falter trade was happening, we just decided to hold on to Andrew and expect he’ll pitch tomorrow night,” Cherington said. “Looking forward to seeing him pitch tomorrow night.”

Cherington added the same logic applies for both Isiah Kiner-Falefa and Tommy Pham, who are veterans also on expiring deals. Both were traded last year at the deadline. Both are performing at a similar level or — in Pham’s case — better. Yet, according to the Pirates general manager, neither had a team willing to offer proper value for their services.

Should this actually be the case, this is a bad look for Cherington in multiple ways. Either his front office is simply not doing enough to sell the assets on the roster, or the front office is holding veterans on expiring contracts at way too high of a price.

Either way, the Pirates now find themselves in a situation where three older players will be taking reps away from younger prospects who have far more future value to the organization.

Just last year, the Pirates designated Rowdy Tellez and Michael A. Taylor for assignment in the final week of the season to create playing time for younger players on the 40-man roster. Now they will be going out of their way to pay a trio of veterans nearly $4.7 million to play in meaningless games for a club that has a low likelihood of retaining them for 2026.

Advertise with us

Time to spend

The final point to be made here is both the most obvious and most significant. The Pirates have zero excuse not to be dramatically more involved in the free agent market in 2026.

As noted by our columnist Jason Mackey, the exits of Hayes, Falter and Bednar gave the Pirates around $18 million to play with next season. They’ll get $16 million more to spend once Kiner-Falefa, Pham and Heaney are off the books. Add even more assuming Andrew McCutchen, Tim Mayza and Ryan Borucki all don’t return.

That’s $41.3 million gone from this roster, $41.3 million that can be reinvested into the starting lineup. There is also, of course, the idea of adding even more money to that total — a concept Bob Nutting should strongly consider if he truly wants to see better results.

But even with all this being established, Cherington still provided little faith the team’s method will change when asked if the Pirates will be a larger player in free agency this year.

“Could be,” Cherington said. “I think we need to get into it — trades and internal improvement, too. Internal players and internal improvement — those are the areas where we’re always gonna rely on more than free agency. We’ve got to operate well and excel in those areas. But, sure, we’ll be open-minded about free agency.

Advertise with us

“We’ve pursued legitimate major league position players in the past here since I’ve been here, and I’m sure we’ll do it again. It’s never going to be one thing that solves that issue and helps us figure out the offense that leads to a winning team. It’s always going to be lots of things, and a lot of that has to happen internally.”

It’s worth noting there is a decent chance Cherington won’t be the one making those decisions. His performance over the past six years gives plenty of reason for Nutting to feel now is the time for change.

Yet, even if that change is made, Cherington’s replacement isn’t exactly inheriting a winning situation. There will be no chance for a rebuild. The money available will be sizable perhaps by this franchise’s standards, but not likely enough to fill the many holes on this roster with established big-league talent. Trading Mitch Keller over the winter might help on that front but will be another tough, high-pressure move to make.

Regardless of who is running the show, the Pirates will head into the offseason with a very slim margin for error if they hope to truly improve in 2026. Perhaps such a reality could’ve been avoided with a better performance from the front office over the past month.