ST. LOUIS — The Pirates lost their fifth-straight game Monday evening, falling to the Cardinals by a final score of 6-3 at Busch Stadium. Gordon Graceffo was the winning pitcher, improving to 2-0 on the season, while Chase Shugart suffered the loss, falling to 1-2. Ryan Helsley earned the save, his sixth of the season.
After leading 3-2 at the start of the sixth inning, the game quickly got away from Derek Shelton’s club when Shugart allowed four runs without recording a single out. Willson Contreras and Jose Barrero did the most damage that frame, as the former hit a go-ahead two-run homer, and the latter added on with a two-run double to left field.
A two-run home run from Bryan Reynolds in the top of the first inning and an RBI single from Adam Frazier in the top of the third accounted for the Pirates runs. The Cardinals bullpen handled the lineup well after starter Miles Mikolas exited, throwing four scoreless innings of relief to secure their victory.
A full recap of Monday’s game can be read here. Below are the Post-Gazette’s three takeaways from the contest.
‘That's what we're asking’
Carmen Mlodzinski’s biggest weakness this season isn’t much of a secret. A former relief pitcher, the right-hander has struggled pitching deep into ballgames since he transitioned into a starter. Entering Monday’s outing, Mlodzinski had limited opposing hitters to a .200 batting average and .559 OPS when facing them for the first time through the order. However, those figures respectively jumped to .460 and 1.160 the second time through the order.
With a full month of data to look over, the Pirates coaching staff has recently begun to use Mlodzinski different than the rest of the rotation. In his last start, Mlodzinski was pulled after facing exactly 18 batters. Shelton made the same decision again Monday, yanking the right-hander off the mound with two outs and no runners on base in the bottom of the fifth inning.
Read More
"I think at times there's going to be times that we just ask certain things of people, and right now, that's what we're asking,” Shelton explained after the loss. “He gave us a chance to win the ballgame. That's all you can ask for."
Shelton is not wrong — Mlodzinski did give his team a chance to win. The Pirates were ahead 3-2 at the time of his exit. Both Cardinals runs came on solo homers in the bottom of the third inning, but rather than allowing further damage, Mlodzinski regrouped and finished his work day on a high note. In the end, he allowed the two earned runs on just four hits with no walks, while striking out a pair.
"I honestly can't say I really liked my stuff today,” Mlodzinski said. “I think the results were OK, not great but not terrible. I think I kinda had to battle with not having my best stuff in a sense, but was able to get through close to five innings without having the quality stuff I try to have every time out. So, I guess it's a positive in the sense I was able to battle."
Perhaps Mlodzinski’s future battles will come in situations that better favor what he is currently capable of doing well at the game’s highest level. His production this season shows he can consistently retire batters from both sides of the plate the first time he faces them.
It’s clear that, at least for now, Mlodzinski is not built to be a true starting pitcher in MLB. His value is greater in the bullpen, where he can give the Pirates reliable production, sometimes in the form of multi-inning outings.
Shelton’s rhetoric after Monday’s loss perhaps indicated that a role change could soon be coming for the right-hander. And while Mlodzinski himself still remains driven to be a big-league starting pitcher, even he recognizes the value he provides in a lesser capacity.
"I think there are positives to look at,” Mlodzinski said. “I have success the first time through. I just gotta figure out a way to make better adjustments the second and third time. I think the last three outings I've done a little better of a job the second and third time through, or I haven't necessarily got to the third time. But I think I'm just continuing to make the adjustments, and I feel like that's all you can do in this game. Continue to adjust and whatever is working, obviously roll with that. And then make the adjustments when needed."
‘Just didn't have it’
With a one-run lead in the bottom of the sixth inning and a stretch of right-handed batters due up, Shelton turned to Shugart to keep the Pirates ahead. Last week, Shelton expressed a desire to get Shugart, who entered Monday with a 1.23 ERA, more opportunities to pitch in higher leverage. And this instance, at least on paper, made sense.
In 12 games this season, right-handed bats were hitting just .139 with a .385 OPS against Shugart. In 36 at-bats, he had logged 10 strikeouts and walked none. But the numbers didn’t matter Monday evening.
Rather that continuing his success against right-handed hitters, the Cardinals punished Shugart, tagging him for four runs before he exited without recording a single out. Each of the six batters he faced reached base, the final five doing so via base hit. By the time his outing was over, so too was the game.
“Shug's been good for us,” Shelton said. “Just didn't have it tonight."
‘We didn't capitalize’
Even after falling behind, the Pirates had chances to claw their way back into the ballgame. Twice in the final three innings of play, the Pirates had the tying run at the plate. In both instances, they failed to capitalize.
The first opportunity came in the top of the seventh.
Tommy Pham got the ball rolling by reaching on an error with one out and Jared Triolo followed with a walk. With two runners on and Oneil Cruz and Reynolds due up, the Pirates couldn’t ask for much better of a chance. But the team’s top two hitters were both retired to end the frame.
A similar opportunity surfaced again the top of the ninth.
Frazier led off the frame with a single. Cruz followed later on with a hit of his own and then scurried over to second base the next at-bat on a defensive indifference. With two runners in scoring position and two outs, Reynolds nearly tied the game with one swing. But his well hit ball down the right field line hooked foul. After watching the next two pitches bounce in the dirt, Helsley froze Reynolds with a 101.9 mph fastball located knee-high over the middle of the plate to end the game.
"It's challenging,” Shelton said. “We had a couple opportunities at the bottom of the order too that we didn't capitalize on. Like we talked about in the pregame, we have to capitalize on those opportunities to win."






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.