In some ways, Memorial Day can be a good marker for how a baseball season is going. There’s plenty of baseball left to play, enough that a season is rarely over, but not enough to determine which team will win the pennant.
The Pirates are 19-34. They’ve played better baseball of late, winning four of five, but are 12.5 games back in the division before June.
Despite this, in his weekly radio show, Pirates general manager Ben Cherington recommitted that he believes the Pirates can “play winning baseball in 2025.”
“That’s what we’re focused on,” Cherington said. “In saying that, I’m saying that outside of what the record is on paper. Whatever the record is, we believe in 2025, we can and [we’re] certainly focused on playing winning baseball. We believe we can get to a team and do the work to get to a team that is playing winning baseball.”
Cherington didn’t say exactly what winning baseball would be, but agreed with Pirates broadcaster Joe Block’s definition of “good quality baseball that wins ballgames more often than not.”
That said, Cherington didn’t say that the Pirates would be a playoff team in 2025 or even that they wouldn’t be sellers at the trade deadline in July.
Read More
“What that means for our record at the end of the season, I don’t know,” Cherington said. “What that means for our record at the end of July, I don’t know. We’ll find out. But that’s the first thing.”
He went on to list some other goals for the season, noting that below the goal of winning baseball, there are player development priorities as well.
“We want to see and help younger players develop and improve and become part of the core of the team,” Cherington said. “We want to create opportunity for that. But just as much, we want to put veteran players in a position to succeed, too. That’s a part of it. Underneath that highest level goal, there will be specific priorities and things we look to do as the season goes on. But it all bubbles up to the same thing. We want to be playing winning baseball as fast as we possibly can in a way that gives us a chance to keep getting better.”
Compliments Carmen
While Cherington was complimentary of Mike Burrows, who made the first start of his major league career on Thursday, he was also sure to note the performance of the guy who Burrows replaced in the rotation.
Right-hander Carmen Mlodzinski, who had started nine games for the Pirates, was sent down to Triple-A Indianapolis on Wednesday. On Friday, he made his first start against Toledo, and he scattered four hits across six shutout innings. He struck out 10.
“To Carmen’s credit, he went down and pitched Friday for Indy and was dominant,” Cherington said. “Went down and did exactly what we were hoping he would do in that outing.”
Mlodzinski will continue to start in Indianapolis, instead of returning to a bullpen role he had success in in 2024. Cherington believes Mlodzinski could be back with the Pirates at some point, potentially playing his way back into the starting rotation.
“Carmen’s going to knock on the door again here in 2025,” Cherington said. “I expect him to and it’s a matter of time. But this is an opportunity for him to iron some stuff out.”
Injury notes
Cherington spoke more about starting pitcher Jared Jones, saying that Jones’ Wednesday surgery was not an injury setback.
Jones had been rehabbing from a UCL strain and was throwing out to around 100 feet when he reported symptoms, per director of sports medicine Todd Tomczyk. But Cherington once again said that Jones’ elbow looked the same way as it did during spring training.
“Nothing changed in terms of what was going on inside his elbow,” Cherington said. “… We just found out that unfortunately in his case, as he ramped up intensity, the elbow wasn’t stable enough to withstand that and he felt symptoms again. At that point, that’s telling us that we needed to go an alternate route to solve this thing.”
Cherington also said that Pirates right fielder Bryan Reynolds was a late scratch from the Pirates’ lineup on Sunday. He reported to the ballpark and felt tight. Cherington did not specify where Reynolds felt tight.
Tommy Pham moved into the Pirates’ lineup in left field, while Alexander Canario moved over to right.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.