In a meeting with reporters Sunday ahead of next Thursday’s trade deadline, Pirates general manager Ben Cherington reiterated his deadline goal of improving the Pirates for 2026. He said he understands the need to add offense, but he also believes the Pirates will need to take on risks in order to do so.
“I don’t think we can be risk-averse,” Cherington said. “I don’t think that’s going to work in Pittsburgh. We want to win, we’re going to have to assume risk. With risk comes downside to that, obviously. If that doesn’t work out, we get criticized. That’s OK. I don’t think we can win without assuming that. … Sometimes that’s going to come in the form of a player that we believe in that hasn’t done anything in the big leagues yet. Until they do, there’s no proof that they will.”
At the same time, Cherington said he wants to make sure that the Pirates aren’t forcing a trade. Several Pirates are on one-year deals and still expected to be traded, but if the Pirates don’t find a deal they like for controlled assets like Mitch Keller, David Bednar, Dennis Santana and others, they could hold on to them.
“Part of it is not forcing it,” Cherington said. “We need to score more runs to win more games. That’s clear, and that’s a goal going into 2026. … We’ve got to stay disciplined and not do something that we don’t believe in just because it brings back a position player that might look a little bit better on the roster. So we’ve got to stay disciplined.”
As the Pirates look to construct their identity for 2026, Cherington said that they’re also focused on determining what they’ve done a good job developing, what they’re working on, and what traits players can have to lead to success in Pittsburgh.
Cherington went into some of the risks that the Pirates could take before the trade deadline, which comes on Thursday (July 31) at 6 p.m. Much of that comes with unproven players.
Read More
“We also know in Pittsburgh, and in a lot of cases, we’re going to be acquiring players who are not fully proven yet, who we believe can contribute,” Cherington said, referring to both pitchers and hitters. “... Part of this, of getting better, is really doing that really well, acquiring those less-proven players and bringing them into an environment where they can thrive and are getting better. We’ve seen some examples of that happening, maybe a little bit more on the pitching side. We’ve got to do that really well, too.”
Cherington said the market has been “very busy,” which is in line with previous years. He expects it to get busier as the week continues.
Bednar and Keller
While the Pirates have been willing to take calls on just about anyone, Keller and Bednar are seen as the top two assets who are likely to move. Keller, under contract through 2028, has a 3.53 ERA and leads the league in quality starts. Bednar, signed through 2026, hasn’t allowed an earned run in 23 consecutive outings.
Cherington addressed Bednar first.
“I think I’ve said something like this before, but I do mean it: I’m not sure I can recall a single player who has been as strong on the field and off the field and who happens to be from that city as David has been,” Cherington said. “The sort of trifecta of those things is not lost on any of us. … I don’t know what’s going to happen. He’s a really valuable pitcher, a really important person. I think we should take that very seriously. Any conversations I have with him I’ll keep between him and I, but I have a huge amount of respect for him.”
Keller and Bednar are both leaders in the clubhouse, well-respected players who have proven their talent.
“If we’re going to be better in 2026, we need more of that, not less,” Cherington said. “We would only contemplate giving up something that’s seemingly more proven if we really believe that they give us a better chance to be better by next year. So we’ll see how that goes.”
Cherington’s job security
Cherington’s job status has been a hot topic as he’s remained in charge in his sixth season even as the Pirates are well out of the playoff race.
Cherington was part of the Pirates’ MLB draft plans and is leading the club at the deadline. He was asked if he views that as an endorsement by ownership that he is the right person to continue leading the Pirates.
“Honestly, the schedule in July is so busy that I don’t really have time to think about much other than just do the work and execute,” Cherington said. “My job is to serve the Pirates. My job is to wake up every day and find a way to help the Pirates get better, period. That’s the only thing I care about. I have consistent communication with Bob and Travis about how we’re trying to do that. That communication happens every day and we’re going to continue to make the recommendations that we believe put the Pirates in a strong position going forward.”
Cervantes and the draft
Monday at 5 p.m. is the deadline for teams to sign their MLB draft picks. With a little more than a day before that deadline, the Pirates have signed 18 of their 21 draftees.
However, the Pirates have been unable to sign their second-round pick, high school right-hander Angel Cervantes. Cervantes announced on Wednesday night that he will be attending his hometown school UCLA instead. The slot value of the No. 50 overall pick, which the Pirates used to select Cervantes, was $1,934,700.
Cherington confirmed Sunday that the Pirates will not strike a deal with Cervantes.
“We understood enough about the situation, what we were hearing about him and his representatives that there was some risk that he would not sign,” Cherington said. “We took him knowing that. We planned for that in the later rounds and after the 10th round and we did, I believe, make a very aggressive and fair offer for him, which he ultimately chose to turn down, and I respect that. Respect that decision, wish him well.”
It’s rare that teams don’t sign their picks in the top-10 rounds. Just four of the 310 players selected in the top 10 rounds reportedly remain unsigned, per MLB’s tracker: Cervantes; Marlins’ competitive balance pick Cam Cannarella, who is expected to sign; and two Dodgers picks. One of those Dodgers picks is sixth-rounder Mason Ligenza, who will head to Pitt.
“After my advisor gave me a call that the Pirates didn’t meet in the middle with my number, I was comfortable going to college,” Cervantes told the Los Angeles Times’ Eric Sondheimer on Thursday. “Going pro was one of my biggest dreams. I had another big dream to play for UCLA. I had a field trip to UCLA in elementary school, and by my sophomore year, I’m committed. It’s pretty awesome thinking about it.”
The Pirates were unable to use Cervantes’ slot value toward signing any players, but were able to use leftover over-slot money to sign 15th-round selection McLane Moody, a right-hander committed to Arkansas, and 17th-round outfielder Carter Gwost, an outfielder committed to Nebraska. They’ll also receive the 51st overall pick in next year’s draft.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.