LOS ANGELES — The Pirates lost 8-4 to the Dodgers at Dodger Stadium on Saturday night. Dodgers reliever Kirby Yates got the win, improving to 2-1, while reliever Colin Holderman took the loss, dropping to 1-2.

There were two clear parts of the game: the first seven innings, where the Pirates matched the Dodgers and gave themselves a chance to win; and the eighth inning, where manager Derek Shelton turned to Holderman, just returning from a rehab assignment, and lefty Joey Wentz, who hadn’t pitched in six days.

Teoscar Hernandez led off with a solo homer off Holderman, followed by a double and a walk, before pinch-hitter Kiké Hernandez scored them all with a 3-run shot off Wentz. The four-batter stretch cost the Pirates the game.

The first seven innings were even, with Mitch Keller allowing three runs, two earned, in six innings and center fielder Oneil Cruz accounting for three on his own with a leadoff homer and a two-run single. There was plenty of good in those innings.

Advertise with us

A full recap of the game can be found here. Below are three of the Post-Gazette’s takeaways from the contest.

The decision to throw Holderman

Shelton explained his decision to use Holderman by pointing at unavailable relievers.

“We had a right lane,” Shelton said, referring to the first three batters of the inning: right-handed hitter Teoscar Hernandez, switch-hitter Tommy Edman and right-handed hitter Will Smith. “[Dennis] Santana was down today. [David] Bednar has been in three of four. We're in a situation where we thought we had the lane we liked, and we didn't execute pitches.”

Using a right-handed reliever in that inning makes sense. Hernandez and Edman are both better against lefties, while Smith has near-equal splits against lefties and righties. The decision to use Holderman doesn’t.

Both Santana and Bednar threw Friday. Both had thrown in three of four games, resting Thursday. Neither threw too many on Friday — Bednar threw 15 pitches, while Santana threw 11. On paper, at least one should have been available, and even if neither was, right-handers Chase Shugart and Kyle Nicolas have both statistically been better than Holderman lately.

Advertise with us

Bednar was even seen warming up in the bullpen on Saturday, getting warm to go in in the eighth inning. When the gates opened, it was Holderman who ran out.

“It's just a decision by me,” Shelton said of the decision to not use Bednar. “There was different decisions made depending on what the score was.”

Shelton pointed to the fact that Holderman has pitched in high-leverage situations before, saying, “We just didn’t get it done.” But when Holderman has been in those situations earlier this season, appearing in the final third four times in the opening Florida road trip, he blew two saves and allowed a run in the third.

Not only has Holderman struggled this season, but Shelton put him into a tied game in the eighth inning in front of 54,000 fans against the defending World Series champions. Holderman was returning from a rehab assignment and pitched in front of less than 5,000 fans in St. Paul, Minn., on Tuesday. You would think Shelton would try to set him up for success, given that Holderman’s confidence is shaky and that the Pirates could really use Holderman at his best.

Instead, Shelton threw him into the deep end.

Advertise with us

“Sometimes you can't [ease someone in] with who you have available,” Shelton said. “If you do it in a vacuum and look at everybody how it is, you can live in that world. But when you have certain people available, you have to make decisions.”

Holderman, for his part, owned that he had a bad outing Saturday. He said he got caught up in the emotions of coming back and “let the moment get the best of me.”

“I appreciate the trust from the coaching staff putting me out there first thing, and I’ll be better, I need to be better,” Holderman said. “The fans, the organization, my teammates, they deserve better, so that’s what we’re going to get moving forward.”

Other negatives

There really was a lot of good that happened in Saturday’s game. That’ll be the third takeaway. A loss like Saturday’s tends to magnify the negative.

The Pirates cost themselves a run in the first inning. With a runner on second and two outs in a 1-1 ballgame, Keller got Edman to hit a weak grounder to second baseman Adam Frazier. Frazier rushed his throw and pulled it past first baseman Enmanuel Valdez, allowing Teoscar Hernandez to advance from third to home when the ball went out of play.

Advertise with us

They might have cost themselves another in the second. With runners on first and third and one out, left fielder Tommy Pham hit a shallow fly ball to Teoscar Hernandez in right field. Catcher Joey Bart tried to score from third base and was thrown out easily. It was unclear if Bart went on his own or if he was sent by third base coach Mike Rabelo, and Shelton wasn’t sure, either.

“I don't know on that,” Shelton said. “I don't know what happened. I mean, Teoscar made a really good play. He was running in and made a throw on the run and got us.”

Proof of the positives

Here’s a bullet-pointed list of positive things that happened Saturday that very well could have been the story of the game:

• The Pirates battled with the Dodgers for seven innings despite the gap in the standings, payroll, experience, and the number of MVP awards on the roster (six, won by four players, against one).

• Cruz went 2 for 4, including a home run on the first pitch of the game. It’s his fourth leadoff homer of the month and eighth homer of the season. Having him as a leadoff hitter has brought the Pirates offense out of its slump.

Advertise with us

• The Pirates hit a good pitcher well. They had never seen Dodgers rookie Roki Sasaki, who throws a fastball with good velocity and a devastating splitter, but they made solid contact for five hits and three runs in 5 2/3 innings. Even the outs were hit hard, including a near-homer from Bryan Reynolds that was robbed at the wall.

• The bottom four hitters of the lineup (Ke’Bryan Hayes, Pham, Frazier and Isiah Kiner-Falefa) went 6 for 14 with a walk, scoring three of the Pirates’ four runs.

• Pham reached base three times. His double in the fifth inning was the milestone 1,000th of his major league career.

• Keller worked a Houdini act, stranding runners on second and third in the second inning by striking out Shohei Ohtani and getting Mookie Betts out. He picked the right times for his six strikeouts and at one point retired nine hitters in a row. He pitched well, allowing just two earned runs.

• The infield defense, after the Frazier error, was really good. Frazier had a good stop on a grounder in the third, Hayes made a tough play look easy in the fourth, Kiner-Falefa made a Willie Mays-esque basket catch in the outfield on a blooper, and defensive replacement Jared Triolo made a crucial 3-6 double play to get out of a jam in the seventh.

Advertise with us

• Even against a tough opponent, the Pirates were in position for a fourth win in five games and a series victory.

Shelton’s decisions didn’t all work out on Saturday, but he nailed his overall summary of the game.

“We need to win,” Shelton said. “We played good for seven innings, but we didn't play well enough to win.”