SAN DIEGO — Often a man of few words, Paul Skenes still understands the power that his voice holds. Not far removed from his one-year anniversary in the major leagues, the 23-year-old right-hander is already one of the sport’s biggest individual brands.
When Skenes talks, the baseball world listens. His opinion is valuable, especially in this town. Which is perhaps what made his comments on May 9, the day after the Pirates fired manager Derek Shelton, so substantial.
“Unfortunately I wasn’t shocked,” Skenes said that afternoon. “At the end of the day we’re 12-26. Someone’s got to be held accountable and unfortunately right now, it’s him. That’s just kind of how it goes, but I don’t know that it fixes the root of the issue, which is we need to play better. That’s been the messaging today, that’s been the messaging for a little bit now and we’ve still got to do that.”
An entire team’s worth of frustration was visible on Skenes’ face that afternoon. Interviews have never been something the right-hander has enjoyed, and having to do one on the topics of losing, failure, etc., undoubtedly made the situation even more unpleasant. But despite his discontent for the overall setting, he did make use of his platform.
When asked what he hoped would come from the remainder of the Pirates’ 2025 campaign, Skenes sent a strong message to the entire organization.
“I think that’s one thing that we need to figure out as a group, is what our goal is for the season and figure out how to get there,” Skenes said. “Salvageable — what does that mean? I’m not saying that for the media, but what does it mean in the locker room, too? If nothing else, we better grow, because if we don’t grow then it’s a completely lost season. Just gotta keep going and understand the urgency of where we’re at right now.”
Read More
Three weeks have gone by since Skenes delivered those words. In that time, the club, at least in some areas, looks to be improving. The Pirates entered the weekend with a 9-10 record in the 19 games played under Don Kelly’s management.
The team’s pitching was notably better, boasting a 3.36 ERA under Kelly compared to a 4.31 ERA under Shelton. Their run production, however, didn’t necessarily follow. The club was slashing .241/.316/.358 under Kelly, compared to .219/.300/.325 under Shelton. While on the surface it’s also an improvement, even those figures aren’t good enough, as none of them rank in the top half of MLB.
Perhaps the most notable trend in Kelly’s first three weeks at the helm was an increase in close contests.
Fourteen of the 19 games (73.6%) he had managed entering the weekend had been decided by three or less runs. Ten of them (52.6%) have been one-run ball games. Those figures are more favorable than what occurred under Shelton, where the team only had 12 one-run games (31.6%) and 22 contests determined by three or less runs (57.8%).
While Kelly’s sample size is smaller, his contests have come against a similar caliber of opponent (.534 combined winning percentage) to what the team faced under Shelton this year (.546). The Pirates are also finding a way to win more in those close games, going 5-5 in the 10 one-run games under Kelly versus 5-7 in the 12 one-run games under Shelton.
So, what’s the significance behind these numbers? For some, it simply comes down to execution.
“We’re just playing better baseball,” Andrew McCutchen said. “It’s the obvious stuff that we’re doing. We’re doing things right, and that’s helping us win some ball games. Can’t get to the reasons why. We’re just playing good baseball.”
For others, it’s a change in messaging that has allowed the Pirates to better execute in their close games.
“There was definitely a spark when we made the move,” Ryan Borucki said. “I think guys are just buying into what Donnie brings. He’s the same guy every day. He just wants you to play hard and leave it all on the field. Guys really aren’t pressing any more, so it’s one of those things where we can take a deep breath, play loose and do their thing.”
Regardless of reasoning, the Pirates are playing better. A team that once viewed “winning on the margins,” as its only chance to compete is now doing so under new leadership. Following Thursday’s win, Skenes was asked to circle back to an answer he gave the day after Shelton’s firing, when he was asked what could be gained from the remaining 2025 season.
"We've grown as a team,” he said. “I don't think it's necessarily because everybody has changed what they were doing. We've done a good job sticking with the process, leading ourselves. We're doing what we need to do, and I think it's kinda showing up now."
While things have been better, the Pirates still aren’t winning at a rate that will allow them to reach .500, let alone the opportunity to play actual meaningful baseball this year. But with the playoffs well out of sight, any sort of progress for the remaining four months of the season should be embraced — especially when it meets the approval of the franchise’s most important player.
THREE UP
- Sizzlin’ Skenes: Paul Skenes struck out seven batters over 6 ⅔ innings on Wednesday against the Diamondbacks, marking his third consecutive outing of six-plus innings, one or fewer runs allowed and seven-plus strikeouts. This marks the second time Skenes has accomplished such a feat, the first time coming on June 11-29. Gerrit Cole (2013), Bob Veale (1965) and Red Witt (1958) are the only other Pirates pitchers to achieve this.
- Watch it fly: Oneil Cruz’s home run Sunday against the Brewers registered at an exit velocity of 122.9 mph, a record for the Statcast era. The previous record was also held by Cruz, a 122.4 mph hit that resulted in a single on Aug. 24 of last season.
- First time: After entering the week 0-29 in games when trailing after seven innings, the Pirates earned their first win in such a situation Tuesday, rallying to score nine unanswered runs in their 9-6 win against the Diamondbacks.
THREE DOWN
- Strugglin’ Solak: Recalled from Triple-A after batting an International League leading .393, Solak has struggled in his brief time at the game’s highest level, entering the weekend with just one hit in 11 at-bats. That hit came in his first at-bat.
- Another zero: The Pirates were shut out for an MLB-worst ninth time Monday. Ryne Nelson led the charge in that effort, leading the Diamondbacks to a 5-0 victory thanks to his 6 ⅔ scoreless frames.
- Second try is the charm: Endy Rodriguez was recalled Wednesday from Triple-A Indianapolis. Rodriguez struggled mightily prior to being sidelined due to injury, hitting .178 in 15 major league games this year.
ON DECK
- Big swinging ’Stros: Pittsburgh’s next opponent, the Astros, are one of the top hitting lineups in the game, entering the weekend with a .255 batting average, good for sixth-best in MLB.
- The out Hunter: Astros right-hander Hunter Brown is in the midst of a breakout season, entering the weekend with a 7-3 record and 2.00 ERA, which is sixth-best in MLB.
- Fightin’ Phills: The Phillies arrive into town following the Pirates’ three-game series against Houston. Philadelphia entered the weekend in first place of the NL East, two games ahead of the Mets.
IN THE PEN
There has been a great deal of table banging for Henry Davis to take over as the Pirates’ primary catcher. Let me be the first to do the same for Alexander Canario in left field. Only 25 years old, it’s easy to understand why the Pirates took a flyer on Canario. The raw tools are there. Per Baseball Savant, he ranks in the 76th percentile in bat speed and the 83rd percentile in arm strength. Last season, he was rated the Cubs’ No. 12 prospect per MLB Pipeline. Canario has produced well during the past few weeks, his first stretch of consistency in the big leagues. Entering the weekend, he was slashing .313/.361/.839 in his last 18 games. Enough with Tommy Pham. It’s time to figure out if the Pirates truly have something with Canario.
NUMEROLOGY
19 — The Pirates’ 19 runs scored against the Diamondbacks were the most the club has tallied in any series this season. That feat occurred despite the club getting shut out in the first game of the series.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.