Ahead of Day 2 of the MLB draft, the Pirates came up with a plan to attack, making 17 picks in less than eight hours.

Then they came up with a nickname: “plunder the deep.”

They came out of it feeling good about their efforts and excited about the players they selected.

“It was great,” said Pirates amateur scouting director Justin Horowitz, the person in charge of leading draft efforts.

Advertise with us

“Super proud of everyone in that room, everybody that was part of our process. … We were able to land a number of the targets that we were excited about all year long, and kudos to them for all the hard work that went into that process and put us in a position to land some players that we think have a chance to exceed expectations hopefully and make an impact for the Pirates.”

The Pirates’ goal Monday, as it was with their top four selections Sunday, was to take the best player available. They said they did that. But they also believe they found some offense, as of their 17 Day 2 selections, eight were college bats.

“Exciting to be able to bring in a handful of college bats that we hope have various ways to make an impact in our organization,” Horowitz said. “Offensively, defensively, on the basepaths. It's a variety of different players that we brought in today, and each one we're excited about for different reasons. Certainly should help us in the offensive space throughout the organization."

There were a couple of headliners. Seventh-round pick Brent Iredale, an Australian who went to Arkansas, hit .286 with 14 homers and is still developing. Eighth-round pick Josh Tate, from Georgia Southern, hit .362 with 12 homers. Horowitz believes there’s more untapped power there.

But the biggest bat is a name Pirates fans know well — Jared Jones. No, not that one. This Jones, a 21-year-old first baseman from national champion LSU, batted .323 with 22 homers and 76 RBIs. Many expected him to be picked in the top-five rounds. Instead, he fell to the Pirates in the ninth.

Advertise with us

“I honestly was a little bit surprised he was still available around that area of the draft,” Horowitz said. “That kid has some of the biggest power, if not the most power, in the draft. He's proven it at the highest level in college baseball, playing for a program that is potentially the best in college baseball. So a lineup anchor and someone we're excited about.”

There are some concerns with Jones, namely his defense and his swing-and-miss rate, but his power is both undeniable and something the Pirates need more of.

“There's one thing that he can do that very few people in the world can do,” Horowitz said, “and that's hit the ball really, really hard and really, really far. So we're pretty excited about that opportunity for him."

And as expected with the “plunder the deep” theme, the Pirates think they’ve found some buried treasure.

They’re excited about fourth-round pick Gustavo Melendez, a shortstop from a high school in Puerto Rico, Tate, and a couple of pitchers. 12th-round pick Cameron Keshock, from Samford, has a 6-foot-7 frame and a couple tools they can tinker with. And 19th-round pick Brandon Cain is the deepest of deep dives, given he pitched to a total of six batters in college.

Advertise with us

“He's been a two-way player in the past,” Horowitz said of Cain. “He's very athletic. Got a big arm. Someone we're excited to bring into the organization and hand off to our pitching development people and … help the kid tap into all that untapped potential.”

Best availability is ‘signability’

The MLB draft is different than other drafts, as selecting a player isn’t a guarantee that they’ll sign and join the organization. Teams have a bonus pool — $14,088,400, in the Pirates’ case — that they can spend how they want. And players, especially prep products, can decide to forgo signing and enroll in college instead.

We won’t know which players cut deals to sign for below slot value until signings are announced, which will happen between Monday and the July 28 deadline.

But the Pirates did select a number of players who, at least at first glance, appear likely to go to college if they’re not blown away by a financial offer; 14th round pick Connor Hamilton, 15th-round pick McLane Moody and 20th-round pick Nick Frusco are all prep arms committed to top programs.

So too is 17th-round pick Carter Gwost, a Minnesota outfielder committed to Nebraska. Horowitz said all are talented and worth the risk.

Advertise with us

“As you get deeper into the draft, especially in rounds 11-20, it certainly gets a little bit more difficult to sign high school players,” Horowitz said.

“But at certain points, you also want to take some shots. We would love to bring every single one of them into the organization, to be honest. Like I said, they're all really talented. Some may be more viable than others at the end of the day. In those areas of the draft, it made sense for us to take a couple shots, and we'll see what happens.”

Jones, too, may fall into that category. He could return to LSU for presumably a lucrative NIL deal instead of taking the Pirates’ offer. However, if he did, he wouldn’t have the same leverage after the 2026 MLB draft. Horowitz said the Pirates are "optimistic" they’ll sign Jones, but acknowledged modern college athletics has changed draft strategy.

“I won't lie, it makes our jobs a little bit tougher, but it's the environment we're in,” Horowitz said. “We're all playing the same game. The kids have every right to do what's in their own best interests. I personally totally support them for that. Definitely makes the draft a more challenging exercise.”

Local kid selected

The Pirates selected local product Dylan Mathiesen, a right-handed pitcher, in the 13th round. Mathiesen, a Montour grad who went to California (Pa.) before a year at Liberty, was the 2022 Post-Gazette Class 4A Player of the Year and an all-Area team selection.

Advertise with us

Mathiesen is currently recovering from elbow surgery, but Horowitz was still excited about him.

“Yeah, Dylan was another one that came through the day two 'Plunder the Deep' project,” Horowitz said, crediting Virginia area supervisor Matt Doughty. “... We selected the player because we're super excited about his talent and his character, but it's also pretty cool that he's fairly local and wanted to be a Pirate.”